Rebbitzen Goldenpickanicerscreenname

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 50 posts - 751 through 800 (of 914 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • Sometimes husbands adopt their wives minhagim. Period.

    Yaakov was punished for preventing a shidduch between his daughter Dina and Esov…I am sure they weren`t on the same page in hashkofos…

    lacisr, this is the version of story as said by Rav Frand:
    On a regular basis, Rabbi Pessach Diskind, grandson of Reb Yaakov Kaminetsky, tells me stories, practices, and opinions from his grandfather, Reb Yaakov.

    One Shabbos morning when Rabbi Diskin was a guest of his grandfather, he noticed that after Kiddush, Reb Yaakov’s Rebbetzin served cake to Reb Yaakov and he made a borei minei mezonos. Afterwards, they went to wash for the meal.

    Rabbi Diskin knew that his grandfather was not a chossid. He was, in fact, a dyed-in-the-wool Litvak. Rabbi Diskin asked his grandfather from where he picked up the custom to have mezonos after Kiddush. Reb Yaakov explained the origin of this custom to his grandson. Rav Yaakov, who had lost his first wife, was now married to his “zivug sheni” (his second wife). Reb Yaakov’s second wife came from Chassidic background. Both her father and her first husband were from Chassidic backgrounds. She was accustomed to having mezonos with Shabbos morning Kiddush. If he would not have mezonos after Kiddush, she would feel something was lacking in the Kiddush.

    Rav Yaakov Kaminetsky was 70 years old when he married his second wife. That means that for 50 years he made Kiddush in the morning without mezonos.

    How many of us would change after doing something for fifty years, and for what? “Because with my wife, this is how Kiddush is made”.

    Rav Yaakov Kamenetsky changed. To Reb Yaakov, it was worth changing a 50-year-old practice for Shalom Bayis — for the feelings of his wife. This is an insightful lesson for all of us.

    in reply to: Can golus end but the geulah still did not arrive? #1691897

    For someone to say, “That’s a false attribution to the Chazon Ish.” he needs to believe he knows every single thing the Chazon Ish ever said. Only then can one say these words were never said by the Chazon Ish and the one who claims they were said, is mistaken or making it up. (In halachic terms it is called לא ראינו אינה ראייה ). A big claim, but like a balloon, filled with hot air.

    Rav JB Soleveitchik and Rav Shach are undisputed gedolim and poskim.

    Takah, $100K is a bargain. The going rate is $250K plus. The girl’s parents are willing to give “full support” but it isn’t really necessary because the girl makes a great salary as an actuary.

    Mrs Joseph “I challenge you to name one or two of the allegedly “many great bnei Torah (and even gedolim) of previous generations had wives that did not cover their hair.”

    In reply to your challenge (and to discredit you), I named two well known giants of gedolim ztl (from both ends of the spectrum) – with sources, that their wives did not cover their hair (at least not till much later in their lives). I also cited a godel that when asked replied that “yesh al mi lismoch” and others…but I guess the Mods didn’t want it posted.

    If you do your homework, you will find it.

    in reply to: Can golus end but the geulah still did not arrive? #1691783

    I expected to hear from the Chabad “experts” on geula and moshiach…guess they are too busy doing what they do best – kiruv and taking care of our Jewish needs in far off places.

    Mrs Joseph – “I challenge you to name one or two of the allegedly “many great bnei Torah (and even gedolim) of previous generations had wives that did not cover their hair.

    Do a bit of homework and you will be astounded to discover some of the most well-lnown gedolim and poskim zal wives did not cover their hair (at least not till much later). It is documented (in pictures) and mesorah among those in the know.

    Besides that one known godol of last generation when asked, replies “yesh al mi lismoch”, the Aruch HaShulchan lamented that it was common in his time, too. The Ben Ish Chai comments on it too.

    Just do a bit of homework so there is no need to name names in public.

    in reply to: Can golus end but the geulah still did not arrive? #1691752

    DY “I don’t wait until the end to drink.”, so when you are at the end of the bottle, there is still 1/4 of a bottle left.

    The story printed in the official biography is that he continued to eat her entire life, gebrokts till after her petirah.

    in reply to: Can golus end but the geulah still did not arrive? #1691740

    Mrs Joseph “You can trust any kosher keeping Jew for kashrus”, that is how it all started, when Adom HaRishon trusted his wife on the kashrus of the fruit…
    “You can trust…but not for psak” – he is THE possek on inyonei kashrus for the OU – it is his PSAK that they use, so you are saying, you don’t trust his psakim, which means you don’t trust the hechsher of OU.
    Start living on water (if you rely on Rav Belskey’s psak that NYC water is ok).

    in reply to: Can golus end but the geulah still did not arrive? #1691736

    DY, when you get to the conclusion of a book and it says “The End” – does it mean it’s almost at the end? Rav Schachter writes b’shem CHazon Ish: “[we are at] the end of the golus but we have not yet arrived at the geulah”, and you are saying “the end” means it isn’t the end, but almost the end…did you start with the purim spirits a bit early?

    Mrs Joseph – “I challenge you to name one or two of the allegedly “many great bnei Torah (and even gedolim) of previous generations had wives that did not cover their hair.””

    Here is a recent one: “The Rav” – Rabbi JB Soloveitchik’s wife.

    But before you have a melt down, let me educate you:

    It was COMMON that frum women did not cover their hair in previous generations.

    How dare I say that?

    Oh, it’s not me saying it.

    It is the Aruch HaShulchan (75:7)
    עתה בואו ונצווח על פרצות דורינו בעוונותינו הרבים שזה שנים רבות שנפרצו בנות ישראל בעון זה והולכות בגילוי הראש וכל מה שצעקו על זה הוא לא לעזר ולא להועיל ועתה פשתה המספחת שהנשואות הולכות בשערותן כמו הבתולות
    אוי לנו שעלתה בימינו כך

    Mrs Joseph,

    I wrote of the reverse that is common, when the wife does not hold of the eruv (because of upbringing) while the husband freely uses the eruv (and she jokingly calls him her ‘shabbos goy’)..

    However, the common situation that you deny is when the husband is ‘machmir al atzmo’ not to be somech on the eruv but does not impose this chumra on his wife and children.

    Rav Yaakov ztzl personally held not to eat gebrokts but his wife didn’t have that minhag, Gues who followed who’s minhag>? As long as he was amrried to her, Rav Yaakov WOULD eat gebrokts!

    I think that shlogs your ‘period’.

    in reply to: Can golus end but the geulah still did not arrive? #1691689

    Mrs Joseph, If Rav Shachter is not reliable to you, you better stop eating OU products (and all the hechsherim that rely on OU by-products). He is their possek on inyonei kashrus! To me and for most American Jewry, that is as reliable as it gets. But to you, if he is unreliable and suspect – I express my deepest sympathies.

    in reply to: Can golus end but the geulah still did not arrive? #1691694

    DY – “He doesn’t quote the Chazon Ish as saying golus is over.”

    How can you say that? It’s online!

    torahweb dot org slash torah slash 2019 slash parsha slash rsch_pekudei dot html

    Here is a cut n paste from this article:

    True Redemption
    Rav Hershel Schachter

    In 1948, when the medinah was first established, the Chazon Ish had already moved to Eretz Yisroel. He is quoted as having said that the establishment of the medinah this constitutes the end of the golus but we have not yet arrived at the geulah. Some thought that this statement was mere double-talk. I think the Chazon Ish was using the terminology of the Ramban in his introduction to Chumash Shemos.

    in reply to: Can golus end but the geulah still did not arrive? #1691669

    Mrs Joseph – “That’s a false attribution to the Chazon Ish.”

    The renown possek Rabbi Hershel Schechter shlitah quotes it in his divrei Torah on Torahweb dot org, titled: “True Redemption”.

    Frankly, I trust him more than you.

    binny “a women wearing pants is totally unacceptable for a ben torah.”

    There are many homes of bnei Torah that the wife wears the pants in the house – figuratively.

    Many great bnei Torah (and even gedolim) of previous generations had wives that did not cover their hair. It did not stop their learning or their sholom bayis.

    I ask you, is it acceptable for a ben Torah to have a wife that eats cholov akum, uses an eiruv that Reb Moshe says is worthless, has an unfiltered phone (which gedolim in EY made into the worst possible aveira) and speaks loshon hara regularly ?! Yet, many do – and life goes on quite nicely.

    I think you are reacting to the “appearances”…but in today’s world, “image” is secondary.

    in reply to: What should I be when I Grow up?? #1691653

    A YWN Mod (and no need to wait till you grow up).

    in reply to: Can golus end but the geulah still did not arrive? #1691657

    DY, are you arguing with the Chazon Ish or saying a pshat in his words?

    Eiruvin 14b – one that drinks water to satisfy thirst makes a brocha of shehakol. R’ Tarfon says he makes borei nefoshos. Rav Chanon asked Abaya, what is the halachs? He answered, puk chazi my ama dbar – go see what people are doing.

    Seeing what others do ESTABLISHES the halacha. Guess what? That is exactly why today we make a bracha of shehakol when we drink water!

    In fact, there is even a principle that minhag of yidden (what ‘everyone’ is doing) is actually MEVATEL halacha.

    wasnt me, – “The majority of MO who refuse to do it don’t do so out of a Halachic argument rather out of precedent- they know there were some very distinguishable people whose wives didn’t cover their hair. ”

    Is that not the same with those that use cholov akum – how many actually researched the issue (or even looked up Reb Moshe’s teshuva) before they decided that they can be maykil?

    How many learned the halochos of eruv in a metropolitan and examined the eruv of their city before deciding that they can use this eruv?!

    Get real: we ALL rely on precedent!

    You eat in an eatery without checking if the hechsher is up to date and confirming with kashrus org because you see other frum people buying their pizza there.

    In halacha this is an accepted rule: check what other people are doing!

    Marriage does not require a match that is a carbon copy of each other.

    In fact, some say ‘opposites attract’.

    Husband makpid on cholov yisroel, wife isn’t.

    Is that a recipe for disaster?! You may ask, how will they raise the kids?! Answer: They will work it out.

    Wife doesn’t hold of eiruv, husband does.

    Is that a recipe for disaster?! You may ask, how will they raise the kids?! Answer: They will work it out.

    He has unfiltered internet smartphone, she has kosher phone.

    Are those so different than this case:
    Husband wears black hat, wife wears pants?

    funnybone: “Rebbetzin: how Yeshivish is he if he “observed her…and expressed admiration”? Not”

    A bochur does not need to sit at the table wearing blinders and his nose deep in a sefer. Get real! He observed her middos – helping out at the table, taking care of my children, joining in the conversation with wisdom and aidelkeit…She heard his divrei Torah, that he wasn’t self-absorbed, humor and worldly knowledge…

    Is that ‘unacceptable’?!

    I can just picture ‘your’ comical illustration of a yeshivish Lakewood bochur sitting at a shabbos table that includes a girl at shidduchim age:

    Stuff his ears with cotton balls, blinders on his eyes to block peripheral vision, a full size Vilna shas gemara within 6 inches of his face while slurping the chicken soup…

    is that normal or comical?!

    Zion, I think Rav Chaim K shlita answered something to that effect when okayed shidduch that a brother was otd.

    Mrs. Joseph, many “eitza tova” of chazal are no longer applicable, example the home remedies for ailments, many (but not all) “sakana” advice…what is applicable to us is brought in halacha. Checking the brothers is NOT brought in halacha.

    Chazal say ‘check her brothers’. Rav Chaim K shlita was asked, what does one ‘check’ the brothers for? He answered check if they are normal. When further pressed, what does ‘normal’ mean? he answered, that they learn Torah.

    in reply to: What should I be when I Grow up?? #1691547

    If male – godol hador.
    If female – ezer kinegdo.
    If none of the above – phycologist.

    Shopping – “If one parent allows them to wear pants and another doesn’t?
    Like how does that work. ”

    Precedent from Moshe Rabbeinu: He pre-agreed with Yisro – One chld for Hashem and one child for avoda zara. They can agree too that sll girls go to MO schools and all boys go to chareidi yeshivot.

    Joe, the Gemara says (Baba Basra 110a): ‘hanosay isha tzorich she’yivdok b’achiha’, there is no machlokes about it, yet it is not brought down as a halacha – not in Rambam or Tur or Shulchan Oruch?!

    Answers in SHU”T Maharam Brisk s. 130 – the gemorah is not saying a halacha but an eitza tova (shidduch advice).

    Therefore, even though the Avos kept the entire Torah including all halochos, this was never a halacha, and the Avos didn’t need to follow it.

    in reply to: Why Should I Pay for your Limo #1691413

    “I have never been asked to chip in.”
    “I have been to many weddings and never once seen or heard of such a thing.”
    “that makes two of us.”
    Only the chosson’s friends!
    Sorry to say, the chosson doesn’t consider you among his friends.

    Joe, as long as one brother is ok, that’s good enough – psak of Chazon Ish (Sefer Ma’aseh Ish, chelek 3, pg 237). But in any event, Yitzchok did not reject the shidduch on account of Rivka’s bother Lovon! Therefore, it is only one factor of many.

    I made a shidduch that the wife would never use the eiruv on shabbos (she holds it is mamash chillul shabbos), but the husband does. She jokingly calls him her shabbos goy. They have a great marriage.

    (I wonder if she would drink non-mevushal wine that her husband poured – since in her view he is a mechallel shabbos b’farhesya??).

    in reply to: Why Should I Pay for your Limo #1691367

    Some hold that the unlimited speeches at sheva brochos is like breaking the glass at the chupah – a bit of availus zecher l’churbon.

    Not required to change if that was their agreement. No one is trying to change anyone. There is so much commonality that this differential is minimal in the big picture of a happy marriage and building a home.

    I have set up couples where the girl used cholov akum and the boy was makpid on cholov yisroel. They are happily married. She still eats her Hershy’s chocolate and he doesn’t. It’s not that big of a deal.

    She doesn’t ONLY wear pants. She can wear skirts and dresses when around his chaverim or chevra. Aside from their upbringing, they are perfect for each other,

    in reply to: Why Should I Pay for your Limo #1691259

    Akup, guess what – you can start tying everything to goyish customs: the wedding gown – goyish brides wear them, so let’s nix it. The wedding music – mamash goyish (even a question if music is muttar after the churban!). The photograper – oy, is that halacha l’moshe mi’sinai? We can make it all goyish and alien to our traditions, but then what? DO you know if traditionally – before the automobile, the chosson kallah did not leave weddings in a horse drawn carriage?

    in reply to: Why Should I Pay for your Limo #1691204

    Dad of Zahava, “What better way to start a new life than drive your new Kallah home” – a chosson is technically pottur from kriyas shema because he is so distracted. Do you want this distracted driver driving on the road – and with his kallah, no less?

    in reply to: Why Should I Pay for your Limo #1691195

    Akup, Excuse me, but since when is “two ring ceremonies” or “bachelor parties contrary to halacha?? We actually do them, BUT in a kosher yiddisheh way! IT has long been a Jewish custom to have a “bachelor” AND “bachelorette” party, except we call it “Shabbos Ofruf” an “Shabbos Kallah”! It is also a custom among many that the Kallah and Chosson exchange gifts in the yichud room. And indeed, we DO have a “honeymoon” – seven days of simcha with friends and relatives showering us with sheva brochos and unlimited speeches. We do all this our way, and l’havdil, the goyim do it their way.

    in reply to: Foods to give for MM #1691184

    The mishloach monos of fried locusts got mixed up with the rov’s mishloach monos of fried gribben, and that became my best purim-horor story. – not for anyone with a weak stomach, after reaching ‘ad dlo yada’ it is a great story.

    in reply to: Foods to give for MM #1691168

    For my friends from Teiman – a basket of deep fried locusts.

    (I already commented about the issue of giving food that one would not eat themselves due to kashrus – but the pool is open if anyone wants to jump in, of course separate hours for men)

    in reply to: Why Should I Pay for your Limo #1691154

    A melech and a malka should be driven in style.

    Is it lip service to say chosson domeh l’melech?

    A levayeh is stopped to allow the chosson-kallah entourage to pass!

    You think the chosson should drive the kallak himself in the beat up family-car?!

    A melech and a malka gets chauffeured in a limo!

    That’s poshut!

    And while we are at it – rabbonim are also called melochim (‘maan malka – rabbonon), so every rov and rosh yeshiva should be driven in a limo like royalty, but in this WE lack the acceptance of rabbonon as melochim. That’s OUR chisoron, and the rabbonim don’t expect too much of us, so they are mochel. [Not sure about din of ‘melech she’mochal al kivodo’ if it applies to rabbonim or chassanim].

    For a moment I thought you were talking about the limos for the bochurim collecting on purim getting driven around in a limo. Now THAT is another whole ball of bees wax.

    But that is v’na’hapoch hu – the bochurim are chauffeured in limos while the rosh yeshiva drives around in a jalopy.

    in reply to: Foods to ban from MM #1690689

    So…you are saying that a Vegan can’t give cold cuts, chicken or meat,,,or a recovering alcoholic can’t give you a 15year scotch “because it gives the impression that you’re just offloading your garbage onto the recipient”? Wow, I did not know that. As a Vegan I will make sure to send you only s celery and carrot stick.

    in reply to: Foods to ban from MM #1690708

    There is a Yiddish saying: one man’s trash is another man’s treasure. The chassidish way it goes: one man’s trash is another man’s ungarbage. But us Litvish say: one man’s trash is another man’s shalach manos. I think in Chabad they say: one man’s Rebbe is another man’s Moshiach. But for all girls in shidduchim, we wish them to easily find their one man without going through too much garbage.

    in reply to: Foods to ban from MM #1690627

    Reb Yid, you certainly CAN give foods that don’t suit your kashrus standards IF you consider it only a CHUMRA (like some are machmir to only use ‘chassidish hechsher’ and won’t use OU but CAN give it to others who do. HOWVER, if you hold that a certain hechsher is OSSUR – like Triangle K (or if you hold Cholov Akum in USA is Ossur), then you CAN’T give this issur to someone, even if they do use it.

    in reply to: Shaloch Manos for Rebbeim is very chaotic #1689624

    In every jest there is a grain of truth. Rabbayim not getting paid on time makes them aniyim, and an oni is choshuv k’mess, so when schools don’t pay the rebbe, they give the students a chance to do chessed shel emess. Missing the flueshot for the anti vaxers is the same as overdosing on tangy taffy (purple flavored – zecher l’yayin, although not chamar medina, it has become ochel hamedina). But how does one say tangy taffy in yiddish – with an oy or an ay? TheGeulah is coming and soon Tishbi will answer all are kashas.

    in reply to: Shaloch Manos for Rebbeim is very chaotic #1689601

    Someone’s gotta be the cheftza shel mitzva,but depends if they wear white shirts and the dialect of their Yinglish. Not everyone has the zchus to be mezakeh ess harabbim.

    in reply to: Shaloch Manos for Rebbeim is very chaotic #1689565

    R’ Yid, In Ailu Dvorim, right after bikur cholim which makes a yid into a cheftza shel mitzvah, comes hachnosas kallah which is the solution to the shidduch crisis!, followed by halvayas haMes – chesed shel emes…so the outcome of missing the flue shot, is not just bikur cholim but could also give the students tremendous opportunity to do a chesed shel emes.

    in reply to: Shaloch Manos for Rebbeim is very chaotic #1689480

    Your kids need to do shlach monos. They want to give their Rebbe the monos. Therefore, the Rebbe must cater to their needs and desires. Makes sense. After all he is a public servant. He should attend the yeshiva on Purim and sit there with all the other educational servants awaiting the appearance of the gift bearers. He will graciously thank each one for the zazas, laffy taffy and bissli – telling each one how thoughtful it was of them to give him nash. If it is a terrible imposition on the Rebbe (and his family) – well, that`s mesirus nefesh, dedication!

    I wrote in another thread re: bikkor cholim, that the choleh is the cheftza shel mitzvah, and like the lulov he can be shaken up when rsting, to enable the visitor to do his mitzvah. The Rebbe too is required to complete the mitzva of shlach monos, so shake him like a lulov, bang him like an aravah, because your child need to do the mitzvah of shlach monos to the Rebbe!

    Although the Rebbe appreciates some items in the shlach monos – liquoréwine, chocolate etc. and the well wishes behind the gifts, I think most Rebbes, given the choice between raisins and a juice box or money, would be MUCH happier to get a check as Maos Purim, mailed to them in advance of Purim.

    Smarten up, people. Treat the Rebbe no worse tha you would want to be treated. Would you want to be in your office on Purim so that all employees or co-workers will be able to give you shlach monos (without the inconvenience of running around to your home)É!

    So here is a progressive idea– why impose on everyone to run around the neighborhood causing traffic jams etc. Lets make a TAKANA (yep, I LOVE TAKONAS to solve all of lifes troubles): Mishloach Monos MUST only be given in shul, immediately after megilah!

    This is genious! No traffic, triple parking, ringing bells with no one home,…this Moray V`Rabbosei and Rebbitzens is a brilliant TAKANA..

    You might ask, what if the recepient davens in another shul? Good kasha! We solve it with takana #2 – all must daven in the same shul.

    I think this will also help solve the shidduch crisis , and maybe also the tuition crisis, and maybe even bring the Geula…as long as everyone wears white shirts and speaks Yinglish.

    in reply to: Is Yiddish Holy? #1687783

    There is only one Loshon HaKodesh and that is …(drum roll)…Loshon Hakodesh!

    Everything else is Loshon CHOL.

Viewing 50 posts - 751 through 800 (of 914 total)