Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
GadolhadorahParticipant
All too often, we read here about yidden in some town or suburb opposing a zoning variance for some shul, yeshiva or other mosdos and immediately he/she is tagged as a “self-hating” jew. In most cases, its a NIMBY thing and has nothing to do with anti-semitism. There are many legitimate reasons why an erhliche yid would oppose such a variance just as there are many BAD reasons why both a yid or goy would seek to block such a variance. Its fact specific and very naive to assume ANY opposition to a non-conforming use is rooted in bias and anti-semitism.
GadolhadorahParticipantZoning laws and other regulations governing allowable land uses protect both individual homeowners as well as various mosdos in their locational and investment decisions, unless they are misused for the purpose of discrimination. Would a shul that properly followed the zoning rules to build its facility in an area zoned for institutional use be happy if a huge industrial shlachthois or a “gentlemen’s club” obtained a variance to build nextdoor?? Likewise, if I purchased a home on a residential street zoned exclusively for single family properties, why would I be happy if some rav decided my neighborhood needed another shtieblach next door and held daily minyanim with parking issues, noise, etc. Local governments are limited in their ability to deny variances for such uses unless they can show serious health and safety issues.
GadolhadorahParticipantSeveral NYS camps have leased camp facilities at locations in Pennsylvania, New Hampshire etc. and there are a few “orthodox” camps in Florida and California. You can find these options by searching on the internet. Otherwise, plan local activities for the summer. Most of the major museums will be re-opening later in July (Met Museum of Art later in August). Check first since some are requiring time-window reservations to spread out the attendance. Most parks in the city and within short driving distance from the City are also open or reopening in the next several weeks although some will have limited activities, again to limit large gatherings. In any event, these will be only partial substitutes for harried moms who already have been caring for the kids at home for 3 months.
GadolhadorahParticipantThe FERC has already initiated requirements through NERC to harden the bulk power system against a wide range of EMP events, natural and weaponized. Not sure what scale of attack you are contemplating.
GadolhadorahParticipantSyag: Sarcasm, trolling, and bad jokes are all prima facie evidence of systemic anti-semitism by CR posters. Clearly, yeshivos shouldn;t be concerned with “misspellings” (is that how it is spellled??
P.S. I thought Webster’s partner in that dictionary deal was named Chanalah, not “miriam”.
”GadolhadorahParticipantThe cost of land (NIS/sq.meter) can vary by 200x or 300x depending on where you are located. A dunam of land in downtown Tel Aviv, 110 meters of sea-front property or a prime residential block in Yerushalayim will obviously cost a multiple of several hundred dunams in the middle of the Negev. Perhaps you could clarify what type of land you are considering purchasing, for what purpose and the general location.
GadolhadorahParticipant” If the chasisdim shvitz like the rebbe (I did not make up the term) with fur hats in the summer why should the rest of us be uncomfortable too? ”
CT Rebbe: A very deep and thought provoking question. Perhaps the answer is that they DON’T shivtz and when worn by a true tzadik, Shtreimlach actually have a cooling effect. Perhaps all the misnagdim have been missing the point all along.
GadolhadorahParticipantLowerTuition: Are you aware of any chassidus that changes over its shtreimlach in the summer to reflect the hotter temperatures? Why do the Litvish feel the need for a seasonal change?
GadolhadorahParticipantNew York’s demise has been predicted on multiple occasions, only to see it rebound. Each time they say “its over” but I have no reason to believe it will be much different this time around. New York will be back in a year or two (likely with new political leadership) but sadly neither the Knicks or the Mets seem to have much a future.
GadolhadorahParticipantI don’t think the few remaining seasonal rentals in Sullivan County are treated any differently than other seasonal rentals in NYS. Same rules govern depending on the “Phase” restrictions. Most owner-occupied clusters of summer homes are already seeing arrivals from the city.
GadolhadorahParticipantChazal bring down that we will not need to quarantine for 14 days when arriving in EY for the geulah when Moishiach comes. However, there is a disagreement as to whether face mask rules will apply on the flight over. I also noticed that the OP included the caveat that “we are VERY LIKELY the generation that POSSIBLY ” will greet Moishiach etc. Thus, while not questioning Reb Yosef’s decision to pack his bags I would strongly suggest CR readers consider purchasing a REFUNDABLE fare.
June 22, 2020 9:40 am at 9:40 am in reply to: If N.Y. doesn’t allow summer camps to open, what’s your plan? #1875055GadolhadorahParticipant“Stay at home moms” includes many moms who work from home OR work in part-time jobs. Very few kollel families have the family support for the husband to be a full-time learner and the wife to simply sit at home taking care of the kids. Nor do welfare payments come even close to providing sufficient support for larger families. Unless they are printing money in the basement, someone in the family is working. The good news is that a small but growing percentage of kollel yungerleit are finding ways to earn a parnassah while learning and some yeshivos are allowing for such work/learn arrangements.
GadolhadorahParticipantAfter scanning a random set of videos from the protests I’d guess that somewhere between 1/3 and 1/2 of the participants on average were wearing masks. Also, they were OUTDOORS and a lot of them were trying to stay at some distance from others. Last night in Tulsa, INDOORS, about 10 percent were wearing masks and sgitting on top of one another (although based on the low turnout they could have left every other seat empty)
GadolhadorahParticipantDoes anyone recalling seeing photos of rabbonim in the Alte Heim wearing a straw hat or is that more of a relatively moderneshe minhag here??
June 21, 2020 9:46 pm at 9:46 pm in reply to: If N.Y. doesn’t allow summer camps to open, what’s your plan? #1874958GadolhadorahParticipantCommon Saychel: Years from now, your kids will look back and really appreciate the opportunity you provided them to travel and see parts of our great country they learn about in school and perhaps see on TV. They are fortunate because I suspect many frum families don’t have the time, resources or motivation to pursue this type of summer vacation.
GadolhadorahParticipantThe comments above from LittleIKnow provide a common sense approach for a ben torah that either chooses or is economically compelled to leave the Heimeshe “bubble” and participate in the broader economic and social aspects of a secular world that has increasingly “normalized” LGBT relationships and lifestyles. One can interact with them in a respectful manner as with any other work colleague or stranger, without “encouraging, endorsing, or supporting their “to’eivoh”.
June 19, 2020 1:54 pm at 1:54 pm in reply to: Lost Talis and Tefilin in Maimonides Hospital #1874455GadolhadorahParticipantNot to minimize the loss of Tallis/Tefillin, which I hope are found and returned to him, these days its encouraging to read about a case where an older yid is admitted to the hospital and B’H is released the next day.
June 19, 2020 8:22 am at 8:22 am in reply to: The “New Normal” for Shul During the Yamim Noraim #1874300GadolhadorahParticipantIn general, the larger hospitals have access to greater resources, deal with a wider range of cases and attract the more experienced medical professionals than smaller local hospitals who generally transfer their more complex and critical cases to large facilities with the needed expertise. An exception to this general rules are public charity hospitals, many of which are “larger”: but severely underfunded and do not attract top of the line medical professionals.
GadolhadorahParticipantWhen asked in a recent Fox interview why he didn’t take steps on January 21, 2017 to replenish the “empty cupboards”, The Trumpkof replied that he was too busy busy keeping out Muslims, writing love letters to North Korean President Kim-Jung-Un and most importantly, spending 133 days during my first 3 years as President playing golf at Trump properties, not to even mention the personal stress from the Russia Hoas.
GadolhadorahParticipantFrumshmurda: You neglected to report that Fox News also showed pictures of Martians landing in Willy and BP were seen wearing masks, so they are taking the viral risks seriously. Geez…..where do you guys dig up this garbage??
June 17, 2020 5:26 pm at 5:26 pm in reply to: aritficial intelligance bio-cameras for domestic security. #1873722GadolhadorahParticipantEcho: Not sure if you are serious or trolling but if the former, you might aliyah to the PRC since the government is in the process of installing the world’s most advanced and intrusive camera/video monitoring technology with an AI capability of tracking a billion souls 24×7 and providing instantaneous locational information on problematic individuals. A new version of 1984 in 2020.
GadolhadorahParticipantYehudalah: Higgins is a relatively ignorant former Deputy Sheriff from a state with one of the highest death rates from CV19 who even before the virus, had characterized public health restrictions as an “infringement” on personal liberty. He goes out of his way to blend right wing Christian Evangelical cultural themes with Trumpkopf-style science denial on matters that even most Republicans accept as fact. Wearing a mask doesn’t fully protect others near you from infection (if you are asymptomatic) but it certainly reduces transmission. Likewise, it slightly reduces your own risk of being infected by droplets exhaled from others nearby.
GadolhadorahParticipant“when I was a child going to the airport to watch the planes take off and land”
Perhaps going to the Home Depot to watch their demonstrations of how to tile your shower in the Post-Corona era or if you are up in the Mountains for the Summer,
edited. Is it really that difficult to write a post without adding a smear of the frum community? I did notice you refrained over the last few months, sorry to see it’s revival -29
Otherwise, the outdoor tables at Tavern on the Green and several other city parks provide a nice place for a drink with the benefits of an outside venue.
“GadolhadorahParticipantI generally find that frum families are aware of the need to pick up after themselves in park settings. The few times I’ve seen flagrant disregard for leaving trash behind/ littering are in the context of large families with very young children who likely are NOT regular park visitors (outside of local city parks) and are just overwhelmed with keeping track of the kids, etc. Most respond positively (and with some embarrassment) when someone points out the mess they were about to leave behind. I don’t think its a cultural disregard for nature or an arrogance that since they don’t plan to be back the next day or week, “who cares”. I do wish more yeshivos would find some opportunity to encourage environmental awareness and personal responsibility in the daily lives of their talmidim to be good stewards of (in the words of the OP) “the beautiful nature of Hashem”.
GadolhadorahParticipantDon’t underestimate how Gorsuch’s opinion, aside from his obvious effort to demonstrate “consistency” in his textual approach to legal interpretation, will also help tee up a future effort to further narrow so-called
Chevron deference”, in terms of how the Courts defer to agency interpretations of statute based on their assumed subject matter “expertise”, where the statute fails to provide detailed guidance on implementation.GadolhadorahParticipantThe Health Commissioner of the City of Tulsa says that the Trumpkopf should NOT hold the rally next weekend but he has no legal authority to stop it since the State has “reopened” to everything with no restrictions. The insanity of having thousands of screaming Trumpkopfers sitting on top of one another with no masks will likely trigger some spikes in the City’s rate of infections but no problem…..they will all have signed a risk waiver so they cannot sue anyone. Perhaps the only positive outcome might be a substantial surge in the infection rate in Tulsa over the next 2 weeks that might result in restrictions on future rallies. I found it laughable that Trump required a NEGATIVE virus test for those attending $250,000/person fundraiser at his NJ golf club last night but no requirements for the poor shleps rally in Tulsa with him next weekend.
June 13, 2020 10:09 pm at 10:09 pm in reply to: If N.Y. doesn’t allow summer camps to open, what’s your plan? #1871742GadolhadorahParticipantParents should be focused on how their kids’ schools are preparing for reopening this fall, both in terms of adopting the needed safety protocols recommended by the CDC and how the kids will make up for 3 months of lost in-class instruction. Do the schools start with the lesson plans where they left off in March or do they begin the new school year with the new grade lesson plans as if the kids were able to pick up all the “missed” instruction either through zoom classes, home-schooling etc? `
June 11, 2020 8:33 pm at 8:33 pm in reply to: The “New Normal” for Shul During the Yamim Noraim #1870791GadolhadorahParticipantCommonlackofsaychel: Most of the Arronites in Monsey are born with Covid19 antibodies (as distinct from the Zalmanites who generally test negative for the antibody) and are thus immune. Those who don’t have the antibody are doing their nagel vasser with a cocktail mix of HCQ with Zinc (as recommended by the Trump’s favorite doctor who recently announced he was leaving Monsey for greener pastures).
GadolhadorahParticipantThe reality is that he looking for some way to leave office 18 months early without seeming to be slinking away with a well-deserved reputation as the greatest loser in NY political history. I checked the NYC code and State constitution and did not find any provision providing for removal of a mayor from office in the same manner as the 25th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution provides for removal of POTUS for physical or mental incapacitation. Fortunately, the late night talk show hosts will have him around to ridicule until 2022.
June 11, 2020 12:21 pm at 12:21 pm in reply to: The “New Normal” for Shul During the Yamim Noraim #1870425GadolhadorahParticipantA local shul seems to have anticipated the issue and will be holding an SDM (social distanced minyan) in the gym of a local private school. Some shuls have done this previously for overflow/non-members but I think you will see more of these types of arrangements this fall in school auditoriums and other public spaces that can be leased and are appropriate for davening.
June 10, 2020 11:44 pm at 11:44 pm in reply to: The “New Normal” for Shul During the Yamim Noraim #1870232GadolhadorahParticipantThough data are VERY limited, the vast majority of “older” individuals who have taken the antibody test do NOT appear to have have been infected by the virus without symptoms and thus rightfully should be concerned about future exposure (whether through davening in crowded shuls or any other venue where social distancing is not feasible). Again, its going to be very case-specific but maybe some of the larger shuls can block off seating for older daveners where perhaps every other seat is empty. A 5:30 AM “golden age/vasikim” minyan for rosh hashanah/yom kippur is not ideal but may be the only option in smaller shuls.
GadolhadorahParticipantAs a matter of common courtesy and separate from the question of whether its a matter of “lchatchilah” versus “bdieved”, if one is aware that w/o his participation there is no longer a minyan, one should daven at a pace consistent with the other daveners, even if its a bit faster than his usual cadence. Likewise, I don’t recall ever seeing our chazan/shaliach tzibur (or gabbai who sometimes serves as a surrogate) , look towards the varbeshe section of the shul to be certain that most of the women daveners have completed the Amidah.
June 8, 2020 1:00 pm at 1:00 pm in reply to: If N.Y. doesn’t allow summer camps to open, what’s your plan? #1869183GadolhadorahParticipantSyag: As I said, everyone has their own risk assessment metrics. In this cases, mine are quite different from yours. You are obviously free to expose yourself and your kids to whatever risk factors (or lack thereof) your personal circumstances warrant and I wish you well.
Uncommonsaychel: You must have real nevius. That would be exactly my plan but for a government travel ban which currently restricts entry to virtually all foreign travelers other than Australia. Hopefully, they will expand their “bubble” sometime later this summer. They seem to have a bit more seychel over there regarding social distancing, masks, etc. than the lunatics lined up on top of one another on erev shabbos last week in Las Vegas with no masks to grab a place at a slot machine. I was even impressed by their demonstration in support of the BLM movement in downtown Auckland where for the most part everyone was wearing masks and showing some distancing (in contrast to the mob scenes were see here in the U.S.)
June 8, 2020 12:04 pm at 12:04 pm in reply to: Census ( brings) magefa R’L and Bracha leaves #1869151GadolhadorahParticipantMilhouse’s strategy is correct. By refusing to participate, he and his like-minded chevrah can honestly claim that ANY census-based reapportionment plan, resource allocation plan etc. is RIGGED and Flawed because certain demographic groups (e.g. right-wing, cynical, Trumpkopf loving yidden) were not counted.
June 8, 2020 11:28 am at 11:28 am in reply to: If N.Y. doesn’t allow summer camps to open, what’s your plan? #1869123GadolhadorahParticipantMy somewhat contrarian comment which confused Syag and drew concurrence from Reb Yosef was really a mix of fact and fantasy. As I’ve noted in other posts, I wouldn’t remotely consider sending my kids off to a sleep-away camp this year under the circumstances. I’m normally not that risk averse but here the risk adjusted consequences (% likelihood of infection X the mortality/morbidity outcomes) make it an easy decision for me. Responsible parents and yiddeshe mosdos (using my metrics) should be planning to find lower risk options for kids staying home this year. Nothing is “risk-free” but but the risks of sending kids to camp at this point have been well documented and the theoretical solutions offered by some camp operators, while commendable, are simply not workable.
June 8, 2020 10:37 am at 10:37 am in reply to: If N.Y. doesn’t allow summer camps to open, what’s your plan? #1869091GadolhadorahParticipantSince so many posters here are so emotionally attached to the way life was in the alte heim and frequently invoke how simple and pure life was in those good ole days, why not simply deal with the kids before we started warehousing them for the summer months.
June 7, 2020 11:34 pm at 11:34 pm in reply to: Census ( brings) magefa R’L and Bracha leaves #1868965GadolhadorahParticipantPerhaps those posters who blame “the magafah” on the census should share their revelations with the Trumpkpopf. Since his rants and tweets blaming the (Wuhand) Magafah on China have not gotten much traction,, he can float some trial balloons blaming the pandemic on the “deep state” operatives at the U.S. Census Bureau.
June 4, 2020 1:04 pm at 1:04 pm in reply to: If N.Y. doesn’t allow summer camps to open, what’s your plan? #1867976GadolhadorahParticipantDay camps will be open, and that was announced earlier this week. Also, for parents with multiple kids at home, reminder that there are multiple mental health resources for adults available within the frum community.
May 28, 2020 2:32 pm at 2:32 pm in reply to: Chasidus bans “informers” from using its facilities #1865773GadolhadorahParticipantStrange that just before scanning the latest posts on this thread, I had read an uplifting story in the news section about some guy named Gary in the Detroit community who had arranged to renovate and distribute thousands of bikes to kids in the community who had been stuck at home for 2 months and just being allowed outside. What an act of tzadakah and kindness. Here were are debating the halachic pros/cons of community members who “informed” on those who violated public health guidelines because they felt their OWN needs were more important than those of the tzibur-at-large. As noted above, I think the informers should be celebrated as heroes and the idiots who endorsed this shunning are the one to be treated as outcasts.
May 27, 2020 9:48 am at 9:48 am in reply to: Chasidus bans “informers” from using its facilities #1865324GadolhadorahParticipantSuch “informers” are actually heroes to their own neighbors, their chassidus, and the tzibur at large. Daas torah allows for such “informing” to save a life in immediate danger. Any rabbonin or askanimn who seek to punish these individuals who may have saved lives by interrupting any dangerous pandemic practices are themselves like to suffer the consequences of what they wished on others.
May 26, 2020 6:23 pm at 6:23 pm in reply to: BIGGEST JEWISH DEBATE: DO YOU WASH YOUR TZITZIS??? #1865105GadolhadorahParticipantOne can tell the Corona fixation is B’H beginning to wane by the titles of some of the recent CR posts. Now we can get back to normal with a focus on the shidduch crisis, WoW making a scene at the Kosel and the latest sighting of moishiach on Eastern Parkway.
May 26, 2020 1:06 pm at 1:06 pm in reply to: $1200 for the Public but Trillions of Dollars for Corporations #1864853GadolhadorahParticipantIn the words of the a great Anmerican, whatever is good for the Trumpkopf’s chavrusah will ultimately be good for the nation. Great Righ Wing talmeidiei chachamim and mainstream Supply Side tzadikim bring down the importance of first making sure the uber-wealthy are taken care of first and then some of the crumbs will trickle down to the poishete citizens of our society.
GadolhadorahParticipantSchnitzel: Lots of shops shut down today in Brooklyn, Queens and Manhattan. Notwithstanding, the opinions expressed by some in the tziur, the Sherriff’s closings were spread across both yiddeshe and goiyeshe owned small business and there was little evidence of some anti-Semitic tirade by the Mayor. The officers were doing their job and enforcing the rules. Some did stay open without any problems while others were closed for the day. I suspect that Cuomo and the Mayor have gotten the message and will begin relaxing the rules later this week for all small stores, subject to the same rules the big stores had to follow regarding percentage occupancy, social distancing, masks etc.
May 24, 2020 10:33 pm at 10:33 pm in reply to: Lawsuit in NJ to force the state to allow worship service #1864250GadolhadorahParticipantWell as many of you know, the Trumpkopf called a special news conference on Friday to demand that all states allow their churches and shuls be allowed to reopen IMMEDIATELY and if not, he would “OVERRULE” them. He insisted that Americans need “More prayer” and they should come out “THIS SUNDAY” (i.e. today) to exercise their rights to worship. Well, this morning a few minutes before the 10:00 AM mass at St. Johns’ Episcopal Church across Lafayette Square,, the Presidential motorcade with sirens flashing pulled out from the north portico of the White House, down the driveway to Pennsylvania avenue made a right turn on 15th Street but headed south to Virginia and showed up on time for the 10:30 AM mass (aka as tee time) at the Trump National Golf Course. Trump then proceeded to worship unmasked for 3+ hours with an occasional shoulder bump to others in his foursome. The golf Gods obviously didn’t accept his teffilos since his deacons (aka Secret Service agents) were photographed on several occasions following the Trumpkopf into the rough searching for his ill-fated drives that veered off the fairways. Never say this is not a President that leads by example on public health and spiritual issues. A tzadik gamur
May 24, 2020 10:31 pm at 10:31 pm in reply to: Lakewood Yeshivos closed because of Murphy not Corona. #1864247GadolhadorahParticipantHaimy: The governor has not focused on yeshivos. All schools in New Jersey, public and private, are under the SAME rules. With few exceptions, ALLl parents want their kids back in school ASAP for the kids’ mental health and their own. Murphy has already said that schools WILL reopen in the Fall even without a vaccine. At this point, there is limited agreement what schools need to do to reopen safely and it will take some time (and $$) for the required changes in physical facilities and operating procedures.
GadolhadorahParticipantSyag: It all depends on how much you value a life placed at risk by accelerating the opening faster than the public health experts recommend. I have no problem with Montana or West Virginia moving quickly to reopen whatever segments of their economy remain closed. To me, the political and economic pressure to reopen NYC before the public health experts agree that its safe is reckless. The economic pain is real and gets worse every day but so was the reality of trucks line up outside the hospitals and funeral homes to hold the overflow of bodies just a month ago. Call it a “lie” if you want, but a slower reopening seems more prudent and should outweigh economic considerations.
GadolhadorahParticipantI missed the question mark?? So take my comment (minus the rhetorical reference to POTUS) as a response to your question. As noted, stupid decisions all around back in March that cost lives and now mean it will take a bit longer to reopen NY metro area safely. Too bad this has so quickly deteriorated into another facet of the toxicity of our politics and culture wars.
GadolhadorahParticipantIts not a binary decision. You can gradually reopen w/o waiting 2 years for a vaccine. Putting aside that Reb Yosef’s hero (the Trumpkopfer rebbe) has told us the vaccine will be available to everyone by the end of the year, The New York area has experienced roughly 25,000 to 30,000 deaths in the past 2 months out of a national total of about 96,000 so it would make sense we are going to be slower and more prudent about reopening. Cuomo is moving slowing after some really bad decisions back in March. The nightly hespedim here on YWN have been painful beyond belief. Clearly , you believe the economic pain should take priority over the niftarim. Some of us respectfully disagree with your priorities.
May 23, 2020 10:33 pm at 10:33 pm in reply to: Minyanim Legal in New York starting tomorrow #1863809GadolhadorahParticipantYidden don’t need the Trumpkopf to tell us that davening is “essential”, but that is NOT the issue for purposes of whether it is “safe” yet to hold minyanim in shuls that either cannot or will not undertake the necessary investments in their facilities and practices to conform the CDC and state guidelines. The comparison to opening liquor stores is beyond stupid since the latter have able to restrict the numbers of customers in a store at any time and enforce social distancing compared to a shul with dozens or even hundreds of daveners in close proximity. Most importantly, the Trumpkopf could care less about spiritual welfare. This was a political stunt for his right wing evangelical voters since he has ZERO legal authority to “override” state laws and orders. He can direct his AG to file an amicus in court cases or even bring a case in federal court but otherwise, even Republican lawyers agree his statement was a joke.
GadolhadorahParticipantWhile it varies from virus to virus, it takes very high rates of vaccination to achieve “herd immunity” and may also take several years to achieve that outcome. I’m not sure how this concept will be helpful for the next school year.
-
AuthorPosts