Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
flatbusherParticipant
So who are you referring to “all doing aveiros.”? How do you know what they’re watching?
flatbusherParticipantI would think that any song that has Jewish-related theme is a Jewish song. In the past, Jewish music was often characterized by being composed in a minor key, but obviously that has changed with all the ripped-off goyishe styles that Jewish musicians have adopted.
flatbusherParticipantDass Yochid, you seem to find it very easy to label things aveirah, and would be curious to know if it is indeed there is a psak that is an aveirah to see a movie that has no unclean content, or it’s just you.
flatbusherParticipantzahavasdad: I have heard similar stories, and they are indeed all sad. Years ago I befriended a guy who had become frum but he didn’t like learning, and someone told him “ain am ha’retz chasid,” and he just gave up the whole thing.
February 18, 2015 5:05 pm at 5:05 pm in reply to: Worrying about something that someone 16 should not be worrying about #1060381flatbusherParticipantI would wonder what a 16 year old girl is doing on the Internet in the middle of the day. At any rate, yes, you can remain friends but I doubt you will have many common interests once she gets married. Make other friends. There are a lot people out there, you need only to reach out.
flatbusherParticipantTry cutting down gradually, instead of going cold turkey. So instead of cutting it completely, reduce the amount of time you spend on this. It worked for me.
flatbusherParticipantI stand corrected, thanks. I was looking at Pasuk 15 and see there the word is “V’nishmartem”
flatbusherParticipantWhy not open a chumash and look it up? The pasuk has been interpreted that one must take care of himself
flatbusherParticipantSure, there are always exceptions, and sadly some people point to that as if that situation is applicable to a broader group. But the one’s you mention are the exception. Many a couple struggle from the beginning, as the wife ends up taking whatgever job to make money and then when the husband finally realizes he needs to work, his options are limited if he can’t afford the time to be trained. Certainly there are people in alll stations in life who struggle but often its their job or career choices that contribute to the situation. Someone who goes to law school or become an accountant usually earns more than someone who works at a supermarket, or ebcomes a rebbi, which is not high paying
flatbusherParticipantWasn’t Adam Ha-rishon the first Yekka, when the pasuk says “A’yekkah:”
flatbusherParticipantDQB: the guy will get a nice position in yeshiva, girl will get a ice job and they are learners for life. What planet are you living on? There aren’t enough jobs for all those yeshiva guys, and besides who said they naturally qualify to be taechers. The experience has been that just because a person can learn doesn’t mean he can be a teacher, and what kind of nice job wil the girl have that pays all their expenses for the house full of children? Sounds like a me’ut she b’me’ut that can live the fantasy scenario you describe.
flatbusherParticipantI just have first hand experience from at least half dozen person observations, as well as discussions with friends of mine who can attest to the same. I guess you don’t think marriage requires maturity.
flatbusherParticipantThe pasuk cited is Devarim 4:15, and contains the word “me’od”
flatbusherParticipantTo clarify my point, there are those who oppose to working out because they say it makes people care too much about their bodies, namely to look good, and I wonder if they feel the same away about people who focus on the way they dress to make themselves look good.
flatbusherParticipantHostility by a boss could mean he wants to fire you. Maybe you just want to meet with him and tell him you feel he has become hostile and you would like to know what you can do to improve your relationship with him
flatbusherParticipantI didn’t define that. I said a boy who goes to work/school after mesifta is worker, while learner/earner is in yeshiva for 2-3 years after marriage and then goes to work. See above
flatbusherParticipantyes, your point? Such a boy is not defined as learner/earner
February 15, 2015 9:01 pm at 9:01 pm in reply to: "Distance Your Path from It" � The Dangers of Academic Study #1141264flatbusherParticipantLower standard of living? Have you any idea what basic necessities cost?
flatbusherParticipantI didn’t say such a boy is a learner/earner. Generally it is understood as someone who remains in yeshiva for 2-3 years after marriage and then goes to work
February 15, 2015 8:58 pm at 8:58 pm in reply to: shidduchim: what's all this about middos? #1093683flatbusherParticipantLior: I’m saying what the boys are looking for. Have you had children in shidduchim? usually the mother is involved, and the first thing most seem to ask is dress size, then they want a picture, then they ask if the family is willing to support. If the ls are davka looking for a long-term learner, I don’t think income potential is an issue
flatbusherParticipantLior: Provide some support for what you call the fact that delaying married stunts maturity.
flatbusherParticipantleft yeshiva after mesifta and went to college and then work, while learner earner may be in yeshiva 2-3 years before embarking on path to earn a living
flatbusherParticipantSome people who are immature when they marry young never grow up. Sounds you like you are underestimating the maturity required to be married.
flatbusherParticipantThere are guys who do want to learn but they also want to be responsible, so they learn but they know they have to earn, as opposed to those who apparently don’t think earning a living should be on their agenda.
flatbusherParticipantI was only responding to comments made. Unfortunately, I have witnessed what happens who make no plans. It has less to do with being kollel for long term than not planning for the future. I don’t know how anyone can find fault with a guy making plans to support his wife and family. After all, it is his responsibility, not his wife, or his father in law’s.
February 15, 2015 8:00 pm at 8:00 pm in reply to: shidduchim: what's all this about middos? #1093679flatbusherParticipantUnfortunately, often when boys are looking for a shidduch, middos are not the No. 1. It comes after looks, dress size, money, etc.
flatbusherParticipantNot sure what point you’re missing. Obviously, without plans for parnassa, it’s going to be tough going. Rebbe Yid, your assessment is unrealistic. You don’t seem to realize how much the basic necessities cost especially when there is a house full of children. Even if the wife works full time, it better be an extremely well paying job, and given the fact that most women at some point want to raise their kids, I don’t know how feasible that is. There are some yachidim who have the wealth to sit and learn their entire lives, but the reality is, most people work to make ends meet, and if the guy first decides at 35 that he has to work, well, his options may be limited.
February 15, 2015 7:24 pm at 7:24 pm in reply to: "Distance Your Path from It" � The Dangers of Academic Study #1141262flatbusherParticipantI’ve heard strange things like bochurim in Lakewood told not to date anyone who has a college degree or who is going to college. I guess the girls’ future is supposed to be running playgroups for every conceivable age group, or to have their husbands go from shul to shul with their hands out. Not everyone is cut out to be a successful businessman, and the reality is that you need money for basic necessities, which include food, clothing and tuition. Of course, we have to have bitachon that Hashem will provide them, but we see that those who actually do make an effort and get trained in something and a job not only are able to provide for their families, but give tzedakah. So I am not sure what the original letter in this thread aims to do. It sounds like those who sit around doing nothing and believe thatthey will get the same parnassa as if they actually worked. We see it doesn’t work that way.
flatbusherParticipantOf course while there may be 21 year olds who are mature, by and large I don’t think I would say any 21 year olds I know are ready to get married, and with the way things work so quickly that is likely to happen sooner or later. If the guy has strong yetzer harah, yes, try to get him married, but why should a young man not experience being adult before finding himself having to deal with matters of love and livelihood at such a young age?
flatbusherParticipantI’m just telling you what I hear from Shadchanim.
Sadly, doing research doesn’t always uncover the truth as many a young woman has found out after she is married to the “best boy.”
The reality is maybe he can learn for 5-10 years, and then what? Instant parnassah?
flatbusherParticipantUnfortunately, when my daughter said she was looking for a boy to learn 2-3 years, more than one shadchan says that is not a serious learner. I guess 5-10 is more like it
I think they choose to learn longer than 3 years because it makes them look good. I’m sorry to be cyncial, but I do not believe every boy who is sitting and learning and plans to do so for some time, actually wants to, but they’ve been told that is the way to get a great shiidduch, makes them look honorable and they can avoid going to work for several years.
flatbusherParticipantOn the other hand, without a future plan, what happens after 10 years and learning, married with a bunch of kids and no training to support the family?
flatbusherParticipantThat could be the case, but based on what I hear, just about all of my daughters’ friends from high school and seminary are looking for long-term learners. Learners/earners are not considered serious learners because they plan to work, and apparently that turns off a number of girls.
flatbusherParticipantBecause a lot of boys are sitting and learning with no future plans and young women returning for seminary are looking for that type.
flatbusherParticipantI don’t have an answer, which is why I am asking. But since it is easier to set up longtime learners, I guess they focus on that.
flatbusherParticipantThe original question is weird. why would someone not one to gain muscle? It takes a lot of effort to look musclebound unless one is genetically gifted but increased muscle in generally good for your health
flatbusherParticipantWhy revive a three-year old post that generated no response until now? Must be bored silly.
flatbusherParticipantmik5: in this day an age, how many people do you think don’t have a seudah at home or a place to go or have food delivered by a chesed organization?
February 12, 2015 6:06 pm at 6:06 pm in reply to: February–a senior HS girl's favorite month #1060374flatbusherParticipantAs a parent, I think Seminary is a waste, despite the fact that all my daughters went (peer pressure, of course). Seminary is designed for young women who want to go into chinuch; everyone else would be better to spare their parents the expense (total around $25,000), and if they are so eager to learn, to attend seminary locally. Yes, it’s nice to experience living in Israel, but why not get a job and work there? Jobs don’t pay well, but it’s better than just draining parents finances. Of course, the Israeli economy benefits from all these girls
flatbusherParticipantI was thinking of that as well, not necessarily how they got that way, but the fact that the Torah mentions it. I think there are people who naturally endowed with great strength, so I don’t think you can bring the Torah as proof. More than the exercising issue, however, is the poor diet, which often is heavy with fat. That combined with lack of exercise could be lethal
flatbusherParticipantSo for those who frown upon working out, what do you do to benefit your health, or do you feel everything is bashert so regardless of how you abuse your body with your diet or neglect by foregoing exervising, you will end up the same way?
flatbusherParticipantIf you are in a legal job, boring or not, I imagine it pays fairly well, and if it doesn’t, then maybe you should look elsewhere. I am not sure why you feel the need at this point to spend a year in Israel to learn, but you can also learn here, keep your job and still enhance your knowledge even if it isn’t full time. If you are really that interested in learning, a 9-5 job gives you plenty of evening time to study. To me, it doesn’t sound it’s worth upending your life, journeying into uncertainty that could easily distract you from your purpose for going. But may I ask, why is this your deam at this point in your life?
flatbusherParticipant147: I don’t call your suggestion a seudas Shabbos. At least to me a seudas shabbos is at a nicely set table with good company, good foos, good zemiros and good divrei Torah.
I am not surprised at some of the responses here.
flatbusherParticipantThat’s not my point. It ust seems unnecessary to make it possible for people to stuff themselves when they will soon be going home to a seudah. It’s not a seudas mitzvah, it;s gluttony.
flatbusherParticipantSo you buy into the lavish kiddushes.
flatbusherParticipantBut what do you think of practice of making these big kiddushes?
flatbusherParticipantSoo you don’t eat your wife’s cholent? DOes she not make cholent when there is a kiddush in shul?
flatbusherParticipantLakewood today is not what it used to be. For people who want to learn there, if they depend on their wives for support, there are no real jobs there and many just start playgroups/babysitting services. One day, people will wake up and realize that Lakewood is just not a feasible option. Reasonable housing won’t make much difference if husbands continue to learn and not work, though it may keep more younger people. Brooklyn itself may not be played; people just may have to pioneer less expensive neighborhoods.
flatbusherParticipantWhat exactly is the issue? Need help with the kids? Totally helpless without him?
flatbusherParticipantThe fact that there are very few frum bodybuilders seems to suggest that people work out primarily for health and if that happens to make them look better, so what, and I would think most people would say that’s a good thing
-
AuthorPosts