Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
DovidBTParticipant
Uhhhh. Not sure what to say. Maybe read the Chazal that all avodah Zoran was uprooted and no longer exists?
The halachos and gezeiros relating to idolaters seem to have been extended to apply to non-Jews in general, even if they’re not literally idolaters.
DovidBTParticipantIt is no different then Bishul, that putting it on the fire is all that counts, even though that it is being cooked at a later point in Shabbos, as long as you did it before Shabbos it is fine.
In addition to putting the uncooked food on the fire before Shabbos, doesn’t the cooking process have to be at least 50% completed before the onset of Shabbos? I’m only asking for clarification. This probably isn’t relevant to the main discussion here.
DovidBTParticipantcan anyone explain why a t-stat is different in halacha then a timer.
A thermostat can be triggered by your actions. Open door, warm air enters the room, thermostat turns on the A/C.
DovidBTParticipantidolater’s scotch – is this Purim Torah?
No. After a month of Daf Yomi-ing Avodah Zarah, I see idolaters everywhere.
DovidBTParticipantCTL: Could you refuse, saying that you need spend the time with fee-paying clients so that you can feed your family?
DovidBTParticipantIt’s a slippery slope. Today drink an idolater’s scotch, tomorrow marry his daughter.
DovidBTParticipantNebuchadnezzar
DovidBTParticipantAnd if the student was not wearing the backpack when the person started shooting?
Or what if the shooter aims for a part of the body not covered by the backpack?
I think the theory is that the students would crouch down and use the backpacks as shields.
The real purpose, of course, is for the businesses that market the backpacks to profit from parents who buy them as a useless gesture, so that they can pretend they’re protecting their children.
DovidBTParticipantIf you drink enough so that you can’t distinguish between Haman and Mordechai, as you’re supposed to, you’ll be too drunk to drive. So it’s a moot point.
DovidBTParticipantHas a bulletproof backpack ever saved someone from injury or death?
DovidBTParticipantIf you ever look at comments on virtually any article on, for example, Yahoo News that concerns Jews and/or Israel, one of the most frequent rants is that we only care about our own.
On the other hand:
Suppose a family conducts a memorial service for their child who was a victim of a mass shooting. Does the family deserve to be criticized for focusing only on their own child? Does that mean they’re being selfish and bigoted for not caring about the other victims?
February 15, 2018 11:13 pm at 11:13 pm in reply to: Is there any way to prevent mass shootings???? #1470386DovidBTParticipantMake it common practice for everyone to be armed, and trained in self-defense.
DovidBTParticipantEat it tail first, so that it can’t bite your tongue.
DovidBTParticipantAlso, anti-Semites are more than happy to point out that some of us don’t regard non-Jews as quite human and are therefore enemies of the country they live in.
Along those lines, I’ve wondered whether non-Jews or non-religious Jews encounter this site, and try to figure out what some of the discussions are about. Do they think that the participants are weird, or even dangerous?
DovidBTParticipantRather we should be sharing the beauty of each tefiloh, how it expresses our praises to HKB”H, how it spells out our needs, and how to include the core of kavanah in each part of the davening.
Personally, I’ve found Rabbi Heshy Kleinman’s books “Praying with Fire” (volumes 1 and 2) and “Praying with Meaning” very helpful.
DovidBTParticipantdon’t see why prevalence should change the din, …
What about the practice of men using mirrors for cosmetic purposes? Is that a reasonable analogy?
DovidBTParticipantIf the restaurant or store posts that it does not accept cash and it is on the menu and/or the server lets you know before you place your order, it is legal.
Suppose when you get the check for the meal, you insist on paying with cash. Could they refuse to accept it and call the cops?
DovidBTParticipantIn fact more and more goyische restaurants no longer accept cash.
How can that be legal? U.S. currency contains the text, “This note is legal tender for all debts, public and private”.
February 9, 2018 12:21 pm at 12:21 pm in reply to: @Chabad Shluchah Please Explain Why Davening To/Betten a Rebbe is Okay #1466280DovidBTParticipant@Sechel HaYashar
I’ll summarize here one last time what I do and don’t believe:
1. … 8.Thanks for the clear summary. I’ll assume that’s the mainstream Chabad belief, unless someone posts otherwise.
DovidBTParticipantI’m a BT, like you. I’ve read all the books you mentioned in your earlier post.
My experience has been that the more Torah study and mitzvos I bring into my life, the less space and desire there is for non-essential secular activities. By Torah study, I’m including Talmud, halachos, etc.
So it’s not so much a matter of consciously excluding the secular. It seems to happen automatically.
DovidBTParticipantWhat about seraphim?
February 6, 2018 4:11 pm at 4:11 pm in reply to: Poppy seeds, YUM! Okay maybe it’s just my yatzar hara but #1463715DovidBTParticipantThe U.S. Federal Bureau of Prisons form BP-A0291 (Furlough Application – Approval and Record) contains the following:
It has been determined that consumption of poppy seeds may cause a positive drug test which may result in disciplinary action. As a condition of my participation in community programs, I will not consume any poppy seeds or items containing poppy seeds.
This form can be viewed at the Federal Bureau of Prisons web site, bop DOT gov.
DovidBTParticipantAlso, study what interests you.
Rebbi said: A person can learn Torah [successfully] only from the area [i.e,. only within the topic] that his heart [currently] desires. For the verse says: [Psalms 1:2] ‘But his desire is in the Torah of Hashem.’
(The commentary adds that “According to Meiri, Rebbi speaks of where to begin [a session of] study.”)
Avodah Zarah 19aDovidBTParticipantIf Watergate happened in the current political climate, it would be news for a week, and then forgotten as soon as the media finds something else to be outraged about.
February 5, 2018 12:10 am at 12:10 am in reply to: @Chabad Shluchah Please Explain Why Davening To/Betten a Rebbe is Okay #1462304DovidBTParticipantI suspect it’s a site made by disenchanted Lubavitchers who are now probably MO, and it is not a site that represents mainstream Litvish opinion.
It’s hard to trust a web site that doesn’t identify its author(s) or provide any contacts except for a gmail dot com address. The whois data for the domain gives the name and address of a person in Lakewood, NJ, but that’s not necessarily the site’s author.
February 4, 2018 9:51 pm at 9:51 pm in reply to: Come on, you know you want to talk about ThatHat! #1462295DovidBTParticipantHow does the folded hat know how to return to its original shape?
DovidBTParticipantIs this topic analogous to buying a computer from a company whose CEO openly transgresses the Noachide laws?
DovidBTParticipantso anyone have any ideas how to improve the standards of the coffeeroom or are you too busy circulating lashon hara?
In order to make a post, you must take an online class in a relevant middah, such as anavah, and pass a test on the content.
DovidBTParticipantWhen doctors have to compete with personal robots that cost the same as refrigerators, they’ll find ways to make their office visits more convenient.
DovidBTParticipantI’m not doubting the existence of G-d, but I don’t think it’s possible to prove it or disprove it.
An atheist could argue that everything in the above post can be explained by science. For example, from an atheist’s perspective, since we’re part of nature, we’re programmed by evolution to find nature beautiful.
DovidBTParticipantOriginally I had thought that I was the only one with this Shabbos bias, now I know I was not alone. And….now I have it confirmed that the bias is REAL.
In my opinion, the non-observant Jewish movements, and their “flexibility” in regard to religious practice, are to blame for the “Shabbos bias”.
DovidBTParticipantI have the credentials.
The hard part is not quitting, but avoiding starting again. After quitting, the desire to smoke can last for months or years. I used to dream about smoking. I would even looking forward to bedtime so that I could “dream-smoke”. 🙂
Some things I found helpful:
1.Remove, or pack away, everything that reminds you of smoking: ashtrays, matches, etc. Of course you may still need matches to light Shabbos candles, but at least keep the matches out of reach the rest of the time. I kept some cigarettes on hand so that I wouldn’t panic, but I packed them away so that they were out of sight and it would take several minutes to access them.
2. Try to avoid going to places where other people may be smoking.
3. Do regular cardiovascular exercise. It needs to be of sufficient intensity that you have to breathe very deeply. With each breath, you’re reminded that you wouldn’t be able to do that if you smoked.
January 28, 2018 10:31 pm at 10:31 pm in reply to: Are people capable of rational thought while panicking? #1458158DovidBTParticipantIt might apply to the engineers calmly sitting at their desks designing algoritms for autonomous (self-driving) vehicles.
January 28, 2018 5:36 pm at 5:36 pm in reply to: You are the conductor of a train 🚂 and you have a split second decision-what wou #1458062DovidBTParticipantIn the area of autonomous vehicle design, this actually has practical implications.
From the Wikipedia article on “Trolley problem”:
In 2016, the government of Germany constituted an ethical commission that addressed the implications of autonomous driving. As a result, the commission defined 20 rules for autonomous and connected driving, which will be obligatory for upcoming laws regarding the production of autonomous cars.
The article links to the commission’s report (a downloadable .pdf), which lists their 20 rules. It’s not clear to me whether they addressed this problem, but “rule 9” states:
In the event of unavoidable accident situations, any distinction based on personal features (age, gender, physical or mental constitution) is strictly prohibited. It is also prohibited to offset victims against one another. General programming to reduce the number of personal injuries may be justifiable. Those parties involved in the generation of mobility risks must not sacrifice non-involved parties.
DovidBTParticipantReish Lakish said: Whoever involves himself in Torah [study] at night, the Holy One, Blessed is He, endows him with charm during the day, as it says: [Psalms 42:9] ‘In the day Hashem commands His kindness, and in the night his song was with Me.’
Avodah Zarah 3bJanuary 23, 2018 5:43 pm at 5:43 pm in reply to: Could we have dinosaurs if we wanted them? #1455975DovidBTParticipantBecause those are more useful but also less fun.
What could be more fun than flying on a giant bird? You could even fly between the legs of the giant cows.
January 23, 2018 4:01 pm at 4:01 pm in reply to: Could we have dinosaurs if we wanted them? #1455715DovidBTParticipantWhy not apply genetic engineering in ways that are more useful?
Examples:
Giant, 80-foot-high cattle. Slaughter one, and you have enough beef for ten thousand pots of cholent, and enough leather to make 100 sets of gassos tefillin.
Huge, ergonomically designed birds that can carry people. Not only practical, but safe. How often do you hear about birds crashing into each other?
DovidBTParticipantno one has explained why the shlemeil in Hawaii who pushed the wrong button to send out the false alert could not have typed in “false alarm” and blasted it out to the same distribution list used for the initial alarm.
There was probably no option for doing that.
IMO, the sirens + EBS radio stations are superior to the modern “high tech” approach.
January 18, 2018 6:41 pm at 6:41 pm in reply to: Closing of the PETA Thread: Your Views On the Matter #1452579DovidBTParticipant@Give Me a Break
That old thread is too long to read. Why not state your viewpoint on PETA?
DovidBTParticipantThis is a test of the Emergency Broadcast System
Back in those days, everyone had radios, with the EBS frequencies marked on them. As i recall, one of them was 640 KHz (AM). If there had been an announcement like the one in Hawaii, people would have quickly determined it to be a false alarm by tuning their radios to that frequency.
January 17, 2018 9:46 am at 9:46 am in reply to: What percentage of off the derech kids/teens/adults return to Yiddishkeit? #1451394DovidBTParticipantThat said, I don’t know that justifies tolerance of the issurim you mentioned.
If someone were transgressing secular laws, e.g. committing murder or robbery, would a tolerant attitude toward them be acceptable? Why should we more lenient with halachic transgressors?
DovidBTParticipant(Since this is the Rants forum …)
What’s the purpose of the Bar Mitzvah “event”?
Is it primarily a family reunion, or is a recognition of the boy becoming a Bar Mitzvah?
If the latter, isnt it “fake” to give the boy special instruction to present the illusion that he has the ability to read any part of the Torah and/or the Prophets?
DovidBTParticipantremember seeing a news item a while ago in the Lakewood Shopper
about a man winning a minor local office due to his own vote for
himself because no one else had voted in that particular election.It would be amusing if there had been a demand for a recount.
DovidBTParticipantWe have invested virtually nothing in upgrading our emergency preparedness since the end of the cold war.
The U.S.’s emergency preparedness in the cold war era was pretty silly. There were sheltering provisions for a small fraction of the population, but for most it was “duck and cover”.
the end of the cold war
What kind of war are we in now? Cold, warm, tepid? Whatever kind it is, it’s been going on since the early 90s.
DovidBTParticipantI got another one…..who gives the barber his haircuts?
Is this the barber who cuts the hair of everyone in town who doesn’t cut his own hair?
DovidBTParticipantWhat’s the source for assigning interpretions to Hebrew letters in this manner?
DovidBTParticipantMeno, cannabis is considered the PC term.
Using “canabis” and “PC” in the same sentence?????
We are enemies now.
DovidBTParticipantYou’re all missing the big picture here.
If the liberals all start smoking grass, that will keep them passive, effectively removing them as a political force.
If the military air-dropped massive amounts of the stuff on the terrorists, they’d stop doing terrorism.
If the police distributed free stuff to the violent mobs, they’d sit around smoking the stuff instead of doing violence.
DovidBTParticipantLike far out, man.
DovidBTParticipantSome rhinoplasty is cosmetic, some is to repair issues such as a deviated septum.
I had a surgical procedure to correct a deviated septum. The procedure was called septoplasty, not rhinoplasty. But I’m not an expert on medical terminology; maybe the terms are used interchangeably.
In the context of this topic, I suppose that a deviated septum would fall into the category of items that warrant discosure.
-
AuthorPosts