Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
Derech HaMelechMember
I always heard that it was “kabbalistic” reasons. But that answer is always vague and who knows if its true. Also, I have heard the opposite, that the reason why Sephardim don’t have black lines is because (I think it’s) the Bais Yosef paskens that the tzitzis have to be the same color as the beged.
I actually like your first reason though. And even though today priests don’t do it, once we start a custom we don’t stop it even the reason is no longer present. Minhag avoseinu byadeinu.
Derech HaMelechMemberI think I understood what puplicious said and if I’m right, then I also suggest Dr. Sarno’s book. I know someone who used it for back problems and another who used it for Chronic Fatigue Syndrome.
Derech HaMelechMemberlesschumras:
Lesschumras’ post was deleted, as well as quotes of it
Your question implies that Torah can’t protect. So here is the gemarah in Sotah 21a
?????? ?? ?? ??? ??? ???? ?? ???? (???? ?, ??) ?? ?? ???? ????? ??? ??? ????? ?? ????? ??? ??? ????? ???? ?? ????? ??? ???? ?? ?? ?? ???? ????? ??? ??? ??? ?? ???? ???? ????? ??? ??? ??? ??? ????? ???? ???? ?? ?? ??? ???? ????? ?? ???? ????? ?????
and later on the daf…
??? ??? ???? ?????? ????? ?? ???? ????? ?????? ??? ???? ?? ????? ???? ????? ?? ???? ???? ??? ?????? ????? ?? ??? ?????? ??? ???? ?? ????? ???? ????? ?? ????
So obviously the zchus of Torah did protect them. So you have to say, as much as the zchus of Torah protected them, there was still that many more gzeiros out. But had it not been for the protection that they did have, it would have been all the more worse.
Derech HaMelechMemberSorry it’s not easy to keep track of the posts.
You are saying, if a person goes into a gvir’s house and demands that he be supported so that he could learn, that is a chillul Hashem.
Here is the Chinuch:
????? ??? ?? ???? ????? ??? ?????? ????? ??????? ????? ???? ?? ????? ????? ???? ????? ????? ????? ???? ???? ???? ???? ???? ????? ???? ?????? ???? ???? ???? ???? ??? ?? ???? ???? ???? ??? ??? ???? ??? ??????? ????? ??? ????? ??? ?????? ??? ????? ?’ ????? ??? ????
??? ?????? ?? ???? ??? ???? ???? ??????
As you can see, the only example he brings of an ish gadol doing something unseemly as a chillul Hashem is when it comes to a maaseh heter. However, we are talking about a mitzvah not a maaseh heter.
I would say the same applies to having children. We aren’t mevatel mitzvos for the sake of chillul Hashem. It’s not a chillul Hashem when the question is a mitzvah. If you have any source that says otherwise, please put it on the table.
Barring that, I would say that in the case of someone barging into a gvir’s house and demanding to be supported, that no, he hasn’t made a chillul Hashem.
Derech HaMelechMemberIt will be easier to get serious comments in your threads if you get your Caps Lock button fixed. If there’s nothing stuck under the key, it might be time to get a new keyboard.
Derech HaMelechMemberNow that you mention it, I don’t remember. Maybe it goes through each one. but i’m 100% sure that is the opening question(s).
Derech HaMelechMemberbut I think I need the doctor to actually tell me that I have that so I can explain to the people who do not realize that they are causing it by constantly yelling at me why they need to leave me alone a bit more often and let me do my own thing (when people tell me what to do- it tends to stress me out, also having to confront pet peeves 24/7 also stresses me out
Someone one time pointed this out to me and even though I never realized it, it’s really very obvious. There is no such thing as a stressful situation. The stress is only a reaction that you have to an event (or person). It’s all in your head. we spend a lot of time reinforcing the idea that if someone yells at us, our response should be to become stressed. But the reality is that we can choose how we want to react. We are people, we can control ourselves.
January 17, 2013 10:33 pm at 10:33 pm in reply to: CR Discussions: Halachic or Non-Halachic Discussions? #922027Derech HaMelechMemberThe question is if someone is able to own something that he’s not allowed to (ie. chometz, chazer). If someone can’t halachically posses an idol, then it can’t be stolen.
Derech HaMelechMemberI would also say to stay away from spicy foods, fried foods, and anything else you might enjoy until it passes. And try to focus more on getting rid of your stress. Try to pick up a relaxation technique or two. Chances are, this is psychosomatic. When you can become more relaxed, this too shall pass.
Derech HaMelechMemberDo bananas and papayas grow in E”Y?
Derech HaMelechMemberIs it bigger than a bread box I remember is also one of them, but the first question is if its animal, vegetable or mineral.
Derech HaMelechMemberINTJ. It looks like there’s a lot of us.
Derech HaMelechMemberThat’s also how the toy works. I bought it for my younger brother once and its uncanny how it almost always gets it right.
Derech HaMelechMemberbenignuman: I have difficulty understanding that the Yerushalmi is not trying to make a practical point. It seems to me that it goes hand in hand with the Gemarah in Bava Basra
??? ?? ????? ??? ????? ??? ????? ????? ??? ???? ?? ????? ???????
…and because there seems to be a lot of Rambam on this thread: ???? ????? ??? ?????? ?????? ?????? ?????? ???? ??????? ?????? ??? ??? ?????? ????
Who are you to say that the zchus of Torah only comes out through the army? Who knows how many countless plots were hatched but HKB”H foiled them because of the zchus of someone learning in Bnei Brak. Once the army is already in place, then Hashem might use it as one of His shluchim. But if not from this shliach, then from a different one.
?? ?? ???? ????? ??? ????? ????? ??? ???? ??? ????? ??? ???? ???? ?? ????? ????? ???? ?? ??? ????? ??? ????? ??? ??? ??? ???? ???? ??? ?????
I understand that you are saying that the point of the Yerushalmi is that armyies/gurads “destroy” because they cause people to think that it is the army that is protecting and not Hashem. But that’s only half of what it says isn’t it? Why are those that learn call the “guards of the city” if not that their Torah protects the city?
When we say the zechus of Torah learning protects us we do not mean that it creates ananei hakovod to catch missiles.
Is that so? Just because you can’t see them, doesn’t mean they’re not there.
Would you hold that it is assur for a Ben Torah to be in Hatzoloh or Zakah? Is it assur for a Ben Torah to leave kollel to get a job to support his family?
I would say that someone who is sitting and learning should not join Hatzolah because the zchus of his Torah is doing more than the Zakah volunteer. His zchus prevents people from getting injured/sick in the first place and for those who do get injured, his zchus brings the shliach refuah. The zakah volunteer is only a shliach.
As to if its assur for a Ben Torah to leave kollel to get a job to support his family. The Rambam says:
??? ????? ????? ???? ?????? ???? ?? ???? ????? ??????? ?? ??? ????? ?? ????? ?????? ??? ??? ???? ????? ?????? ??????
Derech HaMelechMemberA better question is what bracha is said for a papaya.
Well we can ask him… papaya_bar abba, what do you say?
Derech HaMelechMemberYichusdik: In my opinion, the only difference (in terms of rishus) between the Israeli government and the kings is that the kings actually put up the avodah zara and encouraged people to do it. The Israeli government just makes it legal and what people do, they do. Although I don’t think it’s accurate to say that they don’t really encourage it…
Derech HaMelechMemberCan someone help me find that article within the past year here on YWN about the Israeli who was worried about Chareidim taking over the country and forcing the Chilonim into the diaspora?
Derech HaMelechMemberbenignuman:
You said:
We believe that the Torah provides protection but we also believe that the soldiers provide protection.
and
the IDF is certainly saving Jewish lives
The Talmud Yerushalmi says:
??? ???? ????? ??? ???? ???? ???’ ??? ???’ ??? ??????? ???????? ????? ?????? ?????? ??? ????? ????????? ???? ??? ??? ??? ?????? ?? ??? ??? ?????? ????? ??? ?????? ?? ????? ???? ?????? ??? ??????
???? ????? ??? ????? ????? ????? ???? ??? ????? ??? ????? ???? ????? ??? ???? ????? ????? ???? ??? ??? ?????? ????????? ??? ??? ????? (?????? ???) ?? ?’ ?? ???? ??? ???’
You said:
the IDF is certainly saving Jewish lives and thereby engaging in one of the greatest mitzvos possible
The mishnah says:
?????? ???? ???? ????
Derech HaMelechMemberrebdoniel: See Talmud Yerushalmi Chagigah 1:7 that starts
Simcha613: I don’t think you can compare going off to work with joining the army. A person goes off to work and has some say about the environment he chooses to put himself into. If the environment is too physically or spiritually dangerous, he can leave. And most importantly a person who works can become a machzik haTorah retaining his connection to Torah and adding to the Torah that is being learned.
None of those things can be said for someone who joins the army.
mdd: A person with a sick brother who won’t go to the doctor. Do you tell him not to take his brother because his deluded brother will resent him?
Do you keep an eye out for atheists who might see you expressing your identity to a Stone Age religion?
Do you minimize the amount of children you have and send them to public school rather than take money from the government because your and your spouses jobs just aren’t enough and you know what the goyim will think…?
No you don’t. You do what you have to do in the face of others’ erroneous beliefs. Because ultimately, it’s the right thing to do.
Naftush: I really didn’t get the point you were trying to make.
Derech HaMelechMemberIn Miami the Satmar Rebbe was forced to remove his Bekasher at a TSA checkpoint
Do you think for the sake of kovod haTorah and for the sake of the kovod of a Godol b’Yisroel we should feel obligated to provide Private Jets
Fixed that for you.
Derech HaMelechMemberNaftush: It is nice that you have found elements in contemporary Israeli society to praise. But that is not reason enough to loose sight of the ultimate issue.
Walking along many of the streets of the holiest city in the world, one cannot but be struck by the complete lack of tznius that is found there. And if this is true in Yerushalayim, how much more so in Tel Aviv. The two bastions of Israeli society. Even there in our ‘Jewish’ country, on the night of December 31 thousands of Israelis get dressed up (or down really) and rush off to get drunk in celebration of “Silvester” (named for Pope Silvester I).
Yes, there E”Y is a beautiful land. And many Israelis make huge advancements in a number of fields such as medicine and technology. But would you risk releasing your children to a society that places goyish ideology at their helm in the hope that they are not attracted to the evils that lurk around almost every corner? Do you think your teenage son can walk down the streets of Tel Aviv on a summer day and come back to you the same as he left?
Derech HaMelechMemberbenignuman: What you are saying is not entirely true. There was an article here on YWN just a few months ago about a Kol Isha problem that occurred.
Also, it may be true that only the strongest learners were the ones who learned in Europe. Your argument brings to mind those who argue that since there were so many women in Europe who didn’t cover their hair, woman today shouldn’t feel forced to either.
We are a nation that strives to perform the mitzvos. What one generation couldn’t do, is not a sentence for all later generations. 300 years ago it was uncommon for Jews to wear tzitzis all day. But today B”H hundreds of thousands of us are performing this mitzvah d’oraisa to the merit of us all.
Derech HaMelechMemberLeyzer: I’ve been in a number of kollelim in E’Y and you are right, there are those that spend more time in the coffee room then in the beis medrish.
The question is, what’s the cut-off point? Let’s say it’s difficult for someone to learn 8 hours a day, but he can do 6 or 4. Is his 4 hours of Torah learning worthy enough in your eyes to keep him in kollel? How about someone who can get 2 hours of learning? Is the zchus of two strong hours of learning b’ritzifus adequate to keep him in kollel? How about the guy who can do 8 hours but he constantly needs breaks every 15 min or half an hour. How can you quantify or qualify the amount of learning a person does to judge whether he should be given the opportunity to learn Torah?
And let’s say you make the cut-off at 4 hours – someone who can’t learn for 1 full seder should go to the army. Now what happens to the guy who can plug away for 3 hours? How will he make up that time every day while he’s training in the army or while he’s sitting in Gaza? Do you imagine that he will be able to maintain a strong 3 hours under those conditions even if he did have the time?
So do you throw out 70% of the kolleleit so that you make sure you catch all the serious non-learners, or do you keep them all in so that maybe even they will pick up a sefer once in a while.
Which is more important: an hour of Torah study or 3 years of army service?
Derech HaMelechMemberWhy would you want anything that omits rays near your brain?
omit: /??mit/
Verb
Leave out or exclude (someone or something), either intentionally or forgetfully.
Fail or neglect to do (something); leave undone: “the final rinse is omitted”.
emit: /i?mit/
Verb
Produce and discharge (something, esp. gas or radiation).
Make (a sound).
Derech HaMelechMemberHonestly mods, I think there should be some posting rules when it comes to slighting someone like R’ Elyashiv. Anyone who has the chutzpah to speak bad about R’ Elyashiv on “Yeshivah World” should find a different forum.
Zahavasdad, I don’t care what your problem is with chareidim. You’re sad, but there will always be people out there like you. But this site is ostensibly meant to be for people associated with the “yeshivish world”. Someone who thinks they know better than Rav Elyashiv definitely doesn’t fall into that category. You might find company more appropriate for yourself on failedmessiah.
January 7, 2013 12:46 am at 12:46 am in reply to: Do Goyim Have A Shidduch Crisis Due To An "Age Gap"? #918194Derech HaMelechMemberProportionally, a lot less of them are getting married altogether.
Derech HaMelechMemberParents- right away.
Everyone else- when it starts becoming obvious.
January 3, 2013 12:57 am at 12:57 am in reply to: Dating/marriage question, Am I realistic…? #917483Derech HaMelechMemberWIY: I don’t know if it’s nogeiah but I have someone in mind. If one of the mods e-mails me I can pass along some information if you want. I’m not a shadchan, it just struck me as a possibility from the impression I have of you.
December 30, 2012 2:10 am at 2:10 am in reply to: To the citizens of the former US of A (humor) #1143494Derech HaMelechMember1. What is a doughnut? And how do you pronounce that: k?fn?t?
…also, please explain how it is more efficient to use more letters.
2. iz this a mor effishent form of comm 4 u?
3. “holiday”? Did you mean “vacation”?
4 What is “grouse”? I’ve never seen grice before.
5. The National Peeler Association will probably fight the requirement for that permit.
6. What is “roundabout”?
… also, what is “metric system”?
7. Since you are pricing gas to the dollar I assume we will be continuing to use the less stable dollar rather than the British Sterling?
8. What is “catsup”?
9. Should we start calling beer “beeur”?
10.
11. Research indicates that the name “soccer” began in England.
12. No baseball is no problem. No one watches it anyway anymore.
13. Only if you tell us the secret to not laughing at court dress.
14. “Monies”? munnies? monnies? mounies? I’m not getting it.
15. Can the American version of tea be replaced with coffee?
December 30, 2012 1:40 am at 1:40 am in reply to: Validity of Vilna Gaon's Cherem Against Chassidim #915951Derech HaMelechMemberAstrix don’t nitpick I don’t think he was trying to be mevazeh chassidim. It’s normal for a litvak to follow the Gra over the Besht. And the truth is that mainstream yiddishkeit at the time was the way of the Gra. The whole point the Baal Shem Tov was making was to make a change to make yiddishkeit more accessible to the am ha’aretz.
Derech HaMelechMemberI used to have contacts. Like everyone is saying, they’ll usually be really dried out come morning and you’ll need to put them in the solution to rehydrate/clean them. The worst case scenario is that they get lost in your eyeball and you need to fish them out from where they’re hiding. I don’t think it’s dangerous, but it feels weird until you get it out.
December 28, 2012 3:10 pm at 3:10 pm in reply to: Which fruits and vegetables should be refrigerated for freshness? #915873Derech HaMelechMemberI don’t know about what you’re talking. We keep our tomatoes in the fridgidair all week.
Derech HaMelechMember1. In tougher economic times, I think it is easy to understand the forethought these tzeddaka organizations have, to offer greater incentives.
2. We live in a society of “more, more, more”. You can either get on the bandwagon or not, but you can’t blame the tzeddaaka organizations for working within the reality of the situation.
December 26, 2012 3:34 pm at 3:34 pm in reply to: Which fruits and vegetables should be refrigerated for freshness? #915870Derech HaMelechMemberLook at what they keep refrigerated in the supermarket.
Mostly just tomatoes, vegetables, berries and fresh fungi.
Bananas, depending on when you buy them, can last at least a few days outside.
Gourds, tubers, onion, garlic- those don’t need to be refrigerated.
Really though, it depends on how long you want them to last.
Derech HaMelechMemberOk but take funnybone’s examples. Wouldn’t have been better use a conjunction (I googled ‘but’, ‘and’ and ‘yet’ and that’s what it said they were).
I am going home; I intend to stay there.
I am going home and I intend to stay there.
It rained heavily in the afternoon; we managed to have our picnic anyway.
It rained heavily in the afternoon, yet we managed to have our picnic anyway.
They couldn’t make it to the summit and back before dark; they decided to camp for the night.
The couldn’t make it to the summit and back before dark so they decided to camp for the night.
It seems to me that when you are connecting two independent clauses with a semicolon instead of a conjunction the sentences sound disjointed.
Derech HaMelechMemberfunnybone: The trick in answering a question is to do it in way that it won’t cause more questions. Such as “what’s an independant clause?”
Derech HaMelechMemberI didn’t even know there was a frum birthright. Or is frum relative in this situation?
Derech HaMelechMemberyekke2: Koresh is called moshiach too in Yeshaya 45:1. Also moshiach means “anointed one” not “Anointed One”.
Derech HaMelechMemberI think the best way to deal with this is to daven facing a wall without anything between you and the wall. Then you close your eyes or look in the siddur for as much of davening as you can and try to concentrate on the words and to Whom you are standing to the exclusion of everything else. That will usually remedy the sickness you are feeling.
December 24, 2012 11:43 pm at 11:43 pm in reply to: Jews protesting against a job fair! How low will they fall? #915773Derech HaMelechMembermdd: Yes, yes we go through these same things every few months here. I’m not saying that in our current situation everyone should learn. What I am saying is that those of us who are working need someone standing at our shoulders constantly reminding us that the ikkur is to be learning so that we don’t get swallowed up in the workplace.
Maybe that is not you, then you can comfortably ignore the Divine message that was sent to those of us who do need it.
Derech HaMelechMemberI have had this problem and when I speak to other people it seems that it doesn’t bother them as much. It seems to me that we both have fathers that are like that and maybe that makes us too sensitive to it. My way of handling it is to be terse and finish communications quickly so at to limit contact with the offending individual. That’s not necessarily the best way though.
Derech HaMelechMemberpopa: I wouldn’t say anyone can use it. I can’t.
HaLeivi: So basically you use it when you want to write a run-on sentence?
I don’t remember when I used it, I just remember having used it. Maybe during my stint trying to get through Ubuntu? or Python? I really don’t remember. I just remember having pressed it because I’m not used to using it.
uneeq: I was going for “the secret that is ‘the semicolon’.”
December 24, 2012 2:45 pm at 2:45 pm in reply to: A Gartel, a tie and An Arab string around headdress – what is the connection? #915021Derech HaMelechMemberThe Chossid’s upper body doesn’t communicate with his lower self.
The Litvak’s mind is disconnected from his heart.
The Arab cuts off the critical thought processes of his upper brain so that it doesn’t get in the way of what he wants to do.
Derech HaMelechMemberI would blame the school.
Unless I work there. Then it’s the parents’ fault.
I think supervision on the bus would have prevented the issue to some extent. But on the other hand, it’s not that easy to manage a whole bus of children. They are more like sheep than we are and a few kids can make the whole bus go crazy. Unfortunately, the lead sheep is never a lemele. That’s just how children are. It’s our job to train them out of this behavior and teach them to be self-critical by the time they reach adulthood. But you don’t expect a 3 month old child to start walking and you shouldn’t expect bus-age children to not act like sheep.
December 24, 2012 2:00 pm at 2:00 pm in reply to: Jews protesting against a job fair! How low will they fall? #915750Derech HaMelechMemberI agree with HaKatan. They are presenting a valid concern albeit through a means that you are uncomfortable with. I don’t think it is right to label them zealots because of the negative connotation of that word, although I do believe they are being zealous in their desire to keep the klal in the Beis Medrish. That’s not a bad thing. If no one would remind us where we are supposed to be, eventually we will forget.
To you they may appear uncivilized in their manner of protest. Unfortunately, the atmosphere in E”Y is such that this is the only way to really be heard by a community that doesn’t use media. But make no mistake, they are providing a service for the all of us.
Derech HaMelechMemberMerchandising.
Do you mean fundraising?
Derech HaMelechMemberDouble daled. Although oddly, I wrap inward.
Derech HaMelechMemberSome of us don’t live in the selected Brooklyn neighborhoods …
Derech HaMelechMemberDo you either make your own wicks or use loosely twisted cotton ones? I think it just needs to be a little tight and not too long on top.
Derech HaMelechMemberuneeq: I don’t think that’s true though. I think a person’s conscience speaks up according to how sensitive a person is to the issues involved in each case. There’s not always a clear-cut answer on issues of sensitivity, for each person it could be different- but that doesn’t mean some are wrong.
In any case, Seahorse already gave a number of very clear reasons.
-
AuthorPosts