Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
Because the other “opinions” are wrong. It isn’t like both sides are right, different minhagim, different approach, etc. We honestly believe the other practices are objectively wrong and an incorrect and invalid approach to yiddishkeit.
Hungarian Jewish traditions are preserved in many communities in NY.
Sam, I dont know if you are correct about that last point you just made to me, but it is a different issue and irrelevant to your earlier point regarding NY’s (and any States) anti-polygamy laws. My previous point still stands.
Some of our grandparents only ate fruits and vegetables in the concentration camps to avoid treif. And here people are eating Hershy chocolate bars without a hechsher??
Sam, NY state law only considers it polygamy if he is *civilally* married to two people. (If you had been correct, then a woman who got a civil divorce but not a get and civilally remarried without a get would be guilty of polygamy in NY. But she is not.)
Isn’t Rav Abadi pretty much almost the only Orthodox rabbi who takes that position? Can anyone name anyone specifically who wouldn’t disagree?
Popa and mdd: well said.
How do you know the machinery used to make the food products wasn’t also used with treif ingredients on other products made with the same machinery?
yit – how do you know the machinery used to make the food products wasn’t also used with treif ingredients on other products made with the same machinery?
Even IF he was wrong, and it sure sounds he wasn’t, they have no right to embarrass his mother or father. They are not responsible. So all the demonstrators are sinners.
Any rov can be one of the 100 rabbonim that sign a HMR?
apushtayid, kollel guy isn’t telling you that you have to necessarily follow Rav Elyashev’s shittos. Just that no one should dismiss Rav Elyashev’s shittos or “bans” by trying to initiate that Rav Elyashev was fooled or didn’t realize what he was doing or was mistaken.
Sam, if a man can give his wife a get against her will, why then would a HMR ever be needed?
Also, how does he force her to accept the get? He just puts it into her mailbox, if she refuses to take it from him?
Rav Shach was against frum people going to the army.
Soo, if people on the street aren’t supposed to tell girls they see dressed inappropriately that they are doing something very wrong, and you are saying their fathers and husbands also shouldn’t be telling them that, then WHO exactly should tell adult girls and women that are dressed non tznius that they are dressed inappropriately???? (Especially when it’s the wife with the tznius problem…..)
Covering hair prpoperly and dressing modestly is halacha, not chumra.
What if those guys get mace also?
How is covering your hair properly “hypocritically out-frumming” those people who don’t cover their hair properly or dress immodestly??
flowers, s/he also clearly denied that s/he ever posted on Shabbos. What evidence do you have other than the admins hearsay? And considering the admins admitted errors in previous accusations here, I’d say that hearsay isn’t worth the pixels on the screen used to make these terrible accusations!
We don’t let them flip the switch on, in shul, yitay.
Still, I’m not accepting that this is even the case here. There have been too many false accusations that later were admitted to have been a total error here.
lol, I think he spelled “so like” wrong too.
MCP – she is an eishes ish, so it’s actually much worse than the other type of situation.
If the poster is in Australia, did you check the EXACT Shabbos zmanim for every part of Australia, and compare them to the EXACT times of the relevant posts, before leveling serious accusations??