BrooklynGirl7

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: A Hashkafa Question I have no one to ask #2321283
    BrooklynGirl7
    Participant

    First of all, I think there are probably better addresses to bring your questions to than this forum, where you’d find higher quality responses, which you deserve to hear.

    That said, I will take a stab at it, because I wonder if your interest goes beyond just time bound mitzvos, as yr second question is leading there…

    The first question induces a corollary question – if women are exempt from time-bound mitzvos because they need to care for children, why would girls or women who aren’t mothers of children be included? Perhaps a more nuanced reflection on women and their nature is implied.

    If you acknowledge that women and men are – ba’gadol – different (acknowledging that all women have some “masculine” energies and vice versa), that is still within a large spectrum of difference. We all know women who are more logical and analytical, and could probably learn gemara better than some men, but the reality is that most women do not relish a purely abstract mental avodah – if it’s not tied to SOMETHING, it is just annoying. Men, in general, have a much greater tolerance for the ungrounded pure pilpul that is necessary for real gemara learning. (No question that some men have a greater need for “bringing it down” than others – but for real Talmud Torah, the machshava requires a lot of purely theoretical shteiging. )

    Al pi Torah hashkafa, the superpower of women is to take the input from the mashpia, and bring it down into the world of Asiya – not just in the physical realm, but even in the realm of thought – women can smell the implications for a certain line of thinking in terms of chinuch or social endeavors much quicker than men – in general. (No way to have this discussion without some generalizing, so just will say it once and assume that every generalization has its exception.)

    As a woman who happens to have a pretty strong analytical capacity (got 95% on my LSATs), I see how empowering this superpower is – consider the verses of Ayshes Chayil – that is my vision for Jewish femininity – and I see why time bound mitzvos would tie down and inhibit my impact.

    (A good question you should ask is why do men need time-bound mitzvos? Lots of hashkafa on that topic, but the obvious implication is that the same koach to go all analytical requires these anchors to stay firmly attached to the ground.)

    Forgive me if I read between the lines something you aren’t saying, and that might not be there, but it seems that you are equating the external role of these mitzvos and the way we, as a society, relate to them, as being somehow more “choshuv” than what women are doing.

    By definition, a girl who is bas mitzvaed, should have the same hargasha that she has entered a new level, and feel the gravitas of that new stage. But socially – depending on what community you are in – the celebration of this new level may be very minimized, and that is perhaps too bad for some girls, like yourself that feel “less than” because of it.

    But even bar mitzva celebrations for boys are totally different between communities, and in some communities, it’s not the big extravaganza that it is in others. So you have to distinguish Torah hashkafa from the hanhagos of different communities.

    Know that within your role as a young woman, you can achieve tremendous accomplishments in your avodas H’ and become an “Isha chashuva” , even without the time-bound mitzvos.

    Although if there is something specific you’d like to do, ask a rav — there are many women that have taken upon themselves mitzvos like davening maariv or shaking lulav and esrog to enhance their avoda. Certainly there we all have to “personalize” our avodas H’, if we want to be the best Jews we can be. No one can really just rely on what everyone else is doing if they want to actualize their full potential.

    You sound like a thoughtful person with big kochos – and you may have some needs that lie outside the typical, but you still wholesome and Torah-true ways to fulfill them. Don’t give up on asking questions and searching for emesdich answers!

    Two good sources on feminine vs masculine roles are the book by Miriam Kosman, Circle, Arrow, Spiral, and the classes of Tamar Tabak online. Both ladies have done their research and offer many sources you may find encouraging to appreciate your role as a Jewish woman. Hatzlacha and a sweet year to you!

    in reply to: Marriage for widowed seniors… #2164839
    BrooklynGirl7
    Participant

    First of all, please accept my condolences for your loss. A beloved spouse, with whom you built a family, can never be replaced.

    That said, BE”H, you can find much happiness – and bring happiness to another at this phase of life, creating new memories and a new “family” feeling. I applaud your sensitivity for concern about how to best prepare your children for this new relationship, as even if they are fully grown and independent, a new marraige will affect them in many ways.

    The first thing is to have a family discussion that you are feeling ready to explore dating again, and to reassure them that anyone you would marry would also need to appreciate your relationship with them. Ideally, before you make any decisions (which are yours alone to make ultimately), it would be kind to take things slowly and for them to have a chance to meet her and get used to the idea.

    One of the big reasons for negativity of children surrounding a senior parent’s remarriage, is that surrounding inheritance. It would be good to consider how your remarriage may impact their potential inheritance and make some plans, according to what you deem appropriate. It may make sense to draft a pre-nuptial agreement, as anti-romantic as that sounds, it’s also reasonable for those who have significant assets.

    Regarding housing and relocation, i think that is wholly individual and must be decided in the context of the potential relationship. If relocation to another area is not an option, just make that clear prior to embarking on another relationship.

    I wish you the best of luck finding a warm and sympatico companion to share life’s blessings with. 🙂

    in reply to: Shidduchim Between Litvish Girls and Chasidish Boys #2157712
    BrooklynGirl7
    Participant

    The clearest example of how the “age gap” does matter is that in Eretz Yisrael, where boys generally begin shidduchim at 21 and girls at 20, there is no numbers crisis within the Litvish community.

    Were it true that chassidim have that many more potential “extra” chossonim to account for the 15% extra kallahs in Litvish circles, you would have a point. But since most people would not consider such a shidduch for their childbecause of the dangers of such a cultural chasm between the potential spouses, one can assume that people would make it an option of last resort.

    So what age would the girls be? 28? And if by chassidish boys the age was 23 or 24, how would this solve anything?

    Better solution – everyone becomes “heimishe” and then intermarries! 🤣

    Seriously, since social engineering usually generates a bad outcome, maybe we should all dial back our preconceived notions and hakpados and open ourselves to bracha from Above. How? By being more focused on the personality of the potential shidduch, rather than leaving it as a last piece, after all the boxes are checked.

    As a group, we have lost our a way a bit – and all of the obstacles we justify are self-inflicted.

    in reply to: Question for Frum Jews who are anti Trump #2055932
    BrooklynGirl7
    Participant

    EJMRBro, you wrote “I have thrown the proverbial grenade into this chat and have learned there are more libs on this site than I thought.

    Maybe the next poast should be about how many of you support toeiva.”

    Classic example of the sophisticated thinking that abounds here — are those the only alternatives?

    EMJRBro, I guess it’s funny to yank everyone’s chains, but it actually would be positive for people to explain their non-conformist opinions, as in the never-Trump people, because maybe, just maybe, we might learn something from comparing opinions.

    Personally, as a Torah-Jew, I am completely repulsed by Trump’s personality, pleased by many of his policies – esp towards Israel – and still so weirded out by the lionizing of him by the velt. We haven’t show so much enthusiasm for any politician in recorded history. Why did we pick someone so personally objectionable?

    I wish wish wish someone who actually has a brain AND conservative values AND normal kiddos would run a successful campaign, but I’m afraid that is not in the cards.

    I reject both of your options. When it came to Hilary and Trump, I couldn’t vote for either. Last round, I held my nose and preferred Trump, but his big diatribe against Netanyahu was no surprise to me — Trump really has no values besides himself, so like a baby he tantrums… He could turn on us as fast as he supported us, as the spirit moves him.

    If it’s Trump vs Biden, I will have to abstain again.

    I think we all need to simply look upwards – that is the takeaway. Ein Od Milvado.

    Why are so many frum people busy with this nonsense?!?

Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)