Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
June 30, 2025 9:23 am at 9:23 am in reply to: How Should Israel Thank the United States for American Military and Economic Aid #2419674ardParticipant
yb- you dont have to post the same thing on every thread, its annoying
ardParticipantyes were still in golus, unless i somehow missed eliyahu
ardParticipantcoffee- none2 will respond to you that mordechai was wrong to tell the yidden to do teshuva
ardParticipantnone2 doesnt hold of halacha (see wheres hashem thread) some i wouldnt be too keen to accept mussar from her
June 30, 2025 9:23 am at 9:23 am in reply to: Rabbi Yaakov Kamenetsky and the modern State of Israel #2419670ardParticipantum if somejews source is yaakov then yaakov also prepared for war (also see the entire tanach where jews fight back, WHEN directed by daas torah)
ardParticipantthe ramban in this weeks parsha states that throughout all of time there will be people who stand up and challenge the nevuah of moshe and the mesora we received going back to him, he says about those people that their forefathers did not stand at har sinai
ardParticipantand just to make it clear for everyone else who might not be aware that youre a karaite, do you deny the oral torah, how do you know all the halachos lmoshe misinai, and are you great enough to make all the correct derashos (something that was lost with the amoraim) and decree all the drabbanans? please give a yes or no answer, do you believe in the torah shebaal peh?
ardParticipantand your translation point was irrelevant, besides for the fact that words actually do not always translate to their exact and true meaning in another language, who translated the torah for you and how do you know to trust them if “they also make mistakes” the christians also translated the torah and made many errors.
ardParticipantnone2- i dont refute all of your points because theres no one home to argue with, if you cant accept that the torah is a hard rulebook with very defined laws, then nothing i can say, every single sefer written ever from the chumash to mesilas yesharim to the noam elimelech is clear beyond any doubt that halacha is nonnegotiable and applicable to everyone, you in your delusion somehow continue to deny this, therefore i dont try to convince you since you are teflon to any argument, instead i try to distance others from you as halacha warrants
ardParticipantno ones making you buy a 500$ esrog and i know of a prominent posek who sells his chabura matzah for 40 a pound, i dont know why it costs so much but i can guarantee hes not cheating anyone
ardParticipantnone2 reminds me of a gemara, elazar ben poera was a tzeduki who lived during the second bais hamikdash, he convinced the king yannai to kill all the talmidei chachamim, when yannai asked him what will become of the torah he responded “the torah is lying rolled up in a corner let whoever wants come and read from it”
ardParticipantalso the torah is not written in english and if not for those “very smart people who also make mistakes” you would not be able to read it, (unless you use the king james authorized version, and im not convinced youre not a missionary, though you would be a pretty stupid one), apparently if you were running society you would gouge out an eye for an eye
ardParticipantalso”Regardless, that not the point a true biblical life is one filled with gratitude towards G-d not doctrine it’s about living _with_ G-d not rituals” and “I’m very sorry ard but the Torah itself is a book that is written in the most simplistic English/Hebrew and can be understood by _everyone_ the commentary aspect you speak of is just that an opinion. Of very smart people I’m sure. But smart people also make mistakes. If you fallow someone blindly without discerning whether what they say _is_ the truth and just fallow them because they say you should you are still sadly responsible for the choices you make and the wrong ones are still your responsibility.”
ardParticipant“Sorry what’s the point in writing a book at all if it needs to be interpreted by a thousand people for a thousand years and none is allowed to r read the actual book” wow she really took my tzeduki reference to heart, and i can finally say i am now 100% certain that shes a kofer
June 26, 2025 10:04 am at 10:04 am in reply to: How Should Israel Thank the United States for American Military and Economic Aid #2418470ardParticipantits funny how people dont even respond to fandango
ardParticipanthappy new year- thats ridiculous how many open zionists have been attacked in the us, no one cares about the nk and we are not required to thank ovrei avera for the (nonexistent) good that comes from their action
ardParticipanthakatan- literally every pro-zionist poster has strongly condemned the bad (mostly original) zionists
ardParticipant” So everything is just a theory. A thought a hunch. A feeling. Atruth. So relax. It’s not set in stone” um nope halacha (and truth) is set in stone. saying otherwise will land you on the open-orthodox-reconstructionist spectrum, and were not blasting you because youre different, it is actually a mitzva to speak lashon hara about a kofer even about things with no relation to his (or her in this case) kefira (cc hlh 8:7) in order to distance others from the person and prevent the kefira from spreading, do you deny this halacha? this isnt even lashon hara and were directly addressing you
ardParticipantand its actually hilarious how you keep bringing up liberals, one of the key tenets of current left-wing craziness is that everyone has their own truth and it is oppressive to force your truth onto anyone else, which fits quite well into this discussion, just maybe not the way you would like it to
ardParticipantim very sorry to inform you none2 but you cant make your own torah. there are halachos that define someone as a kofer and while i cant for sure you definitely appear to at least come very close to the line (although those halachos probably dont fit into real life, right?) and yes youre correct the torah does not allow you to “think for yourself” when diverge from it. korach, zimri, yeravam, menashe, the tzedukim, acher, the karaim, moses mendelssohn, stephen wise, and avi weiss all thought for themselves, please tell me why they were wrong
ardParticipantcrazy suspiciously hasnt posted since motzaei shabbos
June 23, 2025 7:08 am at 7:08 am in reply to: How Should Israel Thank the United States for American Military and Economic Aid #2416474ardParticipantcrazy suspiciously hasnt posted since motzaei shabbos
ardParticipantR’ Zilbershtein sleeps on a board as a reminder of the hostages while hakatan says that supporting hamas is Hashems message
ardParticipanthakatan is showing his true colors, hugging the sponsors of the murderers of thousands of jews is not the torahs message, the nk support the mass murder of yidden (whose death is considered al kiddush hashem), im not a zionist but there are many dl people who are far closer to hashem than hakatan
ardParticipantor “The fact that you think we care what the lubavitxh rebbe said. Lol sorry but I’m tired of this blind fath and G-dlike whatever you partain to him so he said something great. I also said something”
ardParticipantand only the christians say gomorra, not even artscroll translates it like that
ardParticipantnone2 is clearly not a normative jew, just look at his other posts like “Goes to show halacha isn’t realistic. End of story lol. Does it fit. It doesn’t fit. Everyone needs to live in reality. Wake up” thats literally kefira
ardParticipantwell this aged well
ardParticipantwhy wasnt my comment posted
ardParticipantnone 2.0 is clearly not frum and all those women who are offended by the torahs “misogyny” get over it. yes in your definition of sexism the torah is misogynistic, see daatos nashim kalos hein etc. it is also racist (cham was cursed to have dark skin and his son canaan to be a slave forever, cham inhabited africa) as well as extremely homo and transphobic. women have a different role than men just as kohanim have different roles as yisraelim, trying to say the metzius and halacha changed without gadol-level support is like trying to say the torah doesnt mean for us to keep kashrus out of the home anymore
June 17, 2025 11:00 am at 11:00 am in reply to: Its good to look back (Trumps 60 day threat) #2413185ardParticipantsam klein is sam kol ayin a poison that is entirely nothingness (see his divrei torah)
ardParticipantagreed
ardParticipantthere are many stories like this
June 8, 2025 9:04 pm at 9:04 pm in reply to: circa 1900: Letter from Lubavitcher Rebbe, the Heresy of “Religious” Zionism #2407910ardParticipantif any of the antizionists here are actually peleg or satmar they would not accept the rebbe as a source
ardParticipantnone2- oops you said gomorrah, perhaps a missionary?
ardParticipantits surprising that gedolim agree to speak at it at all
June 5, 2025 9:52 am at 9:52 am in reply to: Jewish critics of the State of Israel, where do they reside? #2406507ardParticipantyankel- im not following this thread closely but i happened to notice your comment. again i made it clear that what i said applies to people on both sides of the debate. a possible exception might be quoting a gadol directly
May 31, 2025 10:20 pm at 10:20 pm in reply to: Rabbi Moshe Sherer and the modern State of Israel #2405414ardParticipantaaq-hakatan is quoting r’ elchanan because there are quotes from him that are (supposedly) relevant. we could also tell you about the greatness of the chofetz chaim but that wouldnt have anything to do with this thread
May 31, 2025 10:20 pm at 10:20 pm in reply to: Jewish critics of the State of Israel, where do they reside? #2405411ardParticipantI hope everyone on this thread knows the gemara that likens someone who speaks lashon hara about talmidei chachamim to an apikores
May 31, 2025 10:20 pm at 10:20 pm in reply to: Jewish critics of the State of Israel, where do they reside? #2405410ardParticipantwhy do people on both sides of this debate think it is anywhere near okay to speak lashon hara (really motzi shem ra) about the gedolei olam who also exist on both sides and are thousands of times smarter and more righteous than them
May 31, 2025 10:20 pm at 10:20 pm in reply to: Jewish critics of the State of Israel, where do they reside? #2405409ardParticipantyankelberel- CONGRATULATIONS!! Your decision to call the Satmar Rebbe a disgrace has made you the lucky winner of one free ticket straight to gehennom. (terms and conditions apply, void with teshuva)
May 29, 2025 2:38 pm at 2:38 pm in reply to: Chanyana Weissman and the modern State of Israel #2404687ardParticipantsquareroot=chananya weissman
May 28, 2025 6:51 pm at 6:51 pm in reply to: Chanyana Weissman and the modern State of Israel #2404259ardParticipantwho is chananya weissman
ardParticipantwhen other yeshivos were started in america like tora vodaas chofetz chaim and bmg
May 23, 2025 4:35 pm at 4:35 pm in reply to: Writing notes, Chazoro and Memorising my Learning #2402829ardParticipantand who told you its important for a bachur to memorize
May 23, 2025 4:35 pm at 4:35 pm in reply to: Writing notes, Chazoro and Memorising my Learning #2402827ardParticipantfor chazara- use 123 method- day 1 learn 1 day 2 learn 12 day 3 learn 123 day 4 learn 234 day 5 learn 345 etc. that way everything is learnt 3 times- endorsed by a gadol of the previous generation
ardParticipant2 dollars and twenty cents to arrange exemptions isnt that much if you really think about it
May 23, 2025 4:35 pm at 4:35 pm in reply to: Rabbi Yaakov Kamenetsky and the modern State of Israel #2402814ardParticipanthakatan- do you think every (or at least the vast vast majority) gadol agrees with your view on zionism or if not because they were lied to
May 20, 2025 1:10 pm at 1:10 pm in reply to: Rabbi Yaakov Kamenetsky and the modern State of Israel #2400975ardParticipantrabbi paysach krohn said he knows that unlike other authors yonoson rosenblum makes sure to only print true stories with a verified source
May 19, 2025 11:30 am at 11:30 am in reply to: Divide among Torah Schools of Thought: YU/RIETS vs The Greater Yeshiva World #2400535ardParticipantrav aharon cried (out of humility) and tried to stop him when r’ joseph b called him the gadol hador at the first annual dinner of chinuch atzmai, which rav aharon specifically asked him to be honorary chairman of. (source: the first biography of r’ aharon, written by r’ alter pekier)
-
AuthorPosts