Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
anon for thisParticipant
NY Mom, I didn’t realize that either until I was in high school, but it’s definitely true. Jesse is indeed Yishai though. I also didn’t know that the name Jemima is from nach.
anon for thisParticipantNY Mom, I know a little girl named Yiskah. Of course Jessica used to be a very popular name, though less so now.
anon for thisParticipantThere’s a well-known Israeli biblical scholar named Avashalom Kor.
Perhaps the boy’s name Shilah is a derivative of Shaila (Yehudah’s third son, so not unfortunate as Onan) or Shiloh.
anon for thisParticipant#25 is the title of one of one of the songs in _The Music Man_, a musical by Meredith Wilson which was (inexplicably) a Broadway hit in 1957.
#26 is an advertising slogan created by Stan Freberg for Contadina tomato paste.
anon for thisParticipantBen Levi, my point is that the hospital was refusing to treat my father, who was on private insurance. They were also trying to take him off the ventilator in the guise of “apnea testing”, and probably would have succeeded in doing so if not for the fact that one of his visitors was a physician who knew what was going on. Whether this was legal or not I cannot say; all I know is that this is what happened.
anon for thisParticipantJAW22, I’m married and didn’t deal with a “shadchan meeting” (my employer arranged my shidduch with someone he knew), but from what I’ve read and heard many young women report similar experiences with shadchan meetings. Because the young women feel this is the only way to find a shidduch, they allow themselves to be subjected to this anyways.
anon for thisParticipanthaifagirl, end-of-life care is an issue for those on private insurance too. When my father was in the ICU, the hospital staff kept trying to take him off the ventilator for “apnea testing” and then “forgetting” to put him back on. My siblings and I took turns staying by his bed to keep this from recurring.
Also, most private insurance companies have lifetime limits, generally of about $1 million. They will not cover any expenses incurred beyond this amount.
Regarding Medicaid, the physicians I’ve spoken too say that there’s a significant difference in coverage between Medicaid plans managed by private HMOs and those managed by Medicaid itself. Generally the latter type offers better coverage.
I do agree with you about the VA. People I know who’ve worked at VA hospitals tell me that the treatment there is not very good. Really our veterans deserve better than that.
anon for thisParticipantSince ICOT asked…I’ll submit my thoughts. I have a master’s degree–in science! (actually engineering, but I used to listen to a radio program that included this line).
I think that it would be nice if more schools could offer AP courses, but that isn’t realistic. What is realistic, and important, is to expect all schools offering chol subjects to teach the basic high school classes properly. This means clarifying to students that the chol teachers and subjects are deserving of their time, attention, and best efforts, even if they can’t–and shouldn’t–spend as much time on these subjects as their public school peers.
I do believe that students should know basic historical facts. No, they don’t need to know when Lincoln was elected to Congress, but they should know the facts about his presidency and the Civil War (especially because in some ways this country is still living with its aftereffects). If historical accounts are sometimes subject to falsehood and speculation as feivel argues, that’s all the more reason to teach students the facts, so they’ll recognize when someone is trying to deceive them.
I think the currently required high school classes will give students a basic grounding in math and science as well. As GAW noted, this will make it possible for students who choose to attend college to major in math/engineering/medicine without requiring semesters of remedial work. Also, this will allow students interested in college to get a glimpse of different areas of study, so they can understand which ones they are well-suited for.
Even those who have no intention of attending college can benefit from basic knowledge these classes can offer. Most of us in our daily routines are confronted with various scientific & mathematical claims: “Vaccines cause autism!” or “You can double your money in a year by investing in my fund!” A basic knowledge of math and science gives one the tools to critically evaluate this sort of information.
Leaving the issue of studying literature, it’s essential for students to learn how to read, write, and think clearly and coherently. Others have noted that many posters on message boards don’t write coherently, but what’s alarming is that a sizable minority don’t seem to think clearly or understand what they’re reading.
anon for thisParticipantsmartcookie, it’s possible that your child is not chewing his food properly (also called “pocketing” food) because the muscles in his mouth aren’t strong enough. Low oral muscle tone can also cause speech difficulties. Speech therapy targeting the appropriate muscles can help with both problems.
If your child also has speech difficulties, google the words “early intervention” with the name of your state to find out about how to get your child evaluated. Often the evaluation can be done for free at your home.
anon for thisParticipantHSS, I did not mean to imply that my year in seminary was not a valuable one. On the contrary, it was a spiritually enriching experience. While the hanhala of my seminary generally disagreed with college attendance, the ideas I learned there, and what I learned about myself, prepared me for college and for life afterwards in a way that my high school education did not.
However, I still maintain that my year in seminary did not teach me as much about living independently as my freshman year in college did. My years in college, among people who knew very little about Judaism, forced me think about why I keep the Torah. In a way, this time, and my time in the workforce afterwards, were a kind of practicum where I applied the Jewish education I’d received.
anon for thisParticipantHSS, when I was in seminary most of my needs were provided for, and I had fewer responsibilities than at home. I did wash my own laundry & keep my room neat, but I did this at home also. The seminary provided three meals daily, so I did not have to cook my own meals; at home I helped prepare food for shabbos & cleaned up also, besides helping younger siblings with their homework. My parents provided an allowance that was more than adequate for bus fare, school supplies, and other expenses. No one had cell phones then, but my parents called me a couple of times each month & I wrote to them two or three times a week.
After attending seminary in E’Y I lived in my parents’ home while attending a local university. Even though I was living at home, I was in some ways more independent than I was while in seminary. I chose my major, planned which courses to take, bought my textbooks, and of course was responsible for my own coursework. My parents provided room & board, while I applied for scholarships and worked to cover tuition, fees, and books. At the beginning of each fall term, I’d arrange with my professors and TAs to make up tests, quizzes, and labs missed due to the Yomim Noraim.
anon for thisParticipantIt is a lovely, inspiring story. But its message would be better understood and received if it were written more coherently.
anon for thisParticipantmybat, you may be better off if you share less information with her. When my children were very young, I used to call my mother-in-law after their check-ups to let her know how much they weighed & how they were doing. Once I called her after my son’s check-up & she asked me if I had allowed him to receive the MMR (measles-mumps-rubella) vaccine. When I told her that he did receive it, she told me it would probably make him autistic, since she knew someone whose child stopped talking shortly after receiving it.
Most of my children started talking late, and my mother-in-law knew I was concerned about that, so I did not find that comment helpful. But I did learn to stop discussing my children’s health & development with her.
anon for thisParticipantNY Mom, do you live in NYC? If so, I’ve heard there are swine flu vaccination clinics on Sundays in November & December; call 311 for more information.
NJ health officials announced yesterday that there were 6 swine flu deaths in the state this past week.
anon for thisParticipanthaifagirl, live donor liver transplants (actually part of the liver) are relatively new, and are only done at certain medical centers. These constitute about one-third of liver transplants in the US. Most recipients are children.
November 19, 2009 12:47 am at 12:47 am in reply to: What Newspaper / Magazine do You Read / Trust Most? #681653anon for thisParticipantenlightenedjew, every time I read the Journal I learn something new, even about stories I thought I understood well. Their coverage of science & medical news is also informative and easy to understand.
EDITED
November 19, 2009 12:43 am at 12:43 am in reply to: Should We Give The H1N1 Vaccine For Kids #671935anon for thisParticipantronsnr, the motivation for posting that video about the cheerleader with dystonia is to “prove” to people the danger of the swine flu vaccine. As my post above explains, though, her dystonia was psychogenic in nature, and as such, not attributable to any vaccine.
November 18, 2009 10:19 pm at 10:19 pm in reply to: Should We Give The H1N1 Vaccine For Kids #671929anon for thisParticipantMany people became concerned about complications from the swine flue vaccine after a cheerleader reported that she had been diagnosed with dystonia–a movement disorder in the brain–shortly after she received the vaccine. She claimed that physicians at Johns Hopkins examined her and provided this diagnosis; however, she didn’t give her treatment team permission to discuss her case, so they couldn’t confirm her statements. Other neurological experts who observed tapes of her moving maintain that her illness is psychogenic, and therefore not a result of any vaccine.
Luckily, she now says that she was cured through chelation therapy, which she claims removed the toxins from the vaccine that had affected her brain. She reports that within minutes of beginning the therapy, her symptoms began to resolve. Neurologists have noted that someone suffering from true dystonia could not experience a cure that quickly. The brain damage which causes dystonia simply doesn’t go away that fast. This lightning-fast “cure” confirms that her disease was psychogenic. This isn’t to say she was “faking”; she may well have believed that her movement problems were caused by the vaccine.
November 18, 2009 9:51 pm at 9:51 pm in reply to: What Newspaper / Magazine do You Read / Trust Most? #681651anon for thisParticipantI consider the Wall Street Journal a reliable source of news, and it generally does not have the same issues of inappropriate content as the NY Post does. National and international news stories are covered objectively and in-depth. Coverage of celebrity and sports “news” is almost non-existent, but that’s fine with me.
anon for thisParticipantWhich government programs provide help for Lakewood tuition?
anon for thisParticipantOomis, the segula of a pregnant woman going to the mikvah is one that is new to me. When I was pregnant, I would give to the tzedaka Efrat-CRIB, which provides financial support to pregnant women in eretz yisroel, in hope that this zchus would help me have a healthy pregnancy, delivery, and child. I do not have any specific halachic basis for this though, other than the well-known chazal “tzedaka tatzil mimaves”.
anon for thisParticipantRav Miller is quoted as saying that girls should marry soon after graduation. At what age did he say boys should marry?
anon for thisParticipantGood point tzippi. Because the nasal vaccines contain live, albeit weakened, virus, they are contraindicated for anyone with a compromised immune system.
Oomis’s point that pregnant women need to be vigilant about what medicines/ vaccines they take is a good one. Many pregnant women have safely taken the seasonal flu vaccine safely, so there is no reason for a pregnant woman to be more concerned than anyone else about taking the vaccine. And since the H1N1 vaccine is not materially different, except for the strains included, it is also safe for pregnant women.
Epidimiologists have noted that pregnant women are particularly vulnerable to H1N1, and are infected at greater rates than the general population. In addition, pregnant women are more likely than others to become very sick or die from the H1N1 virus.
anon for thisParticipantThe injectable form of the H1N1 vaccine contains killed virus, but the nasal version contains weakened virus. That’s why the latter is not recommended for infants. The seasonal flu vaccine is also distributed in both forms.
November 13, 2009 7:40 am at 7:40 am in reply to: Anyone Else Worried About Today’s Frum Music? #793139anon for thisParticipanthaifagirl, thanks for the correction. Wikipedia had it correct also, I just read it wrong.
November 12, 2009 12:01 am at 12:01 am in reply to: Anyone Else Worried About Today’s Frum Music? #793133anon for thisParticipantPer Wikipedia, the lyrics for “Morning has Broken” are by Eleanor Farjeon, set to an old Gaelic tune. Cat Stevens did convert to Islam shortly before recording the song.
November 10, 2009 10:09 pm at 10:09 pm in reply to: Should We Give The H1N1 Vaccine For Kids #671880anon for thisParticipantarc, so the H1N1 vaccine is about as different from the regular flu vaccine as the seasonal flu vaccine from one year is different from the seasonal flu vaccine of the previous year. And the safety & efficacy of the seasonal flu vaccine has been well-established, based on years of research. So there is no reason to think the H1N1 vaccine is not safe.
anon for thisParticipantI have a question about the H1N1 vaccine: I’ve heard people say (here & elsewhere) that the H1N1 vaccine is “new”. But isn’t the seasonal flu vaccine “new” every year, since it includes the strains that were prevalent in Asia during the previous spring? In what way is the H1N1 vaccine different from the seasonal flu vaccine, besides that the virus strains are different? Are any other components of the H1N1 different from the seasonal flu vaccine?
anon for thisParticipantPY, are you saying that this idea is meant more as a mental exercise (for singles or others) than as an actual tool for creating matches? If so, then I see it very differently.
I’ve heard of that gemara, but I’m not sure whether it means that a woman would marry anyone at all–even someone who is violent or abusive–just so that she can be married, or just that she would marry someone who is not her ideal. If the former, in my opinion the gemara is describing what it true for some women, but this would not necessarily be a good environment in which to grow healthy families and children.
anon for thisParticipanttamazahall, are you saying that Aramaic is a holy language? If so, is Aramaic the same as Arabic? I thought they were different languages.
anon for thisParticipanttelegrok, thanks for sharing that story. You might say that it’s an argument for A600KiloBear’s modification of PY’s idea–a goral for shidduch dates, not shidduchim. Such a goral could even include a requirement that the matched couple only be allowed to date each other for a period of time.
However, in your story your future husband was already interested in meeting you, even if you were not interested in meeting him. In this goral, neither party would even know the other’s identity before meeting.
haifagirl, I see that I’ve offended you, and that wasn’t my intention. Please forgive me. To clarify what I was saying, I know that my acquaintances, older singles in their late twenties to early thirties, would definitely not be interested in a polygamous marriage or forced marriage to someone to whom they’ve been matched via lottery. Obviously I can’t speak for you, and I wouldn’t think I can. I only meant to say that in order to make a polygamous marriage work, both the husband and “sister wives” must agree to the arrangement. Ideally, the polygamous family should also live in a community of other polygamous families. And based on my conversations with older singles of my acquaintance (including relatives), there are not enough women to make this plan work.
The goral proposed by PY would also require a critical mass of people willing to participate, and again I don’t think the interest exists.
anon for thisParticipantWow, this is the first time I’ve agreed with every post (okay, both posts) that A600KiloBear has made in a thread.
haifagirl, I know several older singles. None of them would be interested in either a polygamous marriage or a shidduch by goral.
anon for thisParticipantaussie, when I was at BJJ some of the students were from more chassidish families, thought they definitely did not constitute the majority.
anon for thisParticipanthaifagirl, I don’t think we can necessarily extrapolate this sort of data from the marriages of our Avos & Imahos to our own. The medrash tells us that Yitzchok Avinu was 40 when he married Rivka, who was three. And Yaakov Avinu married two sisters.
anon for thisParticipanthaifagirl, if you don’t feel like cooking dinner, there’s always frozen dinners or takeout.
Unless you meant that in a metaphorical sense.
anon for thisParticipantstarwolf, exactly. Hospitals risk losing federal funding if they employ illegals as attending physicians or in their training programs.
anon for thisParticipantA600KiloBear, foreign medical grads working in US hospitals have H1B or J1 visas, so they’re not concerned about ICE.
anon for thisParticipantMM, in discussing American attitudes toward polygamy, of course their views regarding its morality are important. Obviously belief that a behavior is morally wrong correlates with antgonism towards that behavior. What is difficult to understand about that?
Based on the statistics I cited in my earlier post, I think that same-gender marriage will be declared legal throughout the country long before polygamy is.
anon for thisParticipantMM, I never said that Americans are good “barometers” of moral behavior; I was simply responding to your post. When I wrote that polygamy is unpopular in America, and it is therefore unlikely that it will be legalized, you wrote, “anon, I disagree with you that there is currently in the general population much animosity towards it.” So I pointed out that, in fact, the overwhelming majority of Americans believe polygamy is, indeed, morally wrong. Those interested in legalizing polygamy will have to overcome this hurdle.
By way of comparison, 57% of Americans are against same-gender marriage, and about half of Americans believe same-gender relations are morally wrong.
anon for thisParticipantMM, you are entitled to your own opinions regarding American sentiment towards polygramy. In point of fact, though, 92% of Americans surveyed in a 2005 Gallup poll believed polygamous marriage is morally wrong.
anon for thisParticipantMM, as ronsnr pointed out, there is a long history of anomosity in the US towards polygamy. This history makes it very unlikely that US laws against polygamy will be changed in our lifetimes.
As I stated in my previous post, authorities can indeed prosecute for bigamy if a man has a common-law marriage relationship with two different women, even if he is not married to both. Generally authorities won’t prosecute unless there are other issues such as underage marriage or welfare fraud, but laws exist allowing them to do so.
anon for thisParticipantstarwolf, I’m not MM, but the gemara just says “By sending their children off to the Bais Hamedrash, and by waiting for their husbands to come home from the Bais Hamedrash”. No earning a living, cooking, or cleaning required, according to this gemara.
anon for thisParticipantMM, but only one of those endeavors involves breaking US law. Please note that if a man is married to one woman, he may be guilty of bigamy if he lives with another woman, even if he does not marry the second woman. Also, the charge of bigamy may apply even if his first marriage is a common-law marriage only.
anon for thisParticipantMM, not in this state.
anon for thisParticipantMM, I know that this is unusual–so are many stories of courage. I’m sure that when this woman was in her twenties, some people speculated that she was not yet engaged/ married because she was too picky, not really interested in marrying, etc. As it turned out, though, when she was in her early twenties her future husband had not yet reached the age of consent.
Of the women I know who married in their late twenties/ early thirties, most married men within a year of their own ages–some older, some younger.
anon for thisParticipantNY Mom, your story reminds me of a classmate of mine. Unlike many in the class, who married in their early twenties, she did not meet & marry her husband until her late twenties. It’s obvious now why she had to wait to meet her zivug…he’s five years younger than her.
anon for thisParticipantrebetzin, your description of BJJ is consistent with my own experience there.
October 29, 2009 7:46 pm at 7:46 pm in reply to: Tznius Support Group PLEASE WOMEN ONLY, even reading #665268anon for thisParticipantNY Mom, one can also buy a dickie (blouse or turtleneck collar) to wear under tops like those.
anon for thisParticipantIf the divorce rate is lower in the chassidishe community than in the litvishe community, than it might be because they date for a shorter amount of time, or it might be because of other differences between the chassidishe & litvishe communities (maybe it’s because the spouses are closer in age). In order to know that dating for longer leads to more divorces, one would have to compare two groups who are otherwise similar, one dating longer & one dating shorter, to see which group has a higher divorce rate.
anon for thisParticipantWhat’s your source for that, Mezonos Maven?
-
AuthorPosts