Always_Ask_Questions

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 16 posts - 7,801 through 7,816 (of 7,816 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: NYC lockdowns again #1907968

    Syag,
    could you help me understand how this 2 positions can be reconciled:

    1) dont tell me that I need a mask, it is my private issue
    2) high infection in my community is due to overcrowding

    you expressed each of these positions clearly, thanks. I just do not see how this machloket between
    Syag and Syag can be reconciled.

    in reply to: Ever heard of davening? #1907965

    coffee, just contact whomever you consider a gadol, or ask your local Rav to consult whomever he consults. And then please report the answer here as this is the public matter. If you don’t receive the answer, you can post that also.

    in reply to: NYC lockdowns again #1907820

    Syag. All I am saying: if you live in small apartments, you should be more cautious. You listed multiple reasons thru several threads why you should not be more cautious.

    Other poor community you mention consist of people who work in risky conditions and have low education.

    A community that learns Talmud should do better.

    in reply to: NYC lockdowns again #1907796

    Syag,
    thanks for fixing my post. Let me return the favor, then.

    You seem to be claiming that religious Jews should behave same as other communities, but, due to smaller apartments, they will understandably be affected more by the pandemic, and that’s OK. We can keep our equal rights sustained, sorry, grandpa. We’ll say the kaddish with no masks, don’t worry.

    in reply to: NYC lockdowns again #1907732

    Syag, apartment sizes do matter, indeed. Hard to judge which part of the problem is due to human factors and which due to environment. I can understand other locations mostly by newspaper photos. Some photos are zoomed in on someone and it is hard to say whether they are representative of general behavior. Still, I saw many wide-area Israeli and NY photos showing many people in masks, and many without; on the beard; on the mouth only; taken down to talk to a neighbor. Is it different from non-religious Israelis and Americans? not sure. But why should we hold religious Jews to such a low standard?

    in reply to: Ever heard of davening? #1907725

    I agree with everyone here – yes for davening, yes for hishtadlus, and yes for being open-minded…
    on one hand, davening is better than burning tires and starting protests….
    On the other, to protect Yserbius from being accused of insensitivity, we can look at the idea of “sheretz b’yado” – can we daven while doing averos (not just passively not doing hishtadlus …)?

    Presuming that a plague is a punishment and lesson for us – we should at least try to discern the lesson and learn from them. Some of the “lessons learned” I heard are usually simply an extension of the speaker’s agenda, adding Covid for better taste.

    in reply to: better learning from Corona #1905124

    Syag,
    I understand what you are trying to say. And I said what I wanted to say. They are _literally_ in the way when I walk in the street. They are also in the way of my non-Jewish neighbors. And their own relatives and Rabbis. On this note, my contribution to shalom bais isroel is to l’hathila walk on the pavement, where possible, and watch for cars instead of walking around people (not my idea, I saw a friend doing that). Everyone understand the walk-around and most do the same, but why not make it nicer.

    I am also not trying to berate anyone here. I am also not counter-demonstrating BLM or shouting “Shabbos” at a Reform temple parking.

    I am just trying to discuss with people who share same understanding as I do – and there seems to be at least some, a majority in some places, a minority in others – what is for us to do and understand. In this post, I am skipping questions of daily halakhot – whom to count for minyan, whose shhita to trust, and going to what seems more important – whose Torah to learn?

    in reply to: better learning from Corona #1905118

    Syag,
    I am with you on trying to bring all Jews together, omen. Those who disregard simple medical rules are kind of in the way – hard to being them even under a “big tent”, even if outside.

    I am especially bothered that places of Torah learning seem to not perform well.
    How can you go through all machlokets between Abaye and Rava and not be able to compute the risks?
    How can you learn that “saving one life saves the whole world” and then disregard risks you create.
    What are the reasons?
    Maybe if we understand them, we can correct. I am not claiming to know full answers, I am “just asking the questions”.

    in reply to: better learning from Corona #1905100

    @Syag, you have a point. I am, thankfully, not in a place where I can access a large random sample of non-maskers. You see online responses as well as I do. I heard several offline ones that are hard to summarize: one saying that those who care, can walk around him; another apparently believe in some conspiracy theories; one saying that there are more people dying in car accidents from the virus. My kids were able to convince this last teenager by quoting the statistics.

    Maybe an only coherent argument is a claim that their community has herd immunity. It is also not fully thought-through. If you claim that your community achieved herd immunity, you are saying that your community has already killed and maimed the maximal number of people for this pandemic, with no apparent soul searching.

    N0mesorah suggests that most of these people are simply followers. Then, we need to look at the leaders. What are they saying? Are they not able to lead, or are they afraid to lose control of the herd?

    in reply to: better learning from Corona #1905070

    n0mesorah, so you are suggesting that no mask movement is made of followers rather than of people taking a personal stand? Hard for me to figure out as I am obviously not planning to interview them in person. Whom are they following?

    in reply to: better learning from Corona #1905067

    re: telescope. More likely something like a protractor or an astrolab to accurately measure angles and convert into distances .. if R Gamliel were to have a telescope, Jews would be not Jews if they would not use it for commercial, if not military, applications. Early use of telescopes in Italy involved watching for long-haul ships to arrive and buying stock.

    in reply to: Why are massive protests okay, but davening in a minyan is not? #1904952

    OrechDin – you mention poskim in Israel who require masks. So, if a Rav of a shul follows that psak and someone shows up without a mask or in a half-mask – what happens? Do they get an aliya? Or do we now have separate shuls with and without masks?

    Maybe we could use a 2×2 mehitza with traditional men/women separation in one dimension and mask/non-mask dimension in another. I saw this happening spontaneously sans the mehitza.

    in reply to: Davened for Trump? #1904946

    @GH, I agree that sometimes this bracha does not feel authentic. Indeed, I once witnessed how an elderly congregant broke down on Yom Kippur in some country during this prayer “Why do we say this? They are murderers.. They killed my family” …

    At the same time, as we all choose to live in this country (we are all free to leave, right?), I think we should acknowledge it. Thankfully, we do not have to say “adoneinu” as both my Russian and Austrian machzorim say, but why not wish “Hashem give wisdom to …”. Should also apply to governors, unless you are still voting Federalist.

    in reply to: better learning from Corona #1904940

    @N0mesorah – there is no doubt that American and Israeli Jewish educational systems saved a lot of people from assimilation. This worked great as an emergency measure, but I somehow doubt that Hashem is pleased with us using Torah SOLELY as a medicine to save Jewish people, while losing our ability to learn – and follow it – properly.

    As to preventing extremists, it is of course an old problem mentioned in Beitzah that Hashem gave Jews Torah to stop us from extremism. Still, you may be under the influence of the “no true Scotsman” fallacy: yes, most Jewish extremists were not shomrim Shabbat, but where did they come from? If I recall correctly the story, Chafetz Chaim did not shake hand with the Rav from the place where Trotsky came from. And what do you call people who are bravely walking around without the masks as not extremists?

    in reply to: Davened for Trump? #1904749

    We had more difficult cases.
    Look up old machzorim. I have mahzor from one side of my family with a prayer for Kesar Nikolai Alexandrovich (and a named list of his wife and children) and from another – for Franz Jozef.

    I don’t think one would be allowed to have both in his house during WW1…

    in reply to: Kashering A Laptop. #1902459

    School IT person should have an admin account and students should have a local account. Admin account should NOT have “613” for the password.

    Administrator should be able to disable wifi. See link 1. I think bluetooth access may depend on a computer model and is often switched on using an external button. See link 2 that describes how to switch it on. Use in reverse.

    If you have already disabled Wifi, you might not be able to see the links or even read this, of course…

    links removed, sorry

Viewing 16 posts - 7,801 through 7,816 (of 7,816 total)