Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
ahavas yisroel chinumParticipant
Sorry, there was one thing that was mentiond clearly, That it is not not allowed to greet someone from the other gender even through a Sh’liach & even through her husband, and that was inserted not just due to speaking to someone of the opposite gender, but more so in reply to a “P’sak” renderd here by one of the mods ( I’ll leave that annonymous) that you are allowed, hence my response, although originally I didn’t want to bring M’koirois for anything, & just asked him where he gets that from. “Again can everyone just get beyond this shutting down thing? I never said it, only to refrain from conversing directly with someone from the opposite gender S’tam Divrei Hevel”
ahavas yisroel chinumParticipantmod-80; Please no need to all work up or personal. Obviously, you are correct, but being a Yid or not is irrelevant, as is if I am a Amcho Yid, a Talmud Chochom, a Dayan, or a Rov, what counts is what a “person” says, I only brought down things that are included in Harcheik Min Hachiur Umin “Hadoimeh” Loi. Also none of G’morois, Midroshim, Poiskim, were speaking about Blogs as there was no such a thing, but notice that I only brought down things that specificaly refer to the Inyon of K’dushoh V’taharoh by K’lal Yisroel, Its Isurim otherwise, Its S’char if Yes. And Please read through “everything that I have written anywhere on a any post & you will see that I never impleid to close anything down, only to keep our distances between the genders.
ahavas yisroel chinumParticipantAreivimzehlazeh; maybe you should put up a map of the US & a time chart of the world up, & them all the questions will be answered.
ahavas yisroel chinumParticipantAreivimzehlazeh; Thanx again for your input, You are correct. & btw to anyone wondering, there is a Montebello NY.
ahavas yisroel chinumParticipantSince this question might be bothering some other people, i’ll enlighten you all a bit. I don’t, I assume from his/her writings, & neither does anyone really know mine/mine. Besides it was not a Mussar Shmooze, as I/I wrote there!
ahavas yisroel chinumParticipantAreivim; Thanx for checking them out, I really appreciate it since here in Asia I have nothing but the basic few S’forim with me. As for kicking anyone out, you are correct, I havn’t said to kick anyone out, just that people we should refrain from directly addressing someone identified as being from the opposite gender! & as I said in the General 2 days ago, I’m writing this also as a reminder to myself. For everyone else out there that wants to know how we who is what, we don’t, but if someone identifies themselves as such, anyone from the opposite gender should not address that person directly. Also the issue was not a Hechsher but rather a P’sak if it’s Muttor or Osur to to speak with the other gender S’tam Divrei Hevel, & let’s not forget the question from before, are we allowed to shake hands? (btw, I’m probably older then most here & have been traveling for a long time, I am “very” respected all over, for not shaking hands, & for never Shmoozing with someone from the other gender or looking @ them directly). As for the reason I write the way I do, other then the one mentioned, is 1) to keep it short & to the point. 2) Not to leave room for saying I misquoted. 3) Most important of all, not to say things that I should not. 4) To try my best not to make it sound personal. Again Please do not assume that I am fanatic, on my 1st posts in the CR, in the, What to when parents don’t want a Shidduch, I sound just the opposite, here from the ultra right & there from the left, but the Toirah is Nitzchis, given by Hashem, & he asks us to be K’doishim “K’doishim Tih’u Ki Kodoish Ani Hashem M’kadishchem, & he also asked us to do only good & accept every Yid no matter what. btw, This is also on the rules outside the door to my house, & anyone that judges others is not welcome, Therefor at any given time it’s full of all differant types, Chassidish, Litvish, Y’shivish, Modern, Ashk’nazi, S’fardi, Teimoni.
ahavas yisroel chinumParticipantJoseph; well asked! As for 2 rooms, good Idea, but we could just refrain addressing people we know are from the opposite gender directly, & the biggest problem is in the General, where it’s a free for all & some even imply…….., not here
ahavas yisroel chinumParticipantmod-80; As i said before it’s not a problem to get a Rav to say anything these days, even if I’ll bring the biggest Poiskei Hador to give a live Shiur saying 1 thing, 100 others bring their own Rav to say otherwise, even if Moisheh Rabbeinu would say Ossur, someone will say he’s to old & doesn’t remember, V’ho Raayoh, plenty have been brought down by others (& I have to compliment them, especially Joseph), and we still have to bring a Rav, even the Memrois of the G’moro were not enough, so maybe I’ll do something I said I will not do albeit only a bit, (bring down what & where it says). 1) Even Hoezer Siman 21 S’if 7 Ein Shoialin Bishloim Isho K’lal Afilu Al Y’dei Sh’liach “V’afilu Al Y’dei Baloh” V’osur Lishloiach Lo Divrei Sh’loimim, even sending her the greeting is forbidden! 2) G’moroh Yuma 74: Omar Raish Lokish etc. & Rambam Hilchois T’shuvoh 4 Uk’var Kosvu Horishoinim, where you can see how the Yetzer has people do things that are not explicitly Osur Kdai Sheloi Y’hei Liboi Noikfoi V’yachazir Bit’shuvoh. 3) Maseches Kalloh 1 Omar R’ Elozor Kol Hshoiseh, even unintetionally. 4) G’moro Nidoh 13. Kol Hameivi….Ein Machnisin Oisoi Lim’chitzosoi Shel HKB”H & the Rambam explains V’im Poga B’machashovoh Chetoi Godoil B’harbeh 5) Chinuch 188 even if he knows he will not faulter. 6)Y’rushalmi B’rochois P’1 H’8 Omar HKB”H Im At Uhiv Liboch V’einoch Ano Yodaano D’at Dili, what A Z’chus & S’char 7) Midrash Shir Hashirim 3, 13 T’nino B’shem R’ Doiso, ….Omar Hakodoish Boruch Hu Mi Shehu Oimeid B’yetzer Shel Haznus Maaloh Ani Olov K’ilu Oimeid Bishteihem (including S’char for A”Z which is not around anymore & there is no other way to get S’char for it) 8) G’moro Makois 23: R’ Shimoin Bar Rebi….Gezel V’aroyois….Hapoiresh Meihem…..Sheyizkeh Loi U’l’doiroisov…..Ad Soif Kol Hadoirois. I can go on & on, on the Isurim,on the Oineshim, & on the S’char, but I think I’ve said enough V’idoch Pirusho Zil G’moir. As to a Psak, obviously The Chasidishe are a given that it’s Osur or most here might not care, as for Litvish & Y’shivish would a P’sak from a Godoil like R’ Belsky count? If yes, when I come back from Asia next week I’ll meet him right away. ps. I might be off on “some” of the words qouted, all though I tried to qoute as much as possible verbaitim, V’Hashem Hatoiv Y’chaper. I still love each one of you!
ahavas yisroel chinumParticipantWhat is good enough? Not addressing anyone that Identifies themselves as being from the opposite gender. V’al Zeh Umru Harcheik Min Hachiur Umin Hadoimeh Loi
ahavas yisroel chinumParticipantI did read everything before writing. 1) as to Bas 20 K’bas 120, please see the Rambam & Shulchun Oruch, regarding a man looking @ a old or a most disgusting women. 2) mod-42, where do you take it from that when a man walks on the street and a women passes the opposite way that he’s allowed to greet her? 3) Has everyone forgotten the the Posuk Ayeih Soroh Ishtecho? 4) It also says Al Tarbeh Sichoh Im Ho’ishoh, not Im Ishoh, for a very good reason. 5)Not calling married people of the other gender by their first names is not just a custom. 6) V’hoyoh Machanecho Kodoish is a D’oiraiso.
ahavas yisroel chinumParticipantJoseph, Thanx for your support! I’ll see you there B’ezras Hashem
ahavas yisroel chinumParticipantJoseph, As you so rightly assume, I like you, & I agree with you, but after reading through most of the posts, I have to say, I will not get into bringing M’koirois for everything although there are many more to bring down, where it states very clearly the Isur of shaking hands, simply because you’ll never finish arguing with the ones that are looking to do it! I also don’t want to get personal with anyone. But I do have a few comments, 1)Please be careful with your choise of words as they could be misunderstood, like your allowed to embarrass a Goi, I know what you meant, but some might not. Now I’m writing to everyone, 2)It’s not hard to get a Heter today for anything from a “Rav”, including women Davening for the Omud or worse things that I do not want to mention. 3)When the words “reportedly” are used about a P’sak, I’m dumbfounded. 4) Let’s not forget the G’morah on V’yad L’yad Loi Yinokeh, or, Hamistakel B’etzbah K’tanoh Shel Ishoh, and even if it is Muter,what about V’asu S’yug Latoirah? 5) To say women are differant, Chas V’sholoim, if anything, they are worse,(again I’m not getting into bringing referencess or the words written), 6) Who are they afraid to embarrass, the other person? NO! rather “themselves” 7)I have a huge house Boruch Hashem full of guest at all times & I have a list of rules outside the door that includes quite a few on Hilchois Tz’ni’us & no one has yet had a problem with it or gotten embarrassed. Please, I don’t want anyone to think that I am a Fannatic, I’m not! Most of my house is full of people that are not Chassidish or Yeshivish, also see what an impression I give, on the topic of “when parents don’t want a Shidduch”, Avol, Yikoiv Hadin Es Hohor, V’al Yisbayesh Mipnai Hamal’igim Olov Ba’avoidasoi Yisborach Sh’moi, applies by both posts, even if 1 sounds as if it’s from the right & the other as if from the left
ahavas yisroel chinumParticipantAreivimzehlazeh. Yiyasher Koichacho Al Hakabolas Punim! Love you too!
ahavas yisroel chinumParticipantAreivimzehlazeh, Remember what I wrote, that it is included in Harchaik Min Hachiur Umin Hadoimeh Loi, those are not my words, and their is also a Mitzva D’oiraisah of V’hoyo Machanecho Kodoish. Besides with a name like Areivimzehlazeh, I’m surprised at you. But I sure appreciate your nice words to me, Yiyasher Koichacho
ahavas yisroel chinumParticipantames. Sorry but this rule is not ours to decide. But please keep in mind we are only tenants down here in this world and Hashem is the landlord, and also our father
ahavas yisroel chinumParticipantDear mods. I hope that none of these Shmoozers are known to be women (or girls), as Shmoozing Stam without reason, between the two genders, even if unknown to each other, is included in Harcheik Min Hachiur Umin Hadoimeh Loi. Not trying to give a Mussar Shmooze, only making ourselves aware, including myself!
ahavas yisroel chinumParticipantFor anyone out there wondering, I have an unbelievably great Yichus not just from before the war but even after the war & from both sides of my family, but by me it’s never ever brought up for a few reasons 1)It is Gaavah. 2)It is not my doing, Al Korchuch Ato Noilad. 3)Yichus Atzmi is what counts to Hashem. 4)If someone has big Yichus and flaunts it, he loses out either way in Oilom Ho’elyoin, if he does what Hashem wants whilst he is down here in the Oilom Hasheker, he only gets rewarded a little up there, since it’s expected of him to act according to his Yichus, and if he doesn’t act appropriatly down here in the Oilom Hasheker, he gets twice the punishment in the Oilom Ho’emes, once for the way he acted & second for ambarrasing his yichus. Remember the Posuk, V’shoveho Bitzdokoh, we will be redeamed by doing what is right
ahavas yisroel chinumParticipantYou got it right esterh, it never good enough “for the parents”, not that it’s not good enough for children, and please let not anyone say that 30 year olds are not mature enough to know whats right for themselves. It almost always comes down to what Pases for the parents, not what Past for the kids. It’s time to stop labeling & discriminating against our fellow Yiddin. U’bizchus Zeh Nigo’el
ahavas yisroel chinumParticipantBefore I start, I want to clear up a few things, as some are questioning others rights understandings & experiances. 1) I have Boruch Hashem made a few Chasunus. 2)As someone working with others problems (which ones left out for good reason)I might have “some” knowledge of what goes on in the “Frum”/”Heimishe” world, it’s effects & maybe how to deal with them. Please remember who is getting married. The parents do have an obligation to tell there kids “on the onset” of the Shidduch to tell there son/daughter there opinion, but they should remember that it does “not” give them the right to use demeaning terms, including “Es Past Nisht” “what are others going to say/think” “you deserve better” he/she is just not good enough for you” etc. etc. etc. All of these are Avak Loshon Horah! They should say if THEY VERIFIED that he/she is really not a good person (and even then remember that sometimes it’s better to let it happen anyway, & they should still treat there son/daughter well, even for Yiddishkeit purposes). If though it is for the other afformentioned reasons, remember WHAT DOESN’T PAS FOR YOU MIGHT PAS FOR HIM, HE/SHE SHOULD DECIDE WHAT’S BETTER, WHAT PEOPLE WILL THINK/SAY IS NOT THE RIGHT WAY FOR A YID MAKE DECISIONS “WE HAVE TO MAKE DECISIONS BASED ON WHAT HASHEM WANTS OF US!!!!! The notion that a parent always wants what’s best for the child is “not” true, most of them want marriages that will raise their own prestige. And if Yichus or backround is what they want it proves my previous point about prestige, and it goes against everything that HAKODOISH BORUCH HU wants from us as we are ALL HIS CHILDREN. The G’morah states that the Bais Hamikdosh was only destroyed due to SIN’AS CHI’NUM, which is truly illogical, because how many times have you walked down the street, seen someone for the very first time and said I hate him? Never! And if he did something to you, then it’s not CHIN’UM, IT IS WRONG NOT CHI’NUM! WHAT IT MEANS IS WHEN YOU CAN’T STAND ANOTHER YID BASED ON BACKROUND, YICHUS, WHICH GROUP HE BELONGS TO, WHERE HE HAILS FROM, etc.etc. THAT IS SIN’AS CHI’NUM PLAIN AND SIMPLE!!! THE YAITZER HORAH COMES UP WITH ALL KINDS OF GOOD REASONS TO EXPLAIN WHY THIS CASE IS LOGICAL & MAKES SENSE, BUT PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE LET’S WAKE UP K’LAL YISROEL AND HAVE AHAVAS CHI’NUM AND TREAT EVERY YID THE SAME WAY REGARDLESS OF HIS/HER BACKROUND,BE HE/SHE CHASSIDISH,LITVISH, YEKISH, ASHKENAZY, S’FARADI, MORROCAN, SYRIAN, IRAQI, IRANIAN, HUNGARIAN, POLISH, GALICIAN, OR FROM ANYWHERE ELSE!!!! Only “his” actions should count. Also when it comes to second marriages & the “child” is in the 30’s 40’s 50’s & the parents are still busy Haking A Chinik, something is wrong! & YES IT DOES HAPPEN!!!! HACHOISEM MIK’AIV LEV
-
AuthorPosts