- This topic has 63 replies, 18 voices, and was last updated 7 years, 7 months ago by .
-
Posts
-
Bump
zahavasdad,
Wild rice is another example of people making things Kitynot that isnt. Wild rice is a GRASS not a rice, the only thing it has in common with rice is the name and it sort of looks like rice, but its a GRASS
All cereal grains (wheat, spelt, maize, etc.) are grasses too. Halachic categories and botanical categories are different things, so trying to shove the square peg of botanical categories into the round hole of kitniyos is an exercise in futility.
MDG,
“No, kitniyos is not chometz, but still assur for Ashkenazim.”
That should be “assur for Ashkenazim to eat.”
That should be “assur for Ashkenazim to eat during Pesach” 🙂
Grains are Chametz, not Kitniyot
Maize is not Chametz and is only Kitniyot because someone made a mistake.
Grains are Chametz, not Kitniyot
Maize is not Chametz and is only Kitniyot because someone made a mistake.
If you’re going to kvetch about terminology, at least get your terminology correct. You seem to trust Wikipedia, so go read the first sentence of the Wikipedia entry for maize and then come back and tell me it’s not a grain.
Also, grains are NOT chometz. Chometz is the result of wetting the flour of a certain subset of grains (wheat, spelt, barley, rye, and oats) and allowing that mixture to rise (e.g., by leaving it in that condition for longer than 18 minutes).
Maize is kitniyos because its flour can be confused for flour that can produce chometz. Your repeated argument that someone made a “mistake” therefore only strengthens the case that it is kitniyos.
You can make flour out of alot things , that are not Chametz or Kitniyot
Potatoes, Almonds , Apples are examples
The ability to make flour is not the reason to make Kitniyot
The link to the Mishna Berurah: (453:4)
ZD: I am not sure who you think made a “mistake” but the Mishna Berurah specifically mentions Corn (although he uses the yiddish term Tirkishe Veitz”).
The Mistake was made before the Mishnah Bruah
Maize was unknown in Europe before columbus. It is native to North America.
It was brought back to Europe and it was mistaken for something else because the word was similar
zahavasdad,
It was brought back to Europe and it was mistaken for something else because the word was similar
Do you have a source for this notion, or is it a guess/wishful thinking?
zahavasdad,
You can make flour out of alot things , that are not Chametz or Kitniyot
Correct. And some of these “flours” more closely resemble flour from grains that can be made into chometz, and we call the source material for those lookalike flours kitniyos. Because of the resemblance, Ashkenazim have a minhag of not eating kitniyos on Pesach. Rice made the cut and are considered kitniyos, potatoes did not make the cut, despite the fact that both can be made into “flour” and used to bake breadlike products. When new plants are introduced to a community that can be used to make “flour”, it is up to our Torah authorities to categorize them.
The ability to make flour is not the reason to make Kitniyot
No, but the ability to make flours that can be confused with flour that can become chometz is.
It is well known that what we call “Corn” is actually Indian Maize. It is a plant native to North America
Corn and Turkey are the 2 most well known foods native to North America that did not exist in Europe until Columbus
zahavasdad,
It is well known that what we call “Corn” is actually Indian Maize. It is a plant native to North America
Corn and Turkey are the 2 most well known foods native to North America that did not exist in Europe until Columbus
Cool facts. But how do they respond to my post?
“The Mistake was made before the Mishnah Bruah”
And yet you know the applicability of Halacha better than the Chofetz Chaim.
That is why there are people lined up to ask you for Brochos and eitzos as well for your psaokim.
Avram
The yiddish word for Rye is קאָרן
zd: But the Mishna Berurah clearly uses the yiddish word for corn – קוקורוזע. (see 453:4)
So wry humor is the same as a corny joke?
The Mishnah Bruah uses the word Turkish Veitz in 453:4 and Veitz is also the word for Wheat
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.