- This topic has 29 replies, 15 voices, and was last updated 3 years ago by .
-
Posts
-
Because that’s how much you can learn during shachris.
My friend asked me a kasha: In Rav Meir Shapiro’s shul, you could probably learn 2 blatt during davening.
He also probably davened more though. So he could still only learn one.
And this is the raiah that we don’t go to mincha maariv.
Popa
Unlesz you are reviewing a daf you know well it is impossible to Daven and also learn a daf in those few moments that you have while waiting for the baal tefillah. P. S. You may not learn during chazaras hashatz. Its not called chazaras hashas.
If you daven more, then you get a better head. So you could still cram in two hours’ worth into one. (Torasan mishtameres…) But then again, if you’re learning you’re not davening, so you don’t get that benefit.
WIY, the parts that get left over can be done during Lecha Dodi.
why are u doing the daf during shacharis? Rav Shapiro would not approve ive been learning daf yomi now on my own since the siyum hashas and it has changed my life b”h
Popa, you can daven up the daf during psukei dzimra, just say baruch she’amar, ashrei, and yishtabach, and then you have a whole 3 minutes left while the rest of the people say the other stuff.
you could leave early
But the daytime Tefilos aren’t for Daf Yomi. People usually bring piles of other Sefarim to their place for that.
WIY: It’s not clear that you can’t learn during Chazaras HaShatz. I think I’ve quoted Rav Weinberger on this here before.
Sam, not with a Kol, since others will think you are talking and they will talk. It is also advised to focus on what the Baal Tefilla is saying.
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Dear Popa,
Mazel tov! I am inspired to start some other tractate on Tuesday. Being that I do Mincha/Maariv I guess I am require to daven two daf a day.
nebbuch!! learn like a mentsh!!
if you can skip bletter here and there?????Dear Rebbu,
Yeah, it is like first seder in any yeshiva.
Most yeshivot never teach more than a handful of masechtot. In daf yomi you learn the entire Bavli. Maybe not as in depth, but you can do a good job learning it if you are diligent. It is not clear that Chazal thought that one masechte was more important than any other so they would likely approve. I am now in cycle #3 for me. It gets easier each time through.
The Maseches emanate from the six sedorim of mishnah, shas, making the acronym זמן נקט – זרעים, מועד, נשים, נזיקין, קדשים, טהרות teaching us to grab on to time and not to waste it.
Shekolim part of the Yerushalmi is included in the Daf Yomi as it reminds us of the Tamid requiring unity and the rebuilding of the Beis Hamikdash so everyone learning the same thing brings to unity.
iyun is the ikkur!
we however can’t finish shas b’iyun and our goal is to do the best of our ability not to “read” shas getting the shidchiyos shebo and then forgetting itRebbu, what do you with sinai veoker horim sinai adef, bekios is more important than beiyun? The reason is that bekios can destroy a whole building on a false foundation.
Should be above, what do you do with sinai veoker horim sinai adef, bekios is more important than beiyun?
the day yomi of today has no shaychis to sinai!!!!!
Rebbu, aderaba, the opposite is true. It is all for bekios.
Dear Rebbu,
Why do you say iyun is the ikkur? I never met someone who learned real iyun who thought iyun is the ikkur.
What part of Torah has shaychus to Sinai? (I am not ch”v refuting anything. I doubt this question could be answered accurately without a lot of knowledge. You shlugged up yourself.)
Sinai (at the end of Horiyus) is equivalent to bekios.
You can do both. Like Popa bar Abba, I finished along with the thousands others in 2020, and decided to add Tosafos, so I just climbed out of Eiruvin. I doubt I’ll catch up this way but being up to date is not worth giving up Tosafos.
Mazel Tov! Did you say …Abba Bar Popa…?
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.