- This topic has 107 replies, 23 voices, and was last updated 3 years, 5 months ago by .
-
Posts
-
@avira
I don’t know any and never heard about any non-yekke who washes before kiddush.you say you don’t know any other posek who frowns upon non yekes doing this…that is, they’re ok with it? or they never heard about it/were never asked about it?
Participant; I’ve been a guest in many yeshivishe houses that on occasion will, to save time, make a yekkishe kiddush. It could be that almost no one in your community does that, but I’ve seen it several times. That’s why Rav Belsky spoke about it.
> who sometimes do the Yekkishe washing … also sometimes eat milichigs three hours
is this a major kulah? you make Kiddush, you wash, you eat challah, just in a different order. You also make kiddush with clean hands. Just had in the daf, Kohen Godel reads one of the parshiyot by heart instead of a scroll to avoid tircha d;tziburah, surely you can say kiddush with clean hands. I’ve seen people doing it not as a routine but in certain circustances, say in a sukkah where coming in and out takes long time.
It’s a kulah because it’s a shailoh of hefsek between netilas yadayim and hamotzi. Those who allow is hold that since the kiddush is le’tzorech the seudah, it’s not a hefsek.
> What’s the halachic basis for Yekkes only waiting three hours
what’s the halakhic basis to do only 6 hours?! really menchen did 24 hours according to Gemora.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.