Home › Forums › Controversial Topics › When asked Shiduch info: Do I have to tell the girls side that my friend smokes?
- This topic has 71 replies, 33 voices, and was last updated 12 years, 11 months ago by Disrael613.
-
AuthorPosts
-
December 22, 2011 11:43 pm at 11:43 pm #601260davidzMember
I was recently asked Shidduch information on a boy that I know, and as we were completing our conversation, I was asked if there is anything else that the girls side should know about. My question is When called about a Shidduch…Are you obligated to mention that a boy smokes, when you know that it would probably be a factor on the girls side (which it is most of the time)….?
December 23, 2011 12:02 am at 12:02 am #838309ToiParticipantno.
December 23, 2011 12:04 am at 12:04 am #838310Think firstMemberNo. Because that is something the girl can ask the boy herself if she cares and one isn’t supposed to say something that the person themselves won’t deny or tell, for example if u know a boy is on some sort of medication but will tell the girl about it at the right time (most rabbanim say 3rd date that’s between getting to know the person and liking the person) then one isn’t supposed to say because that may stop them from going out and in reality the girl may be ok with it once she has the full picture.
December 23, 2011 12:05 am at 12:05 am #838311dash™ParticipantIf they ask you.
December 23, 2011 12:09 am at 12:09 am #838312✡onegoal™ParticipantIt’s not even a question. Are you another troll?
December 23, 2011 12:11 am at 12:11 am #838313HolyMoeParticipantYes you should.
Smoking boys try to hide their habit.
Most girls I know will not consider a boy that smokes and must know about this Chissaron.
December 23, 2011 12:12 am at 12:12 am #838314here i goMemberi’m not exactly your local orthodox rabbi but here’s my personal opinion… not always will a girl find smoking to be so terrible and if it’s on her list of NoNos she should make a point to ask directly… if it’s something that she thinks will make it or break it, she’d probably make it her business to find out so i don’t think you need to mention it under “anything else”
December 23, 2011 1:10 am at 1:10 am #838315skiaddictMemberNo dont unless asked specifically, because girls know that most boys smoke, and if you mention it specifically, she will think he is a heavy chain smoker or something worst than it is.
Girls know that boys smoke and just expect them to stop when married- not that its an issue before they are married, most girls dont care about that.
December 23, 2011 3:09 am at 3:09 am #838316cherrybimParticipant“Are you obligated to mention that a boy smokes, when you know that it would probably be a factor on the girls side”
That’s like saying,”Are you obligated to mention that a boy is not always shomer shabbos and he eats a little pork on the side”
December 23, 2011 4:00 am at 4:00 am #838317OneOfManyParticipantcherrybim: How is smoking comparable to chillul Shabbos and eating treif?
December 23, 2011 4:11 am at 4:11 am #838318DyafMavenParticipantAccording to many rabbionim now days smoking is a major issur may even be a issur desorsah to start. Quiting once you started is another issue I went to whole shiur on problem of smoking today.
Many boys I know do not smoke and the ones that do a lot of them try very hard to hide from there wives or tell their wives they are going to quit. I personally believe smoking in a way is issur desorsah because you cannot purposely cause yourself harm.
In my opinion you should not tell the girl that he smokes but he should be willing to admit it if she does ask. Because I know many guys would deny it. It beginning trust matters a lot.
December 23, 2011 4:30 am at 4:30 am #838319aries2756ParticipantWoa. Do you know the girl personally? Do you know that this is an issue with the girl? How do you know that the girl’s father doesn’t smoke. Can you imagine giving information to the father and saying “BTW, he smokes” and the father saying “so do I”.
No, unless they ask, it is not your place to say unless you know the girl personally and know this is a pet peeve of hers. She will find out about it soon enough in addition if it is bashert he can quit or she will find a way to work around it. If it is NOT bashert, there will be another reason she will find that he is not for her, or she will find out on the first or second date and it won’t be your achrius.
December 23, 2011 4:45 am at 4:45 am #838320chaimssParticipant“girls know that most boys smoke”
What??? I’ve been in Yeshiva for almost ten years and I assure you, most boys do NOT smoke. There are those that do, yes, but it’s a minority, not a majority.
December 23, 2011 6:05 am at 6:05 am #838321RABBAIMParticipantAny info which may be seen as negative we must answer when asked, but should not offer info.
Be careful if you are doing the asking- ask DOES HE SMOKE AT ALL? Do not ask IS HE A SMOKER as that is inviting interpretation.. What is a smoker?? cigs, 10? A pack?? Two?? Fell in once…….. and she got married. and he quit.
December 23, 2011 2:01 pm at 2:01 pm #838322apushatayidParticipantIt is NOT something a girl can find out on her own, if a guy deliberately wants to hide it until after an engagement or marriage. It is not like a pronounced limp or a lisp that she will figure out rather quickly.
I don’t see any reason why it would be assur to tell a girl if you knew for certain that a guy smoked. The guy doesn’t feel there is anything wrong with it if he smokes publicly.
December 23, 2011 2:05 pm at 2:05 pm #838323apushatayidParticipant“because girls know that most boys smoke,”
You would have more credibilityif you claimed most yeshiva boys will be going to midnight mass, tomorrow night. Your statement surely ranks as one of the single most spurrious and ridiculous claims ever made on this site.
December 23, 2011 2:42 pm at 2:42 pm #838324miritchkaMemberOneOfMany: I dont think that smoking is coparable to chillul shabbos or eating treif but i believe cherrybim may have meant that smoking kills and therefore oiver ‘v’nishmartem m’od’. I am one of those girls, in fact part of the majority of girls, that did not/does not want a boy that smokes. I wouldnt even consider a boy that smokes and would feel very bad about hurting a boy’s feelings that i went out with, without knowing he smokes.
So to the OP, yes, i believe that because so many girls feel its terrible to smoke and dont want themselves or their children to live with the dangers of second hand smoke, it is imiportant to mention. Especially nowadays when covering the scent and hiding all hints of cigarettes are much simpler, girls should be told about it so that heartbreak can be avoided.
December 23, 2011 3:08 pm at 3:08 pm #838325kollel_wifeParticipantThe Halachos of these things are very complicated. It’s really best to ask a shailah. Some things an individual may be makpid on, and then there are things most people are makpid on.
For example if a person has always told you, I don’t want a shidduch if the person has a mental illness in the family. You may have more of an obligation to tell them initially than someone else who should perhaps be told later on.
If you’re lucky enough to have time to get back to them and didn’t yet reveal this information – then go ask a shailah.
December 23, 2011 3:09 pm at 3:09 pm #838326BTGuyParticipantHi Davidz.
Check it out with a prominent rabbi.
I would strongly hope you would be permitted.
Smoking is a serious health hazard for all those around a smoker.
In any case, she should know. If she is ok with it, then fine. Secondly, if he plans on hiding it, then he is starting off with the shoe on the wrong hand, and that is not fair to her.
He may end up quitting smoking, too. Who knows?
In any case, the smoking issue out in the open is the right thing for all reasons. I cannot think of a good reason to keep this secretive. It is an important variable in the dating world. But, again, run it by your rabbi.
December 23, 2011 3:28 pm at 3:28 pm #838327mytakeMemberI’d ask my Rav, considering that this can be a very big issue to many girls (sometimes even a dealbreaker).
I’m with BTGuy on this one.
December 23, 2011 5:46 pm at 5:46 pm #838328Bar ShattyaMemberTo rule out someone who smokes, would be shallow. To assist in this crime, would be accomplice. Therefore, you should definitely lie to conceal it, as much as you can- as long as you won’t get caught.
If they say they saw him smoking, you say it was just a chosson cigarette. After all, if fat girls can eat food at a wedding, why can’t guys smoke at a wedding. And if fat girls can lie about their ages, then why can’t we allow smoking- which is not even part of who they are.
It is very sad that girls today judge others only by the outside, and not by what is within. Within their heart (not lungs).
This is what they should teach in seminary, instead of all that navi that my illustrated brother popa_bar_abba knows better than them anyway.
December 23, 2011 6:32 pm at 6:32 pm #838329BTGuyParticipantHi Bar Shattya.
Ruling out someone who smokes is the perfect right of the person deciding who to date. Why is it shallow for someone to not want to date a smoker? Smoker/nonsmoker happens to be a big deal to people in dating, the workplace, public events, malls,…etc.
I believe the point was if someone smokes, is that something the other person should be made aware of.
There are perfectly fine people who smoke. But this is not a matter of the guy likes to wear blue ties as opposed to white and black ties.
Who would not want to know if the person they are considering for marriage is a smoker or not? Some won’t rule them out. Some will, and that is their right.
Off the record, smoking is not such a benign thing for a lot of reasons, and will be a very noticeable and intrusive component of sharing their lives together.
The fact that smoking (not the person, necessarily) is very repulsive, annoying, uncomfortable, unclean, and dangerous to nonsmokers and smokers, is not something that can be swept under the carpet during dating. Let the other person know and they can take it from there.
It is not a matter of judging. Smoking is a tangible annoyance to many people and for that reason has been outlawed in public places. So what is so difficult to imagine someone does not want that in their living room for the rest of their lives? Or around their children?
Frankly, smoking is such a known sakana now, you have to somewhat ignorant in thinking on your own to take up smoking. It is deadly, chas v’shalom, in over 70 known ways, and now they are finding it is radioactive from the radon where the plants are grown.
I dont want to hear the ‘relaxing’ argument either, as only those who think smoking is ok would accept such a lame justification. There are smokers who know it is bad and want to quit if they could. Those who see good things in smoking are off the hook, period.
December 23, 2011 6:39 pm at 6:39 pm #838330Bar ShattyaMemberWho would not want to know if the person they are considering for marriage is a smoker or not? Some won’t rule them out. Some will, and that is their right.
You don’t have the right to be so shallow at other people’s expense, and expect me to play along. If you say you will only marry a girl who wears size 8 shoes, do you have that right? Do I have to play along with your stupidities?
Besides, this is not about rights. You have the right to not get married altogether. This is about what is the correct. And what is good good for klal yisroel. And what Hashem wants.
Maybe if you would think about what Hashem wants, once in a while, just for kicks, you might realize this.
It is not a matter of judging. Smoking is a tangible annoyance to many people and for that reason has been outlawed in public places. So what is so difficult to imagine someone does not want that in their living room for the rest of their lives? Or around their children?
It sounds to me like you are judging. Lots of things are illegal. Shechita is illegal in many countries, and bris milah was almost illegal in California.
This is what chanuka is all about. You get your morality from the yevanim, apparently. A hellenist incarnate.
I hope you’ll excuse me if I take my cues from the maccabis.
I dont want to hear the ‘relaxing’ argument either, as only those who think smoking is ok would accept such a lame justification.
The fact is, that most people who have tried smoking, and understand how relaxing it is, do agree with this justification. Maybe you should walk in their shoes, before you start ripping their shoes to pieces.
The bottom line is, that you haven’t even addressed my main point. The important thing in a shidduch is who the person is inside- not that your living room will smell a bit, and you will need to buy air fresheners.
There are many things which can bother someone a little bit about a spouse, but I would that yisroel kedoshim would see past a few extra pounds, or a little bit of smoke, or being a couple months older, and see the person inside.
So what is so difficult to imagine someone does not want that in their living room for the rest of their lives?
Your living room will not raise your children. Your husband will. Your living room will not learn with your children, and take them to shul. Your husband will.
Maybe you should be willing to trade your stupid clean living room for a good yiddishe lichtige freileche mishpacha.
December 23, 2011 6:43 pm at 6:43 pm #838331lesschumrasParticipantJust the fact that people consider replying to shidduch inquiries with lies makes me question the whole process (keeping silent is in effect the same )
December 24, 2011 11:43 pm at 11:43 pm #838332ToiParticipantfor those who say that most bochurim dont smoke. yes, if your looking at chofetz chaim in yihupitz then fine. but most bochurim on the yeshivish spectrum will take a cigarette now and then and at least a third smoke rather heavily. for it to be a concern for shidduchim- fine, you can also decide youd rather not marry someone with a limp, but to rule it out entirely is jst dumb. blame the girls for their own shidduch crisis.
December 25, 2011 12:32 am at 12:32 am #838333ChachamParticipanttoi- I still believe most don’t smoke.
Bar Shattya- do you think someone wants to marry your mishmar dude who doesn’t take showers ever and stinks even if he will bring up fine children? Some people can’t take being near the smell. Another reason why some won’t want someone to smoke is because it is a certain personality of people who smoke. Also it is against halacha according to many poskim. Do you thinks they want someone who shaves with a razor?
December 25, 2011 12:38 am at 12:38 am #838334yitayningwutParticipantThe majority of bachurim do not smoke. But it’s a ????? ????? – a significant minority.
December 25, 2011 12:56 am at 12:56 am #838335ChachamParticipantOK, there is also a significant minority of bachurim who don’t take showers. so for some people they want to avoid those people. You can’t have any taanos on them.
I remember the first day of the zman i made up to meet my second seder chavrusa in the yeshivas CR and the first thing he said to me after asking me if i am chacham is if i mind if he goes to take a smoke. I told him I will rather getting started right away. After this minor disagreement he decided he does not want to be my chavrusa and that shoft only lasted one day. (bh i have a chavrusa but i think this guy is still learning by himself)
December 25, 2011 1:38 am at 1:38 am #838336davidzMemberOver Shabbos I asked a prominent Rov in Flatbush for a response to the question.
He responded that…. ten years ago it would have been a totally different scenario and he would have said it should absolutely not be brought up, because even if the parents request the info. odds are that the daughter would be able to work it out, if the boy carried all other traits she was looking for. However nowadays, since we can confidently say that over 51% of girls consider smoking a serious issue, therefore if you believe that there’s even a slight chance that it may affect the marriage, not only do you have a right to share the info, you actually have an obligation to.
December 25, 2011 4:02 am at 4:02 am #838337yitayningwutParticipantChacham –
LOL. I’m sure he found a great chavrusa who doesn’t mind that he smokes.
December 25, 2011 4:46 am at 4:46 am #838338ChachamParticipantyityningwut- Well as far as i am concerned nobody ever told me he has a chavrusa. I guess if you know him better than i do you can tell me he does.
December 25, 2011 4:49 am at 4:49 am #838339yitayningwutParticipantHmmm. I’m going to put my money on it that I do and he does.
December 25, 2011 4:58 am at 4:58 am #838340ChachamParticipantalright- we are you putting down this money? when and where can i come pick it up?
December 25, 2011 5:09 am at 5:09 am #838341yitayningwutParticipant??? ??? ??????
December 25, 2011 6:22 am at 6:22 am #838342apushatayidParticipantSo “ocassional smoking” is ok (ask any cardiologist or oncologist for their opinion)? What about ocassional unfiltered internet use? Ocassional ditching seder for a morning of sleeping in? Please explain why it might be different than ocassional smoking?
December 25, 2011 6:31 am at 6:31 am #838343real-briskerMemberapy – The girl can ask him herself if he smokes.
December 25, 2011 1:03 pm at 1:03 pm #838344apushatayidParticipantSure she can, she can also ask him all the silly superficial questions peope ask the shadchan and references too. There is a reason people ask or expect to be told certain basic info, so as not to waste anyones time. I think this falls into that category.
December 25, 2011 3:55 pm at 3:55 pm #838345davidzMemberreal-brisker: “The girl can ask him herself if he smokes.”
That’s exactly the issue at hand….. there are certain things which should not go as far as having the girl ask about a certain issue, but rather the shadchan tell the girl beforehand…. How unfair it is to have girls go out with boy after boy, only to get burned out due to the fact that they find issues which individuals found unimportant to mention.
December 25, 2011 4:42 pm at 4:42 pm #838346HealthParticipantMore people should smoke -it’s good for business! 😉
December 25, 2011 5:26 pm at 5:26 pm #838347real-briskerMemberdavidz -If he feels its important for the girl to know, then whats your question. Of course the shadchan can/should say. Your question only is when the boy is trying to make a secret out of it.
December 25, 2011 5:47 pm at 5:47 pm #838348apushatayidParticipantIf the boy is trying to hide it then don’t bother telling the girl he is a smoker, he has a bigger problem you must tell her, he is a liar.
December 25, 2011 7:26 pm at 7:26 pm #838349real-briskerMemberapy – Isn’t that what this thread is about, people trying to hide it?
December 25, 2011 7:36 pm at 7:36 pm #838350Bar ShattyaMemberit is a prerequisite in todays shidduch market to be a liar. there is a crisis going on, people. you must lie about anything and everything that will convince a boy to go out with you. lie about age. lie about weight. lie about dress size. lie about middos and all important things too. I fthe boy is a liar then he is going to fit right in. The perfect candidate.
On a side note, coincidentally, earlier today I was sitting and pondering how cool it would be to smoke. My friends are right. It really is cool.
December 25, 2011 7:39 pm at 7:39 pm #838351A Sheep without a SpleenMemberMore people should smoke -it’s good for business!
You’re right, it supports the tobbaco farmers in brazil, the lawyers, and the doctors. Best of all it prunes off the unproductive old folks, that’s real Medicare Reform
December 25, 2011 7:42 pm at 7:42 pm #838352davidzMemberBar Shattya
I was extremely tempted to respond to your baseless statement, but I realized that it would be worthless to give you any credibility at all.
December 25, 2011 7:45 pm at 7:45 pm #838353ToiParticipantsmoking is cool. shadchan is roshei teivos- sheker dover, kesef notel. girls manage to ascertain if a bochur is in line with her views on movies and goyish music (so they can enjoy those together after marriage), she can figure out smoking,too.
December 25, 2011 7:46 pm at 7:46 pm #838354I can only tryMemberThis is a halacha question, not an opinion question.
When is it “loshon hora” to tell?
When is it “lo sa’amod al dam reyacha” not to tell?
Is there a “right time” and “wrong time” (before they first meet, or after x number of dates) to tell?
Are there other factors to include in the “tell” decision (i.e. he promises to quit, she has asthma, etc.)?
“davidz”s approach – ask a shaila – is the correct one.
December 25, 2011 7:55 pm at 7:55 pm #838355Bar ShattyaMemberdavidz
Stop crying and admit the pitiful state of the union. Just because you dont like it, doesnt make it not so. By lying about the current status of the crisis you morph into exactly that person whom you are trying to condemn. Your pants are indeed on fire. Oh another one with a chazkas kashrus has become a Shakran D’oraysa. Woe is us. Woe to the nation of Israel.
December 25, 2011 8:02 pm at 8:02 pm #838356whatrutalkingabtMemberBar Shattya- You and pba are waaayyy to obsessed with skinny girls. I think it would be pretty funny if you marry a skinny girl and she gets fat after her first baby
December 25, 2011 8:16 pm at 8:16 pm #838357Bar ShattyaMemberWhat a sick joke. I think it would be funny if you marry and then he/she “starts” smoking after you get married. hahahaha so funny.
Mods its not fair whatrutalkingabt is making jokes as not funny as dead baby jokes. sickening.
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.