Torah613Torah, thnk you very much. Please spread the word.
Cheaper gifts:
aleph beis puzzles, nice judaica coloring book with crayons, A cute children’s CD such as Marvelous Middos Machine, Uncle Moishy…., plush shabbos set which includes a stuffed becher challah and candles.
More expensive but appreciated:
Judaica: mini challah cover – my son uses it every shabbos and is so proud, a silver plated little becher, kids size tallis, Brachos book – this is adorable – there are pictures of diff foods and buttons to press and you hear the bracha played out loud.
Non Judaica the possibilties are endless, any type of toy, fire truck with lights, kids tool box, train set.
Hope this is helpful, no I do not own a toy store, but I made an upsherin about a year ago.