Tanaim and Techiyas Hameisim

Home Forums Bais Medrash Tanaim and Techiyas Hameisim

Viewing 16 posts - 1 through 16 (of 16 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #599752

    Has anyone heard that in order to get your name into the Mishnah you had to be able to do techiyas hameisim?

    Does anyone know the source for this?

    #814999
    Sam2
    Participant

    It sounds very strange. I don’t doubt that they could, but it’s just a weird requirement.

    #815000
    bezalel
    Participant

    How would you know if someone is able to do techiyas hameisim if they haven’t actually done techiyas hameisim?

    #815001
    yitayningwut
    Participant

    I’ve heard it too. Never saw the source though. Try googling it.

    #815002

    bezalel: when I become a tana I’ll let you know.

    tayning: i tried

    #815003
    gezuntheit
    Member

    I think it is truly truly amazing that our yiddishe chachomim were capable of reviving the dead a “mere” 1800 years ago. Mi k’amchu yisroel!

    #815004
    yitayningwut
    Participant

    I heard it about the entire Gemara.

    I have a shtickel raya that it’s not true, from the story of Rabba and R’ Zeira in Megilla (7b). One year at the Purim seuda, Rabba got drunk, shechted R’ Zeira, and then brought him back to life. The next year Rabba invited R’ Zeira again, but R’ Zeira declined, saying he was worried Rabba would shecht him again and a miracle wouldn’t occur this time.

    Now, if this were true, 1) Why was it called a miracle? They knew how to do it, presumably through heejee beejee, so why would you call it a miracle? and 2) What’s the big deal? Just bring along some friends as backup, if Rabba can’t resuscitate him the others will!

    #815005

    That’s only a raya that the amoraim couldn’t. Maybe the tanaim could.

    #815006
    yungerman1
    Participant

    yitayningwut- Its a shvacha raya. 1. Techias Hameisim is considered a miracle, just one that they had the ability to perform. 2. Since its a miracle it is a big deal. Hashem may not allow them to do it again.

    Derech HaMelech- I dont think its quite the way you phrased it. Its not like they all had to pass a test to get into the Mishna. “Field trip to the cemetery. Whoever raise the dead gets in the book, those who cant… you lose!”

    My understanding is everyone that is mentioned (I heard in the Gemara) is on the Madreiga that they could have been mechaye meisim if necessary. Its just pointing out the Gadlus of those Tanaim.

    #815007
    HolyMoe
    Participant

    See Gemara Avoda Zara 10b: Antoninus tells the Tanna Rabbi Yehuda HaNassi: “I know that even the smallest of you can make the dead live”.

    So it is clear that this gentile nobleman understood as a simple matter of fact that even the smallest Tanna can perform Tchiyas HaMeisim.

    #815008
    yitayningwut
    Participant

    HolyMoe – Good raya.

    #815009

    That’s a good one unless anyone knows anything more direct.

    #815010
    bezalel
    Participant

    My understanding is everyone that is mentioned (I heard in the Gemara) is on the Madreiga that they could have been mechaye meisim if necessary.

    Based on Megillah 7B and Sanhedrin 90B, I’d say that the Amoraim in general were not nessasarily capable of Techiyas Hameisim and that Rabba was exceptional in this regard.

    #815011
    ItcheSrulik
    Member

    I heard that in yeshiva but I could never find a source. In the end I found it in a kuntres of popular “chazals” that are not found in the primary sources (Mishna, Tosefta, Bavli, Yerushalmi, Sifra, Sifre).

    HolyMoe: Who said he was right? Who says it wasn’t guzma?

    #815012
    deiyezooger
    Member

    According to the Mharsa”h the gemarah in Megilah 7b should not be interperated literly.

    #815014
    littleapple
    Member

    The gem in BK 117a an incident with Rav Yochanan and Rav Kahane also may involve techiyas hamasim but it seems it was not thru a mofas but tefilla.

Viewing 16 posts - 1 through 16 (of 16 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.