- This topic has 66 replies, 25 voices, and was last updated 8 years, 10 months ago by .
-
Posts
-
“those eating one gender and those eating the other” sounds like cannibalism.
Misogynistic cannibals!
Joseph, if you ever eat out on Yom Tov, in middle of the meal wordlessly take a napkin and wrap up a piece of meat to take home. It’s a mitzvah to eat on Yom Tov.
sdd: Everyone has their own Yom Tov meal. Not everyone has a Bris that morning.
Have you not seen the baal simcha’s caterer bringing bags and wrappings specifically for the purpose of guest’s taking home food from the Bris? This is quite common not strange.
It’s strange that it’s common. The ba’alei simchos only bring the wrappings once the custom has become widespread. No one wants to be the grump who posts a sign that says, “Attn. everyone: I am providing a s’udah for the bris, not all your meals for the day.”
sdd: You haven’t addressed my first point above.
Joseph, you need a written confession from me? Here goes:
My above argument comparing taking food home from a b’ris to taking food home from a y”t s’udah was erroneous, as Joseph so accurately pointed out.
Now when anyone is planning a bris they need to include in the count and order bagels form everyones coworkers and the kids Morahs. that can add up to quite an expense.
I went to a bris today. I took a bagel, and lox, and a cinnamon bun, and a coffee. I ate them while driving after I left. And that’s just how it was.
You ate the coffee?
Poured it into my mouth while chewing the other stuff, and then chewed it all up together.
Why?
Just wondering altz shiur for brochoh achroinoh.
DaasYochid~ thanks for remembering my link 🙂
we served fleishigs for ours sons’ brissim… decades ago.
our grandsons’ brissim have been milchig.
looking forward to the bris of our 10th grandchild, ka’h, on Monday, iy’H! Mazel Tov! 🙂
Harav Aharon Feldman Shlita, Rosh Hayeshiva D’Yeshivas Ner Yisroel in Baltimore will not attend a bris if fleishigs is not served because he holds that people are mezalzel in seudas mitzva of a bris.
why is milchigs a zilzul? on shavuos many people have a milchig yomtov meal. is that a zilzul? nowhere is fleishigs a requirement for a seudas mitzvah.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.