Seeing Stars

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Seeing Stars

Viewing 41 posts - 1 through 41 (of 41 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #605032
    popa_bar_abba
    Participant

    So lots of married couples like to talk about how when you are dating, you shouldn’t expect to “see stars” or to “be in love” or special things like that.

    And lots of married couples have bad marriages.

    ??? ?? ????

    (See also this post below http://www.theyeshivaworld.com/coffeeroom/topic/seeing-stars#post-456915)(added to OP at OP’s request)

    #946292
    shein
    Member

    True love only comes once you are already married.

    #946293
    WIY
    Member

    Lots of couples see stars after marriage: she throws things at him, he sees stars.

    #946294
    WolfishMusings
    Participant

    True love only comes once you are already married.

    You know, I loved my wife before we married and I love her today.

    Considering the fact that you don’t know my wife or myself and can’t possibly know about our feelings for each other over the years that we’ve been together, do you mind telling me how you know when I “truly” loved my wife and when I didn’t?

    The Wolf

    #946295
    Sam2
    Participant

    Shein: I have a Rashi in Kesuvos that seems to disagree with you.

    #946296
    shein
    Member

    Sam2: Please quote the Rashi in context so we can determine how you may have misunderstood it.

    #946297
    Sam2
    Participant

    Shein: 7a (maybe 8a), where it discusses the Sheva Brachos. On the words, “Re’im Ha’ahuvim”, Rashi translates that as “Re’im Ha’ohavim Zeh Es Zeh”. Please, tell me how I misunderstood that. I don’t claim to have perfect P’shat in everything, but this one seems pretty clear (to me, at least).

    (By the way, it’s idiotic when people say that a wedding should be the “happiest day of their lives”. It shouldn’t be at all. The couple should love each other more and be happier and happier together constantly after their marriage. But this Rashi clearly states that it’s assumed that there are already feelings of love under the Chuppah.)

    #946298
    shein
    Member

    Now can you understand the difference between plain love and true love? (Then notice the terminology I employed.)

    #946299
    Sam2
    Participant

    Plain love and true love? What are you, an ad for a Disney movie? How about we let people who love each other determine what their love is. There’s no reason to judge or set rules about this for anything.

    #946300

    I agree with Sam2, Wolfish and PBA – shein, your comments don’t make sense.

    Indeed I can quote Wolfish and I am also quite sure of this: “You know, I loved my wife before we married and I love her today.”

    #946301

    Love is very fleeting.

    #946302
    Oh Shreck!
    Participant

    Aren’t you supposed to see the stars on sukkos?

    #946303
    HaLeiVi
    Participant

    Popa is right. You are supposed to check with your local astronomer before committing.

    #946304
    Brony
    Participant

    And to think I was all set to post the gripping tale of the time I helped Natalie Portman pick out a sefer in Eichlers. Oh well, some other time.

    #946305
    WIY
    Member

    Brony

    Right cause that happened. …

    #946306
    Torah613Torah
    Participant

    Brony – I saw a famous actor once. My friend said he was. But I can’t remember the name though.

    I would like to see Obama someday, and make the bracha on seeing a king.

    #946307
    soulguy
    Member

    I actually saw a definition that love is appreciating anothers goodness,which should ring true for anyone,and to brony-your better than that,you dont have to bring your lustful fantasies to the public,may hashem guide you!

    #946308
    Brony
    Participant

    ^ lol wut. stay off the green bro, it isn’t 4:20 just yet.

    #946309
    WIY
    Member

    Torah

    If you were to see Obama you say the bracha without Hashems name.

    #946310
    Brony
    Participant

    nah w/ a bracha bro, dude has drones.

    #946311
    Torah613Torah
    Participant

    WIY: I thought Rabbi Yosef said to say it.

    #946312
    HaLeiVi
    Participant

    You’ll be able to say it when he changes term limits and makes a state of emergency.

    #946313
    WIY
    Member

    Torah

    The Steipler, Satmar Rav (Reb Yoel) and Shu”t Beer Moshe pasken otherwise. If you are a sefardi and he is your posek you may follow him otherwise you should do as the Ashkenazi poskim pasken.

    #946314
    oomis
    Participant

    I do believe that people can “fall in love” and see stars before they get married. That’s part of the initial chemistry. Real, meaningful, deep and abiding love comes after two people have been married, live together, hopefully BE”H raise a family together, and seen the good and less good in each other and still want to be together. But we should not discount the initial feelings. They are more based on attraction, but that is what brings people together in the beginning. The real love is what keeps them together after that “honeymoon” phase wears off a bit.

    #946315
    popa_bar_abba
    Participant

    In fact, remembering the initial attraction and “stars” is what can get a marriage back on track many years later after a falling apart and bitterness and acrimony.

    It is so powerful that Hashem references it as the moshol for how He will draw us back despite everything that has happened between us. ??? ????? ????? ?????? ???? ?? ??? ???? ????? ?? ??? ?????? ???? ???????

    #946316
    popa_bar_abba
    Participant

    Hmm. That was a really good point. I wish it wasn’t buried here in the middle of a thread. Maybe I should ask them to put it in my OP also. But that will mess up the elegance of the OP.

    Hmmm.

    Maybe I should start 10 new threads with this as the OP.

    #946317
    hahahaha
    Member

    What’s going on here today?

    the use of words are terribly inappropriate for a setting such as this! The crowd that is reading and responding to this is made up of single girls, boys, married ladies and men etc… How can you bring up an extremely volatile subject as this, in a mixed crowd of anonymous people?

    #946318
    playtime
    Member

    so why are you laughing?

    #946319
    Torah613Torah
    Participant

    Popa, please define “a lot” and in your anecdotal observation, how much do the two sets of “seeing stars” and “happy marriage” intersect?

    #946320
    popa_bar_abba
    Participant

    Popa, please define “a lot” and in your anecdotal observation, how much do the two sets of “seeing stars” and “happy marriage” intersect?

    Let “seeing stars” be x, and “happy marriages” by y.

    y = x squared

    #946321
    OneOfMany
    Participant

    if anyone is having a problem with seeing stars I will be glad to call up Bugs Bunny and have him solve that problem for you ^_^

    #946322
    Torah613Torah
    Participant

    lol

    Did you mean to reverse x and y? So that the (square) root of a “happy marriage” is “sees stars”?

    #946323
    popa_bar_abba
    Participant

    Again, I’m tayning that seeing stars makes happy marriage. So if X is 1, I want y to be 1, and if x is 2, then y is 4, and if x is 3, then y is 9.

    So the curve will curve upward exponentially (in the mathematical sense). The more x, you get even more and more y.

    #946324
    Torah613Torah
    Participant

    But your way, x is always greater than y. So the set of x’s, of people who see stars, is always greater than set y of happy marriages.

    So the amount of people who see stars, exceeds the number of people who have happy marriages. So people who see stars don’t always have happy marriages.

    Am I misunderstanding your equation?

    #946325
    popa_bar_abba
    Participant

    Yes, you are.

    My curve is graphing the relationship between the extent to which you see stars, and how good your marriage is. Thus, if you are a 1 on the seeing stars axis, you will only be a 1 on the marriage happiness axis. (how do I make the negative work? it seems like negative stars would still make positive happiness in my graph).

    You are correct that this is different from how my original post was posed, which was that seeing stars is a binary decision and then happy marriage correlates with seeing stars. If so, I need to make a new graph.

    x is how much stars you are seeing.

    y is happy marriage.

    the definition of seeing stars is 100

    y = x – 100 (I’m not making it exponential because I’m not math sophisticated enough)

    #946326
    spelt
    Member

    popa:

    How does one know the difference between infatuation and love, when seeing stars?

    #946327
    popa_bar_abba
    Participant

    spelt: Who says they are different?

    #946328
    spelt
    Member

    If they are not different, you admit the idea of seeing stars is another way of referring to infatuation.

    #946329
    Torah613Torah
    Participant

    Okay, that works.

    By removing the exponential, you’re also taking care of the negative stars issue.

    #946330
    popa_bar_abba
    Participant

    If they are not different, you admit the idea of seeing stars is another way of referring to infatuation.

    We don’t need to use the word “admit”; this is not a interrogation, and I’m not trying to hide anything from you. When we discuss something, we can use the word “concede”.

    My response is that I’m not completely sure. I think that they are pretty much the same thing, but if you describe a behavior or feeling and I think that is not what I’m referring to, then I’ll say that.

    #946331
    soulguy
    Member

    hey brony-i dont get the green and 4:20?

Viewing 41 posts - 1 through 41 (of 41 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.