- This topic has 139 replies, 30 voices, and was last updated 13 years, 10 months ago by .
-
Posts
-
if this is going to become a scotch vs bourbon machlokes so be it
but i need some information
i have to bring a bottle of whiskey to a Sholom Zochor this Shabbos.
im tired of seeing glenthis and glenthat and would like to bring bourbon for a change. i heard woodford reserve is good.
but is anyone going to drink it?
in other words, bottom line question, is bourbon anywhere near as popular as scotch or only a small minority of people that like it?
Real men drink Bourbon.
Try a rye.
Probably few 😉
Seriously tho, it depends. If you go to a kiddush there are always more Scotches than Bourbons but the few bottles of Bourbon are always polished off.
So good to know there are a few good men out there…
sac is right that real men drink bourbon and though there are normally less options the bourbons tend to go faster.
Woodford is a good choice because it’s smoother than most bourbons so many people will drink it.
Mazel Tov!
Woodford is a good choice because its non-threatening. Its recognizable to those who arent connoisseurs, it isnt complex, it doesnt feel like you are swallowing acid, and of course, the price is right.
Real men drink Bourbon.
I guess I’m not a real man. I don’t drink either.
The Wolf
“I guess I’m not a real man. I don’t drink either”
You’re an Angel 😉
Don’t feel bad. Wolves drink water, and they’re pretty fierce.
On the other hand, do you chase down moose and eat them off the carcass? Because if you don’t, you may need to at least drink bourbon.
Bring something everyone will drink.
Something strong, a man’s drink.
Real Diet Coke.
The one of a kind.
Mazel Tov 🙂
seriously, if you are buying it to make the drinkers happy, get a scotch.
While you’re at it, get one that is not sherry cask so everyone will be comfortable with it.
popa
I know some heavy drinkers… they all prefer Bourbon.
Scotch is a status symbol.
bourbons are by definition aged in new charred oak casks. That is why they are popular among yeshivish people.
That is also why it is funny that bourbon is now the most problematic.
People will tell you that scotch and bourbon are something you have to “acquire a taste for”.
I can’t figure out why.
I can understand “acquiring a taste for” something that is good for you, like broccoli or spinach, but alcohol? – Sorry, I don’t get it.
ainohd:
Are you kidding? Which part don’t you get?
It makes you feel good.
I believe the alleged issues with bourbon are the fact that they may be jewish owned and therefore chometz sheavar on pesach.
I dont know if I believe the issues but I cant bring myself to drink anything on the list just in case. I guess B”H I have a better heart than head.
“I would like him to chime in here”
Are you kidding? I see a post on booze, and you think for a BP minute,I’m not in on the action?
The only thing I woould add is this: any of the Kentucky batches are good and you can get something nice for $35 – $50. Woodford is a good choice. The Wild Turkey, Rare Breed we have now, is a bit too high a proof for my liking (101), so aim for something a bit lighter (in case I stop by 🙂
And Sac, real men drink bourbon, but real RICH men drink scotch. Give me a choice of 21 y/o scotch or a bourbon of the same age, and I’m off to the highlands!
mod 80
if your price range is in the 30’s you won’t get better than woodford reserve. it’s an excellent choice, go with it.
ps if you don’t like bourbon or scotch try amaretto.
Real men never drink and drive (i know the original post was about a Shalom Zochor and would not be applicable) but seriously if u imbibe take a cab home
Not sure what real men drink, but personally I really like bourbon much better than scotch.
Mod-80 – If you want to bring something that’s “shoveh l’chol nefesh” – try a scotch that’s in a bourbon cask. One great bottle is Auchetoshen classic, it runs about 30-32 bucks & is enjoyed by both scotch & bourbon drinkers!
Give me a choice of 21 y/o scotch or a bourbon of the same age
We can’t give you that choice, because bourbon is aged only 2 years.
Please Sac, tell me how you manange to get that past the Mods :D. From time to time,I get the EDITED potch, and need to know how to skirt the line, without getting whacked.
I paused for a min before approving it but then i thought: no I’m reading too much into it, knowing the poster I’m sure its a benign comment.
BPT
Look what you did!
Figured it out.
auchentauchen is not a bourbon or shaveh to it either.
Mod
It was a benign comment. And before I pressed “Send” I was thinking are they going to post it or are they going to read to much into it?
Then I figured na…
So, thanks BPT! 🙂
“If you want to bring something that’s “shoveh l’chol nefesh” – try a scotch that’s in a bourbon cask.”
Are you nuts?! No bourban man will go near any scotch. I’ve already converted two of my scotch sons-in-law to bourban, because that’s where the real flavor is. Woodford is ok, but not my first choice.
” I’m sure its a benign comment. “
Good call, 80. After all, Sacrilige is such an eidel maidel!
arc – please read what I wrote: it’s a scotch that’s in a bourbon cask. Additionally, I wrote that it’s “shoveh l’chol nefesh” – not that it’s shoveh to bourbon. Chas v’sholom, I would never say that a scotch is shoveh to a bourbon. Rather, it can be enjoyed by both scotch & bourbon drinkers, as it has the taste of both.
“Sacrilige (sic) is such an eidel maidel!”
You have no idea 😉
Im saying it isnt shoveh to bourbon and half the taste isnt bourbon and half isnt scotch
cherrybim – trust me, I’m also a pretty strict scotch drinker. I’m not converted like your sons-in-law, I have been for many years. However, on the rare occasion that I come to a Kiddush & there’s no bourbon left – scotch in a bourbon cask will do b’dieved. But, it’s certainly no subsitute for my regulars – Baker’s, Maker’s Mark, Corner’s Creek, Rowan’s Creek, etc.
I bought Rowans creek recently. did you recommend it in the bourbon thread? it’s pretty good, better taste than corner creek imo.
arc – yes, I highly reccomend it. It’s my one of my favorites. It is better than Corner Creek, but usually a bit more expensive than Corner Creek.
lkwdfellow
Did you ever try Four Roses, is it any good?
There was a small difference I think it was $33 instead of $30
cherrybim – sorry, meant to say – trust me, I’m also a pretty strict BOURBON drinker, NOT SCOTCH. I guess I already had 1 l’chayim too many l’koved Chanuka….
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.