Name "Batsheva" for Seventh Child

Home Forums Family Matters Name "Batsheva" for Seventh Child

Viewing 19 posts - 1 through 19 (of 19 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #602465
    gabie
    Member

    Is the name Batsheva sometimes given to the seventh child who happens to be a girl, even if there are some boys among the first six children, or does the name tend to be given when a person k’h has his 7th girl, which might be his 10th or 12th child?

    Also, shouldn’t an Ashkenazi use the name “Bassheva”, as opposed to the Sephardic Batsheva?

    #859640
    yitayningwut
    Participant

    Also, shouldn’t an Ashkenazi use the name “Bassheva”, as opposed to the Sephardic Batsheva?

    They do, as far as I know (though I suppose it depends on how “modern” you are).

    #859641
    postal
    Member

    Is Bassheva one word or two?

    #859642
    147
    Participant

    According to the compendium of names at end of Chapter 129 in Eben ho’Ezer, Bas Sheva is spelled as 2 words.

    Both Bas Sheva & Bat Sheva are spelled the same way in Hebrew, so this entire question of which name to utilize, is a mute point.

    If you wish to strictly adhere to Ashkenazic pronouciation, here are some quandries which I have:-

    Why do Ashkenazim pronounce Ezra & not Ezro?

    Why do Ashkenazim pronounce Hadassah & not Hadassoh?

    Who invented Nochum, since Nachum is written with a Patach?

    Who invented Yeruchom, when 1st verse in Haftoro of 1st day of R’H calls him Yerauchom?

    Who invented Yerachmiel, when name is Yerachme’el?

    As far as 1st question, if there is prcedent to utilize name of Bas Sheva for 7th child or 7th daughter:- There is only 1 prcedent:- Utilize a name which both Dad & Mum like, and find pleasant; & if Elisheva is more your taste, this works just fine.

    #859643
    tzaddiq
    Member

    what is the significance of the ‘seventh’ daughter, as opposed to the other daughters, that there is a special name specifically for her (what about Bas Sheysh for the sixth or Bas Chameish for the fifth daughter, etc.)?

    #859644
    147
    Participant

    We don’t coin new names. ………. Bas Sheva is already an extant name in Nach.

    #859645
    gabie
    Member

    I never heard an Ashkenaz called Bassheva. It always seems to be Batsheva.

    #859646
    chofetzchaim
    Member

    I know a family who named their first daughter Rishona.

    #859647
    ItcheSrulik
    Member

    147:

    1) Because diqdhuq could be an Elvish word made up by Tolkein for all most people care about it.

    2) ditto

    3) Somewhere along the line it was decided that a kamatz is somehow more frum.

    4) The Yeruchom we name after is not that Yeruchom. Ours is the masculine form of Hoshea’s wife’s (daughter? I forget) name. (OK, I made that one up)

    5) Sh’va na can easily become a chirik with the right (wrong) accent.

    #859648
    ambush
    Participant

    Rishona? Are you serious??

    #859649

    @ ambush- Of course it’s serious. They ended up naming their last child Acharon, but the other kids ended up disliking Acharon because, as they said, “Why is Acharon, Acharon always chaviv???”

    #859650
    Shticky Guy
    Participant

    You can call your daughter bas/bat sheva wherever she comes in the family, though i’d much rather my daughter to be called bas talmid chacham…

    #859651
    A Heimishe Mom
    Participant

    Using Bat/Bas Sheva (or Elisheva) for a 7th girl or 7th child who is a girl is purely a cutesy thing to do. As is naming your first Rishona (and yes, I do know a Rishona who is the first).

    As to the one word vs two words: It technically, as per proper dikduk and usage in Navi, should be either two words or one hyphenated word. However, common convention spells it as one word.

    As to the Bat vs Bas – as far as dikduk, not sure when it is, but it might actually be Bat in certain scenarios. But in general, most Ashkinazim resort to the Bat for convention’s sake.

    #859652
    gabie
    Member

    Like Ben-Tzion is two words.

    #859653
    bpt
    Participant

    Leah had her 7th but chose to go with Dina instead of Batshevah. Why not follow her lead?

    #859654
    A Heimishe Mom
    Participant

    Gabie: in Hebrew everyone does spell Ben/Bat Tzion as two words. In English, however, its one word, and Bat rather than Bas – even by Ashkenazim. As a mentioned, convention does play a very big role here. For some reason Batsheva is just not usually split. (I DID look into it so I am not talking out of my head.)

    #859655
    gabie
    Member

    Bat Tzion?? I never heard of a name other than Ben-Tzion. And I have seen it spelled as two words in English.

    #859656
    Sam2
    Participant

    AHM: There would never be a Dagesh in the Taf in Batsheva. Honestly, I would guess that people name their kids Batsheva instead of Bassheva because it’s easier to say. It’s hard to get out a “sh” sound right after an “s”. It’s much easier after a “t”.

    #859657
    147
    Participant

    According to the Medrash that each of the tribes was born with a twin sister, and Benjamin with 2 triplet sisters, Leah would have no reason to name her daughter Bas Sheva, rather than Dinoh, her birth being way after 7 children.

    But then, Dinoh would have been the 7th daughter, which brings us back to the 1st paragraph in this coffee room discussion.

Viewing 19 posts - 1 through 19 (of 19 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.