Leaving children alone in the house

She could invest in a treadmill, or walk when her son is in school or when her husband (or another adult) is home. Child Protective Services could remove your nephew from the home for what they see as negligence.

duvdl: not true. ny does not have any set rules as to when a child may be home alone. the c.s.a of new york wont interfere after about 10 (though they advise to wait to 12), since many pediatricians claim that the age of 10 is fine to be left alone. maryland has the age of 8, and connecticut 12.

shindy: have your sister check her local csa (children services administration, or similar state agency) for the guidelines, if such exist. if she cant find them, have her make a call, and get the persons name, time/date of the call, and the personnel number of the representative that she is speaking to. get a definitive answer, and she will be ok, LEGALLY.

as to whether it is smart, it truly all depends on the 10 year old.

My friend told me the other day that her sister wanted to go to slichos and leave her BABY (~5-6 month old!) home and leave the phone on speaker and asked her sister (my friend) to leave her phone on to use as a moniter! I was sure she refused because it’s unsafe but no! She wanted to go to sleep! I was shocked. Besides for the fact that the phone could get disconnected at any time without notice, what if there is a fire? What if the baby stops breathing? I am aware that these things cannot always be caught even if the mother is home but there is a much greater chance. I don’t have a child yet but I find it hard to understand how a child is not precious enough to a mother to give up her desires for the sake of the child’s safety.

Shindy, if you have trouble leaving your 17 year old alone, I think you have a bigger problem than just leaving your child alone. Who did you want to talk to about your sister? The cops?

If the 10 year old knows that he might wake up and Mom will be out, I have no problem with it if the child is mature. As for the infant with the baby monitor that depends on how far away the baby sitter was. Was she next door or down the block?

BTW, for you parents with boys in dorms, you might not want to know who are the “adults” in the dorm. I was horrified to hear that my 18 years old and his friends were the oldest in the dorm-no dorm councelor. I asked him what would he do if there was an emergency? I don’t remeber the answer, but I remember not being happy about it. Then in another son’s dorm, there was a 19 year old dorm concelor, but he liked to hang out with the councelor from the other dorm, across the street.

My 17 year old “baby” left for a dorm this year. I’m sure I will hear in a few years what went on that he would’t tell me at the time. I heard from my other boys AND from my daughter in sem. So…is your baby going to seminary?

if she gets in and we can afford the $$$

Shaindy, Gateshead is about 1/2-1/3 the price of Israel. You don’t get the great Israel experience, but you do get a great education and hashgafa. The “new” sem, BCR, now is good for college credits.

Have nachas from all your children.

I am not for going away for sem at all, but if it is necessary for whatever reason, I think I would chose a sem outside of israel. I live in Yerushalayim right now and am not so impressed with what I see of the girls in Sem. In Gateshead, they can gain really a lot without all the fun, fun, fun. So if a girl is really serious about going to sem and learning, she won’t mind going to one out of eretz yisroel. Of course if she wants to get a chance to be in Eretz Yisroel and go to the kosel, kevarim etc., why not spend succos there (it’s cheaper to fly there than to the U.S., and she probably will not be desperate to come home just a few weeks after arriving.)

Shindy,

Who said there is anything wrong with being a “frummy”? That should be a compliment as opposed to an insult. But anyway, about your comment. You’re right, I shouldn’t have said it that way. But once I brought it up, let me clarify. I shouldn’t have made such a blanket statement. There are those girls who come really to learn and stay off the streets (I don’t mean literally; they go to the supermarket etc.) but they don’t go out for ice cream all the time and don’t talk loudly on the buses. Then there are those who, I guess you can negate the previous sentences for them. They do do all the above and more unfortunately. I am not even saying that I would not have acted that way. They obviously don’t realize. Most of them are good girls who just don’t get that they are living in a regular city where everyone is living a regular day to day life while they are in a sort of camp setting except in middle of a regular neighborhood. So, as I said, this should not be taken as loshon horah on a whole group, but on certain individuals who you (and even I) do not know who they are. So, why am I bringing this up? Because most girls in sems here, have more opportunities for “fun”. I in no way have anything against fun. I think it’s very important. But you have to seriously consider what the purpose of your daughter’s year is here. Fun? Or learning? Growing? Or all of the above?

You say you weren’t such a tzadeikes at that age yet. Well neither was I and don’t htink I am a tzadeikes right now either. Maybe when I am your age I will be one! (I am MUCH closer to the sem girls age than to your age, by the way, so I can probably remember what it’s like better than you can. Besides for that, I’m sure you know more than me. I hope I didn’t come across as someone who thinks she knows it all. I didn’t mean to.)

Shindy,

You should not need to ask the question of whether to say anything to your sister, on

this site or ask any authorities.

Common sense dictates that leaving a 10 year old sleeping alone is outright dangerous and irresponsible. As others have pointed out, will a cell phone awake the child in case of a fire C”V?

Is ten really so young? When I was six, I was able to walk one mile from my house to my best friend’s house. I guess it would depend on the child – is he responsible?

Shindy, I agree with you on the year of fun. Sometimes, people forget that life is about LIVING (obviously while keepin the mitzvos), not just learning about what you cannot do in life.

Times have changed, we live in a very dangerous world (even in heilegeh Monsey), and there is no such thing as SAFELY leaving a young child alone. If G-d forbid a fire broke out, guaranteed if the child survived, he would be removed from the home and the parents would be the subject of every news report.

Actually, I read in the October issue of Reader’s Digest (sorry, I do read things besides the Jewish papers) that acording to police records, violence by strangers against children is down to the level it was in the 70s. What has changed is the hype by the media i.e. radio, internet etc. This causes the level of paranoia to increase. You have to use sense, but you can’t make yourself or your kids too crazy.

BTW, to those that are very paranoid or controling about where there children are, how do you send a child to sem in Israel when in most sems from Friday afternoon until Sunday, the sem has only the girl’s word where she is? I’m not judging, but I’ve always wondered.

shindy: Its not OK!

Not every parent is such a maiven on their kids,

like they think they are!

Also not every possible scenario is considered by parents

(wanting to leave, they will justify it as responsible)

& you should intervene!

When bad things happen people always say

“how could the parents do such a thing?”

but beforehand, “it’s ok, Nish Geferlich!”

only if one truly considers that something bad might happen

will they rethink their decision.

Children are as responsible as you allow them to be. Ten used to be responsible, now 24 is too young.

Yes.

A ten year old may be very responsible (I babysat at that age, during the daytime), or might him/herself be in need of a babysitter. But no matter how responsible, in my personal opinion a ten year old should not be left alone in the house when he or she is not awake.

This ten year old is now fifteen. I think at this point he can stay sleeping home alone

Not everyone has a dog, and a dog cannot tella 10 year old the right thing to do in an emergency. Suppose there is a carbon monoxide buildup, the CM detectors are not working and the dog AND the boy are overcome, ebcause they were both sleeping. Clearly the mom is up, she went out to walk. A kid of age 10 should not be left alone unless he is awake and aware, IMO. And then, only if he is a responsible kid. And DEFINITELY not when there are younger children home also.