- This topic has 23 replies, 10 voices, and was last updated 10 years, 6 months ago by .
-
Posts
-
A certain ad disturbs my sensitivity. Just wondering… no one else seems disturbed. Or maybe no one else is here (where) now.
Which ad? Where?
On my little device, I shut off images and Flash doesn’t work anyhow. So, I’m completely fine with all the ad placeholders.
Froggie, what’s wrong with just ignoring it? These days it is virtually impossible to avoid everything, adverts included, that may be offensive. One kind of ad that I find offensive are the ones that, for a specific donation amount, 40 “tzadikim” will daven at the Kosel for 40 days and 40 nights which is a sure segula and cure fore everything from cancer to athlete’s foot.
????? is doche ???.
This works even without any filter installed (I think!) Go to Chrome App Store and download free “Ad Block”. It simply makes all the adds vanish.
Dunno about Internet Explorer or Firefox.
I didn’t see any such ad, on any screen. Maybe it’s your browser.
LF: Do you have any idea how many people who have zero connection to Yiddishkeit learn something and come closer to being Frum because of Birthright?
LF, based on my observation, these ads are generated according to content, as you’ll find with some email providers.
The programmed algorithms generated “Jewish” (or Israel) themed ads based on the content in the CR.
Sam, that may or may not be the case, but it doesn’t excuse pritzus.
yekke2, happy to hear someone litens to my ideas on how to block ads
Froggie, I’m 70 years old. At my age I don’t have to avoid temptation, Temptation avoids me.
?? ????? ????? ?? ??? ????
DY- we already know that Negiya Can Save Yiddishkeit, so why not all types of pritzus?
Agav, to Sams point, it may feel good to make a cholent for someone who has zero connection to yiddishkeit, but it would be a much more worthwhile endeavor to focus that energy on the ones who have a 100% connection to Yiddishkeit and decide they want zero. Kiruv rechokim is so 90’s.
Little Froggie: it is not only you… i was quite perturbed by it! couldn’t believe that A. they chose that picture and B. it was advertised on YWN!
Hodulashem, I think we’ve established that it was not a YWN ad, it was probably a third party ad through your browser.
It’s probably motzi shem ra to blame it in YWN.
LF: I’m not familiar with the ad in question, so I can’t comment directly. I’m not going to make judgment calls on other people’s sensitivities, but if it was up to me I would guess that a girl in a short-sleeve short or shorts in a tiny 4 square-inch ad isn’t going to ruin anyone’s Ruchnius and could bring people to Yiddishkeit.
The reason even Frum Kiruv places are willing to show not-Tznius girls is because they want to give accurate representations of what their programs are. First of all, it’s more honest. And secondly, they don’t want people who wear short sleeves or whatever to feel uncomfortable going on the program.
That being said, people should be smart about ads. Most people using this site are quite Frum and would probably be more sensitive to such things than the average Birthright person. So YWN is probably not the place for such an ad, because the ratio of people who are offended to those who would be interested is probably very, very high. So while I could hear the claim that the ad in general is worth it, putting it on YWN probably isn’t.
I edited Little Froggie’s post, but he described the ad as worse than short sleeves. -100
DY: The site puts the third-party ad generator (something like Google Advertising) on its site allowing that third-party to generate random, supposedly relevant, ads on its site. Without the site putting the third-party ad agent on its site, no third-party ads would appear on the site. Thus the site does bear responsibility for what appears at it has the option to not use a third-party ad service and use only internal, and approved, ads.
Sam: Short-sleeves is forbidden to look at and thus cannot be used in ads. Irregardless if that supposedly might attract non-frum people to look into frumkeit. You can’t do something that causes frum people to sin because it might make non-frum people frum.
I don’t know how that works, but I do know that for me, it didn’t show up on two separate browsers.
DY: To put it more simply, a website needs to allow (and code their website to display) third-party ads in order for them to appear, otherwise no third-party ads can appear on the site.
Do you use an adblocker on your browser? That would explain why you didn’t see the ads even if they’re being displayed.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.