- This topic has 6 replies, 7 voices, and was last updated 13 years, 7 months ago by .
-
Posts
-
Is it just me, or does anyone else find it wierd that people have turned to CR for Shaalas that they should be asking a Rov?
Is the CR becoming a place for Piskei Halachos???
discussing a shaalah is not the same thing as asking one.
No one asks for a p’sak. They ask for advice about something. Most of us say to ask a rov.
you seem to be insinuating that there are no rabbanim in the CR
😉
we have heard this expressed here over and over and over again.
you never discussed a Halachic issue with someone who wasnt a Posek?
you dont talk about Halachic issues with your friends?
do you meet with a Posek for every single question you ever had? do you call a major Posek when you forgot to say Yaaleh v Yaavoh at Shachris and you forgot the Halachah? maybe you should, but do you?
80,
One difference – if I ask the fellow next to me what to do if I missed Ya’aleh V’yavo, there’s a certain degree of accountability, because I know who he is. An anonymous blogger has nothing to lose if he’s wrong.
I know, I often say what I think the halachah is here, but I don’t expect anyone to follow l’maaseh, and I’ve said that a few times (and in a case where I know I’m right, it’s not my issue anyhow).
I totally agree with you and deiezooger that discussing a halachic issue is different than getting a psak.
The poskei CR are from among the finest in the world. Have some derech eretz, please.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.