hair covering and married women

Home Forums Controversial Topics hair covering and married women

Viewing 15 posts - 51 through 65 (of 65 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #816470
    sam4321
    Participant

    Mishna Brura 75:15

    #816471
    HaKatan
    Participant

    Bottom line: does it look “nice” and “well-put together”, or does it clearly exceed that and demand inappropriate attention?

    Is a long-hair sheitel the latter? Or the former? Or could it be either?

    #816473
    gavra_at_work
    Participant

    How long is “long”? 60 Denier? 80?

    LOL.

    Justice Potter Stewart’s statement of “I know it when I see it” might apply, but makes bad halacha.

    #816474
    mw13
    Participant

    Yaela:

    “In addition, many women now wear sheitels. So many of them look so real that I can’t even tell if they’re wearing one. What is the point of covering your hair with someone else’s hair?”

    Very good point; R’ Elyashiv (may he have a refuah shelaimah) holds the same. I quote:

    Harsh Words Against Sheitels

    (Tuesday, November 4th, 2008)

    [UPDATED INFO BELOW]

    The Rav repeated over and over again the severity of the isur of wearing such sheitels, which the wife and her husband share equal responsibility.

    (718) 906-6400 [Kol HaLashon NY]

    Press 3 for Yiddish

    Press 2 for Gemara

    Press 19 for Rav Eliyashiv

    Press 1 for Pesachim

    Press 173 for the shiur

    While listening to the shiur, press 6 (skips 5 minutes) 4 times.

    There is no need to call Kol Haloshon in EY

    http://www.theyeshivaworld.com/article.php?p=25413

    #816475
    yitayningwut
    Participant

    Sam2-

    I agree.

    However, the statement is very ambiguous.

    In regards to what is it d’rabbanan?

    In regards to speaking ????? ??????? why would you say it’s d’rabbanan? Even if it’s an ?????? and ???? in societal norms, at any rate, if in a particular society it is something which can be called “ervah,” then the pasuk of ??? ???? ?? ???? ??? applies. Which would make it d’oraisa, unless you tell me that drasha is an ??????, but you would have to show your basis for saying that. And if in a particular society it is not called “ervah,” then it would be mutar, as the Aruch Hashulchan paskened and numerous other poskim.

    In regards to covering it, I have already noted here and on a lot of other threads that I don’t believe this halacha primarily has anything to do with ??? ???? ????.

    To everyone saying there is a problem with attractive sheitels: Please see my first post.

    #816476
    amused
    Participant

    Wow, those are sharp words from the Godol HaDor shlit”a.

    #816477
    msseeker
    Member

    “shlishi & msseeker- Look why don’t You call the Poskim and ask them?”

    Because I don’t have a shaila. If I wanted to wear a long shaitel I’d definitely ask.

    #816478
    sam4321
    Participant

    There are Gedolim who do permit it.

    #816479
    Dr. Seuss
    Member

    Such as?

    #816480
    sam4321
    Participant

    Dr.Seuss:In Tshuvas HaGrach Rav Chaim Kanievsky was asked if the Chazon Ish and the Steipler permitted paos nachris, and he answered yes.(see Mishna Brura 75:15 for more info)

    #816481
    amused
    Participant

    Define paos nachris.

    #816482
    Nechomah
    Participant

    Some poskim would say that pe’a nochris is a synthetic sheitel, but others hold that anything made not from the woman’s own hair is a pe’a nochris.

    #816483
    Health
    Participant

    msseeker -“Because I don’t have a shaila. If I wanted to wear a long shaitel I’d definitely ask.”

    First of all, why would a man want to wear a Shaitel? I know I don’t want to wear one.

    And the reason you don’t have a Shaila is because you Paskened for e/o on the page previously that it’s Ossur Gamor!

    #816484
    tahini
    Member

    My married girls have thick long hair they usually wear under an israeli style scarf. When they have a simcha the sheitels come out at their husbands’ requests, when their father first saw them he could not tell they were covering their hair. As a mother I had a dilemma, what to do? They looked gorgeous with their sheitels on, but the sheitels were so similar to natural hair, hard one.

    #816485
    Health
    Participant

    tahini -“under an israeli style scarf”

    Does any hair stick out from these scarfs?

Viewing 15 posts - 51 through 65 (of 65 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.