- This topic has 16 replies, 7 voices, and was last updated 10 years, 10 months ago by .
-
Posts
-
If we’re supposed to be emulating Hashem’s many attributes, how does the “midda k’neged midda” aspect filter down to us humans?
When we emulate Hashem’s traits, we only emulate the “positive” ones — chesed and forgiveness and the like — and not the “negative” ones like punishment for sins or being a “jealous G-d.”
So if someone does something bad to us, that does not give us the right, under the principle of emulating divine traits and midda k’neged midda, to do something similar back to them.
However, certainly if someone does something kind to you then you should also do something kind for them. (But I suppose you should already be doing kind things for them anyway, since G-d is good to all.)
Tomer Devorah, by the Ramak, is available in English online for free. It’s a good manual for emulating Hashem’s traits.
Not every thing are we supposed to emulate. Still I can think of one thing here too.
When criticizing or punishing someone for a wrong s/he did, make sure that person can figure out WHAT they did, in order to correct themselves. That is the purpose of midda k’neged midda – for a person to be able to take note and correct himself.
streekgeek- bais din is supposed to follow that when giving an onesh.
streek
Try your best. If you really think into it you will figure it out.
Hi streekgeek!
Do you know how the two Lkwd girls that were in an accident are doing?
HaShem equips a person with the natural capabilities to figure out certain things, to be able to self correct, readjust. Feelings of shame and guilt. They’re all for a person’s ultimate benefit. A person may try to corrupt and disable those heavenly sent gifts because it’s sometimes to hard to try, to attain a lofty standard.
??? ?????? ?? ???? ??? ???? ????? ??????? ????, this Yashrus is enough for us to (only the intended recipient – not anyone else taking you on a guilt trip) discern HaShem’s message. Sometimes as clear as a bolt of lightening, sometimes not as clear.
Little Froggie-
You’ve started showing your deep side more often these days 🙂
Yes, we learn from Hashem’s Middos of discipline. What does that have to do with hitting a friend you are angry at? We also learn from Hashem how to act as a judge — if you are one.
The response, to only learn from His positive traits, is sad but it made me laugh.
The Gemara says that if someone looks to Shamayim to punish a friend, he gets punished first. The Maharal explains that this person is seeking bad and therefore gets that himself. And although Hashem also punishes, that is for the purpose of the gain for that person or the universe, but it is impossible for a human to seek revenge without the badness.
Any parent can understand this. The difference between the parent punishing and a sibling is a big one.
TAOM: Does that offend / bother you or any one else?
Lil Froggie-
I love it 🙂
“If that’s the case, why would Hashem use this method of punishment in our days? Who can possibly figure out (besides for those few holy people) why they were punished? Who can possibly judge and decide that?”
The books of R’ Shalom Arush discuss this, for example in Garden of Peace (his marriage manual for men). Well worth reading.
Did you put a miniature frog on the dashboard, with a bobbing head, as a reminder?
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.