- This topic has 21 replies, 10 voices, and was last updated 11 years, 1 month ago by .
-
Posts
-
I heard that HaRav Chaim Kanievsky Shlit”a says that even if a Mezuzah is perfectly kosher, if the left “tag” is taller than the right tag on a lamed, then it can cause a person Tzaros – sickness etc… and I heard that since it’s halchically OK, not all sofrim are so makpid with it.
Does anyone know where I can get Mezuzos that are guaranteed to have this done the correct way?
Perhaps you might want to look up what the Rambam has to say about using the Mezuzah as a “shemirah”.
Check out mezuzot that Rav Daniel Cohen has, a very rare high quility ktav by a person with Yirat Shamayim. 718-310-1047
Yussel, are women Mechuyav in Mezuza?
zichronolam.com – they also have a hechsher on their mezuzos
Halevi:
What does that have to do with my comment?
This entire thread is based on hearsay. Why dont you first verify that R’ Chaim actually said what they claim he said.
my friend also heard it from R’ Chaim firsthand, but I don’t think its R’ Chaims chiddush, I think it is brought down earlier
I’m not going to comment on the veracity of these statements, but why on Earth would being M’kayeim a Mitzvah D’oraisa cause Tzaros?
Sam2, you make too much sense. Being too logical is a no-no. People will accuse you of being a kofer.
Sam2, you make too much sense. Being too logical is a no-no. People will accuse you of being a kofer.
Is this a famous mantra? I see it being repeated here at regular intervals.
Call me an am haaretz, but I always thought that only the letters “shatnez gtz” had tagin.
1- This is from sefer shmirat haguf v’hanefesh, a contemporary collection of segulos regardless of source.
2- The version recorded there does not say that it causes tzaros, it says that having the taggim is a segula for shalom bayis.
3- If this segula is true, what did Jews do for all the centuries before we started making lameds that way?
apushatayid: ????”? ?”? get the collection of three taggim with which most people are familiar because those are mentioned in the gemara. Ketav beis yosef has a number of other single taggim, or taggim without heads (sometimes called kotzim, regular taggim are supposed to look like zayin’s) on various letters. The Lamed has two kotzim on the tip and the one on the right is supposed to be larger. Many sofrim don’t bother with the right hand kotz in tefillin and mezuzos at all because of the risk of making a psul.
Being nice to your spouse is also a segula for shalom bayis.
Thanks for the info on tagim.
Oh really? Did you try it?
You’re wrong about being nice to your spouse. It’s not a segula if it makes sense on its own. (you can probably tell that I’m one of the people who tends to cry nichush when hearing such things)
The rambam disagrees with you.
No, the Rambam disagreed with what we call segulos.
Yussel, the Gemara in Kedushin wondered if women are Mechuyav in Mezuza. Then, the Gemara says that it can’t be that they aren’t Mechuyav, since they also need a Shmira. This is besides the Gemara about Rebbi and Antoninus, and Unklos and the soldiers.
The Rambam had an issue with those who used to put strange characters into the Mezuza. This bothered the Rambam, and he said they are turning the Mezuza into some king of charm, which it isn’t. However, the practice seems to have been condoned by Rashi and the Yereim.
Halevi:
As others have pointed out, to claim that a person can have tzaros caused by his fulfilling a Mitzvah is hard to understand.
Although I agree that ‘it seems wierd’, my friend did hear it from R’ Chaim himself [he said its based on the Vilna Gaon].
I think it does not “cause tzarros” but rather can be “meoroer the midas hadin” and [sadly] nobodys perfect.
zichronolam.com mentions the concept, as do other websites that deal with sta”m, and they are also makpid on it – in any case i don’t think it was “made up”.
If I was getting new mezuzos, I would for sure get ones that have this.
Servebesimcha: My first impulse was to ask if you made an appointed to a doctor for OCD diagnosis and treatment. But on second thought it occurred to me that you are being facetious. It is impossible in the range of normative (That is an Israeli definition that may very well be used here in the US.) thought and behavior to have the concerns you have. We have Halacha. That is the only factor that determines whether we use or don’t use something. That is our only standard and guide in life. Besides, I’m certain you misquoted R’ Chaim Kanievsky.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.