- This topic has 12 replies, 8 voices, and was last updated 7 years, 3 months ago by .
-
Posts
-
If someone from the French Satmar community makes aliyah, who becomes thay person’s Rebbe? Does he/she or do they defer to a/the Satmar Rebbe in Israel?
Would said Satmar Rebbe be upset or disappointed that the person didn’t abide by the Satmar Rebbe of France’s decree?
Thank you ☺
Satmar Rebbe To Jews In France: Don’t Make Aliyah To Israel – Save The Children! [LARGE PHOTO ESSAY]
There’s no Satmar Rebbe in France or Israel.
There are Satmar rabbonim in Eretz Yisroel. But the Rebbe is in America.
Regarding France, to the best of my knowledge there aren’t even any Satmar Chasidim living in France. Though the Rebbes are involved in holy work for Klal Yisroel around the world, including for non-Chasidim. Satmar is renown for their chesed that they do for every Jew.
There are 2 Satmar’s Rebbe’s. They are brothers
Neither of whom lives in France, One lives in Williamsburg and the other in Kiryat Joel. Their attitude to each other is well known
Its somewhat bizarre that a Rav who cannot even get along with his own brother feels competent to give musar to the yidden in France whose own sense of security is at risk. He says nothing about how they can resolve their security issues and instead uses his comments to exploit their fears and tell them their children will go OTD if they c’v move to eretz hakodesh where there security will be substantially approved.
Jews in the State of Israel face a greater terror threat than the Jews in France. Furthermore, it has been proven from past experience of many Jews moving to Israel that the government works overtime — unfortunately successfully in the past — to shmadb them against the Torah or otherwise turn frum Jews into chilonim through pubic schooling, etcetera. Hence the rabbonim shlita (including Rav Dovid Feinstein shlita and others), led by the Satmar Rebbe, are working to avoid such a catastrophe by encouraging French Jewry to build up their Torah community in France.
As noted in my response to the original article:
It’s amazing how much of a parallel with the Meraglim in the Dor HaMidbar this presents. The Meraglim were the leaders of the nation, and felt that Am Yisrael was better off in the Midbar, where they were fed by HKB”H and had nothing to do but learn, rather than entering Eretz Yisrael, where they’d have the burden of parnassa and the need to fight the seven nations to deal with. This was the view of ten of the twelve Meraglim – a strong majority – but the right answer was that of Kalev and Yehoshua – “Tova ha’aretz me’od me’od” – the land is very, very good.
I have lost all respect for the various feuding Satmar factions and their leaders. Their belief that Hashgacha Pratis ended in 1948, and that all thereafter is a Ma’ase Satan, and their maintenance of that stance to the detriment of their followers and all other Jews, is self-serving and destructive.
an Israeli Yid
I once knew a Satmar from the Alter Heim. He told me a story how he once met a woman when he was younger who was bragging how none of her family had gone to either the United States or Israel
Joe -“Jews in the State of Israel face a greater terror threat than the Jews in France”
This I agree with. And also in Israel there is a spiritual threat. The zionists that post here can’t begin to see the Truth. Wake up and smell the coffee & I’m Not Satmar!
Like Paris is such a spritual city and there is no temptation to do averaihs in Paris.
If you live in Beitar or Modiin there isn’t a “spiritual threat”. Certainly not more than France.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.