- This topic has 24 replies, 14 voices, and was last updated 13 years, 11 months ago by .
-
Posts
-
(I speak for myself here also!)
How much of davening do we sail thru, convinced that we know what we are talking about, but if someone asks us to translate a word or phraze we suddenely see that we aren’t sure?
I bought my son a siddur with translation under each word and am amazed at what i dont know. I used to think I am fine with my tefilla.
I will list below a few examples. Be honest with yourself and dont cheat. Translate out loud NOW to yourself the whole of the following lines:
?? ???????? ??????? ??????????. ???????? ???????? ????????*
?????? ?? ??????-?? ??? ???????? ?????????. ??????? ?????????????*
?????????? ?’ ???? ???????????*
?’ ??????????? ???????????? ????????? ??. ???????????? ??????? ???????? ???????*
????????? ?????????? ??????? ??? ??????????? ????? ??????????????? ??????*
???? ????? ?’ ?????????. ??????? ???????? ??*
??????? ??-? ??????????. ??????? ?????????? ????????*
?????? ?????????? ??????????. ??????????????? ?????????? ???????*:
??????? ?????????? ?????????? ????????? ????????? ?????????*
AND SHABBOS? Have a try at these:
?????-???????, ???????-?????; ????? ????????? ??????????*
or
????, ????????? ??????????; ?????????? ????????????? ??????*
or?
?????? … ??? ??????????; ???-???????? ??????, ????-????????*
And what about birchas hamazon? Surely we all can manage that? Lets see. Here’s a passuk from the beginning and one from the end:
??????? … ??? ??????????? ???????????? ?????????*
or
?????????? ?????? ????????*
I could go on. In a nutshell, if you,ve managed all these then you’re A-OK. Otherwise, and i’ve asked lots of chashuve people, we must put more effort into tefilla. And thats to look up peshatim and translation BEFORE we go to shul so that when we arrive we can go immediately uninterupted into our tefillas.
Chazal say that the words of davening are not a important as the tefilla shebaleiv. So lets get our hearts in the right place. And we cant do this without understanding what we are saying.
May H’ answer all our tefillos!!!
Israelis know most or all of these because they speak the language. Words like ?????,????,??,???? and others are part of their everyday speech. Americans must learn it independently and therefore their understanding of it is relatively poor. Another reason to live in Israel.
sz: Hebrew is not Loshon HaKodesh.
Now we start all over again with a Hebrew argument…
Anyway, Davening is definitely not the same without knowing what you’re saying.
Trying my best, you can not deny the undenyable: Biblical Hebrew and Modern Hebrew are variations of the same language, and they are very similar. Stop repeating the right-wing propaganda without thinking!
And German is certainly not the Lashon HaKodesh!
Sorry if I was unclear in my last post.
What I meant to say is that Israelis know most of these difficult words found in the davening because they are part of their everyday speech. I’m not sure what is difficult to understand or accept in that fact.
Trying my best, why do Israelis understand the Loshon HaKodesh so well? Please, tell us.
If someone can’t translate davening (I know many can’t) call your elementary school, and ask for your parents tuition back.
This is the first and most important thing they should be teaching!!
Shticky Guy
I can translate all of those but its partly because I daven daily with the Artscroll Interlinear Translated Siddur and I have memorized the meaning of many words.
chesedname
“If someone can’t translate davening (I know many can’t) call your elementary school, and ask for your parents tuition back.
This is the first and most important thing they should be teaching!!”
True but they dont teach it or only teach bits and pieces. I am still waiting for my refund lol.
From 8th grade through 12th I used the regular metzuda siddur and it’s still my favorite. And I got all the words!
Shticky Guy
I dont know who you tested, but any truly Chashuveh person should at least know perush hamilos, (if not in depth mefarshim on Davening) not to say that they arent good Jews, but if they can stomach Davening everyday to Hashem and not knowing what they are saying, there most be something missing with their “chashivuskeit.”
I dont mind to be the first to admit that I couldnt translate some of those words! I’m actually quite shocked aswell. Its back to school for me!!!
Shticky Guy
Forget it people are obviously not looking for public humiliation but it is a busha that there are many words in Davening that people have no clue what they mean.
I always wondered how some people Daven so fast. But its really not such a tough question. When you arent thinking about what you are saying all you are doing is trying to say the words as fast as possible.
The only one I had trouble with was ?’ ??????????? ???????????? ????????? ??.
I put some serious effort into learning the Hebrew language becuase not knowing what davening — or even many of the words they threw around while learning — meant was one of my major gripes in yeshiva.
It is a real shame, but this was another girls vs boys situation. In most yeshivas they taught beiur tefilah to the girls while not doing so with the boys. And of course girls leanred Hebrew/Ivris and boys didn’t. So girls have a little more advantage in this area. I’m not saying that girls/women understand everything word by word but yes the general meaning. Also because we say tehillim more, and probably peak to the english side if we don’t understand something, but again girls were taught tanach, pirkei avos, etc. A lot was translated where boys were at a disadvantage.
Kinor and Navel are musical instruments and higayon means thoughts.
But here is a tough one:
Vhaofanim vchayos hakodesh braash gadol misnasim l’umas serafim, lumasam meshabchim v’omrim. This is the high point of birchos kriyas shema.
Pashuteh Yid
If I remember correctly, Artscroll translates higayon as the higayon, also a musical instrument.
Kinnor and navel are stringed instruments, a higayon is supposedly a type of woodwind.
Pashuteh Yid: Funny, I thought the high point of birchos krias shma was ??? ?????
Shticky: was that addressed to me?
hurray for interlinear siddurim – my davening has taken on a new dimension with them! Thank you artscroll
“tefilla b’lee kavana kguf b’lee neshama”
Maybe Higayon is an instrument. However, we know it means thoughts or expressions, as in hegyon libi. Alei higayon bkinor seems to make sense as expressing oneself through the music of the kinor. Otherwise why lump together two separate instruments? And wouldn’t it be Alei higayon vkinor (a vav not a beis).
As far as the high point, I mean in the sense that this is part of the kedusha which the entire kahal says together out loud.
I apologize, higayon was a mistake, possibly (mis)remembering a vort I saw somewhere, though the rest are described various places in gemara. Grammatically, higayon is the noun form of hegyon which is in turn a binyan (that turns the verb into an adjective on libi in your example) on the root heh-gimmel-heh which refers to a specific type of conteplative thought. Looking at the verse “Higayon b’kinnor” it seems to refer to an example of a type of musical composition for a kinnor. *which is only a violin in modern Hebrew! end minirant*
Fair point about the kedusha. Though in a way, those are the easiest to translate: just point at RaMaK and say “what he said.”
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.