Chofetz Chaim Heritage presentation this year

Home Forums Inspiration / Mussar Chofetz Chaim Heritage presentation this year

Viewing 37 posts - 1 through 37 (of 37 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #598513
    Getzel
    Participant

    I just finished watching the video very powerful

    #796289
    yeshivaguy45
    Participant

    How did you see it already?

    #796290
    Getzel
    Participant

    i am hooked up!

    #796291
    Getzel
    Participant

    Rabbi Frands speech is so powerful i”m shakin to the core by it, he brought out the inyun of family fights so well it made me cry

    #796292
    deiyezooger
    Member

    Whats the link?

    #796293
    Getzel
    Participant

    there is no link its a DVD that will be screened worldwide, check out the preview http://www.cchfusa.org/

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=paxkmqOgD48

    #796294
    deiyezooger
    Member

    Thanks getzel.

    #796295
    ima1997
    Member

    Which one did you see, A or B?

    #796296
    yeshivaguy45
    Participant

    I saw the preview it looks very powerful

    #796297
    Getzel
    Participant

    I JUST WATCHED B AWSOME

    #796298
    MichaelC
    Member

    I also watched it.

    #796299
    ☕️coffee addict
    Participant

    I’m sooooo upset I’m going to miss it because my kid and I are sick so my wife went by herself 🙁 (I asked her to bring home a cd though)

    #796300
    agent
    Participant

    Getzel1 did you go see it or were you able to see it on line?

    #796301
    Getzel
    Participant

    i have all 3 DVDS i watched them on DVD not online

    #796302
    shein
    Member

    getzel: Where can I get the DVD from? And is there a website to view it from too?

    #796303
    agent
    Participant

    Lucky you! I want to see them but cannot get out of the house to go see it!!

    #796304
    Getzel
    Participant

    we screened them so we have the dvds at home

    #796305
    YW Moderator-42
    Moderator

    It seems that they are not available to watch online. But are these available for purchase online?

    I was thinking of the pros and cons of having them online. On the one hand many more people would be able to watch. But on the other hand there is something to the experience of watching it together with many others in a shul and if it was available online many people wouldn’t go.

    #796306
    shein
    Member

    So they should put it online tomorrow for the people who missed it.

    #796307
    ☕️coffee addict
    Participant

    And what about the people that couldn’t go (like me)

    #796308
    smilingrps2
    Member

    Please can someone tell me where to get it, I was busy with my family id still would like to watch it, thanks for any leads

    #796309
    am yisrael chai
    Participant

    “Please can someone tell me where to get it”

    845 352-3505 Chofetz Chaim Heritage foundation

    361 Spook Rock Road

    Suffern, NY 10901

    saw both A&B, both of them powerful, got both & already lent them out!

    #796310
    shein
    Member

    am yisrael chai: The CCHF has it available for sale on DVD?

    #796311
    am yisrael chai
    Participant

    “The CCHF has it available for sale on DVD?”

    They were selling only CDs at the event. However, I just put in a call to someone affiliated with the CCHF & said they would let me know tomorrow be”H if they will sell the DVD now that the event is over.

    #796312
    shein
    Member

    What’s the difference if it’s on CD or DVD?

    #796313
    ☕️coffee addict
    Participant

    cd you can’t view the speakers just listen to them

    #796314
    shein
    Member

    Oh, so they sold the full audio on CD at today’s presentation? How much did it cost? And how much did the presentation cost to attend in person?

    And what was shown at the presentation? Any historical video footage? Who spoke? And what were the subjects being discussed?

    #796315
    am yisrael chai
    Participant

    A- Harav Aron Leib Shteinman, Harav Shmuel Kaminetsky, Harav Gamliel Rabinowitz, Harav Yaakov Hillel, Harav Yissocher Frand

    B- Harav Yaakov Hillel, R Yitzchok Berkowitz, R Eli Mansour, Dr David Lieberman

    Peace, resolving machlokes

    #796316
    Getzel
    Participant

    if they were to sell the DVDs they would stand to lose tons of $$$ from ppl coming to watch it.

    one thing i don’t understand is the singing, who needs music on Tisha b’av the rabbonim prohibit acapella so why do they put it on the dvd?

    #796317
    shein
    Member

    They wouldn’t lose any money if they now sell the DVD, since Tisha B’Av is over and no one else will be paying to watch it in person.

    BTW, how much did the audio-only CD cost today? And how much did the presentation cost to attend in person?

    Which DVD has acapella music?

    #796318
    kapusta
    Participant

    one thing i don’t understand is the singing, who needs music on Tisha b’av the rabbonim prohibit acapella so why do they put it on the dvd?

    I didn’t see it but I guess it was just voices…? They probably asked a shaila (in previous years), but to answer your question, music (or singing) has a certain power and can touch a person in a different way than just talking would.

    *kapusta*

    #796319
    YW Moderator-42
    Moderator

    I didn’t see it this year but I remember the music from previous years being very moving. Gets you into the spirit of the day. Music in the 3 weeks is only assur if it live or gets you to dance, although many of us are machmir and won’t listen to any music during the 3 weeks there are poskim who even mattir any acapela or recorded music so certainly moving acapela should be fine in this situation. Like kapusta said, I assume they asked a shaila.

    #796320
    inspiredteen
    Member

    From what I understood about accapella during the 3 weeks is that there is a problem with the ones that don’t sound like accapella – anyone who has heard it know what I am talking about.

    The acappella the the CCHF uses is what is considered ok. It is clearly just voices and they aren’t heavily computerized.

    And like kapusta and Mod-42 said – I am sure that they asked a shaila.

    #796321
    Another name
    Participant

    The music they was very powerful and moving. Many were brought to tears by my shul. In this case, the music helped accomplish the purpose of the video, if it drew people to be inspired.

    #796322
    Getzel
    Participant

    The music they was very powerful and moving. Many were brought to tears by my shul. In this case, the music helped accomplish the purpose of the video, if it drew people to be inspired.

    I believe that w/o asking a shaila the above reasoning is not enough, we can not decide what we may and what we may not. i hope they did ask a shaila

    #796323
    shein
    Member

    am yisrael chai: Did your contact at the CCHF advise you yet if the DVD will be made available?

    #796324
    cherrybim
    Participant

    am yisrael chai: Correction. R Yitzchok Berkowitz and R Eli Mansour are Harav Yitzchok Berkowitz and Harav Eli Mansour.

Viewing 37 posts - 1 through 37 (of 37 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.