- This topic has 14 replies, 6 voices, and was last updated 11 years, 11 months ago by .
-
Posts
-
In the 3rd Bais Hamikdash, will there be Chanuka?
If so, how could they light 8 lights on the 7-branched Menorah?
If so, how could they light 8 lights on the 7-branched Menorah?
Why should it matter? The menorah in the BhM had nothing to do with Channukah. It was lit every day.
If Channukah is to be commemorated in the times of the third BhM, we will probably lit menorah in our homes, just as we do now.
The Wolf
torah613613torah
You can ask the question better, what did they do the year after chanukah?
I think the Menorahs that chazal instituted for pirsumei nissah of chanukah were only in (front of) peoples homes. However in the mikdash which is not a private residence, they only light the regular 7 branch menorah.
The Wolf: But wasn’t the mitzva in every home? And isn’t the BHMK our home?
No. We don’t live in the BhM (as a residence).
The Wolf
T613, they didn’t use the 7 branched Menorah to commemorate Chanukah. The Menorah was lit fully, each day, as a separate service of the Kohanim, and it has nothing to do with Chanukah. If there was any need to light a “Chanukiah” (8 branched menorah) in the BHM for Chanukah, like we do at shul, they would not have used the seven branched golden Menorah.
Yesterday’s Haftoro of “Roni vSimchi Bas Zion” is generally taken to be referring to the 3rd Bais-haMikdosh, in light of the fact that the prophesies being prophesied by Zechariah did not transpire during the 2nd Bais haMikdosh, so refer to Haftoro of Neiros Zechariah to answer you queries about Chanukah at the 3rd Bais haMikdosh.
T613, correct – they had enough oil for the 7 branched Menorah to last for a single day, but it lasted for 8 days. Thus, a flask which was supposed to fill 7 heads of the lamp filled 56 heads of the lamp. I am unsure when we historically started celebrating Chanukah, but I presume since it was to celebrate the miracle of winning the war, that it started the year immediately after the war was won – on the 25th of Kislev.
L’shana acheres kav’um va’asaum yomim tovim b’halel v’hoda’ah. – Shabbos 21b
torah613613torah
147 – that’s interesting, but I personally found the haftorah hard to understand.
Rav Berel Wein shlita has a tape on the Haftoro of Beha’aloscho A.K.A. Chanukah.
Curiosity I am unsure when we historically started celebrating Chanukah,
The Nes occcured either in 165BCE or 164BCE.
You are very welcome 🙂
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.