Home › Forums › Decaffeinated Coffee › anyone else been to OWS
- This topic has 28 replies, 9 voices, and was last updated 13 years, 1 month ago by soliek.
-
AuthorPosts
-
November 13, 2011 5:50 am at 5:50 am #600489soliekMember
soliek i just came back from OWS ad i gotta say…it was an eye opener…not at all what i expected. i was pleasantly surprised and found myself agreeing with a lot of what people had to say
November 13, 2011 7:11 pm at 7:11 pm #827291soliekMemberno one…seriously…i mean its not like you people have anything better to do 😛
November 13, 2011 11:48 pm at 11:48 pm #827292yentingyentaParticipantsoliek, i kinda have 1 opinion on OWS. as long as they dont mess up public transportation in NJ and NY, i could not care less what they do. seriously. IMHO until they get their act together and say what they want and not a mess of ppl in a park and formally announce how they plan to change the financial market, all they are is a group of ppl living in a park making a whole lotta noise.
November 14, 2011 7:45 am at 7:45 am #827293soliekMemberno its actually quite a bit more than that. after going down there and talking to some of the protesters my opinions on why theyre there have changed. as i see it occupy wall street is essentially a public forum where people can come and exchange ideas. theres even an open stage where anyone who wants can speak their mind to whoever will listen. you need to actually go there and talk to people to undersatnd their objectives…
while its true that they have no single idea behind which they all unite, the general talking points, as far as i can tell, are basically ending massive government regulation of what should be a self regulating free market, and ending corporate influence of politicians through massive campaign contributions. the logistics of exactly how to go about both varies from person to person, but i must say i came across quite a few intelligent people with some very interesting ideas.
as they say…dont knock it till you try it. oh and the best part is? OWS is completely nonpartisan! i found that to be very refreshing.
also i think OWS is completely misrepresented by the press and politicians in general. i mean to hear the press describe them, on either side, theyre basically a mindless violent rabble comprised of idiots and rabble rousers who want to take over the city…and thats just not true at all. also, after speaking to a bunch of them, (and i intend to go back this motzaei shabbos) i get the feeling that theyre annoyed by both sides of the aisle using their movement for political advantage.
for example, on friday hannity interviewed michelle bachmann who, when asked about ows, essentially called them a bunch of socialist idiots. with a few eexceptions, i did not see anyone at OWS looking for government handouts. to the contrary, many of them are vehemently opposed to socialism! or on the democrat side, when democrat politicians tout OWS as a reason to increase social programs…theyre missing the point completely.
in fact…the one name that kept coming up over the course of virtually every conversation…was Ron Paul! in their opinion, ron paul comes closest to matching their ideals than any other candidate. that should tell you something about the movement. theres also a lot of talk about feeling misrepresented by either party…and the desire to form a third party if only our governmental system allowed for it. (to preempt…it technically does…but realistically speaking a third party would never win a national election.)
soliekyea…if youre actually curious about what they have to say…take a motzaei shabbos…theyre getting longer…and go down there to talk to some people. i think youll find it to be an interesting and enjoyable experience.
November 14, 2011 8:00 pm at 8:00 pm #827294bptParticipantYes, I saw it. What shocked me was how so few people (maybe 300) could so totally overtake the national attention.
I doubt they will accomplish anything concrete in the end, but it does show how new media (facebook, twitter, blogs) can make a movement out of anything.
But I can tell you, Century 21 is LOVING this, as every tourist in NYC heads downtown, and C21 is right around the block.
November 14, 2011 9:18 pm at 9:18 pm #827295TheGoqParticipantYou should absolutely not go down there its a major sakana.
November 14, 2011 10:53 pm at 10:53 pm #827296yentingyentaParticipantso basically, they want complete laissez-faire with NO govt control as well as big name corps can not contribute to gov affairs and funds?
i dont follow politics much but ron paul is not a name i have heard a whole lot as apposed to gingrich, romney, cain etc. is paul tea party? even thought the media is misconstruing the thoe whole OWS matzev, thats the only side majority of the ppl are hearing and seeing. one point i have to add, a teacher mentioned they use the terms 1% and 99%. she pointed out that its much easier to classifier one self into this rather than upper lower class, lower middle class, middle working class etc. in this way, e/o knows which part they belong to.
while you were there, what was the average age and level of ed? the media says they are all college aged students. this true? and what is there stand on obama and his policies? even though i may not really care about their movement, i’m still interested in it. that make sense?
November 15, 2011 12:17 am at 12:17 am #827297soliekMembergoq…no. it really isnt.
and no not complete laissez faire…they ARE realistic, but definitely more than we now have. about corporations not being able to contribute they mean corporations as an entity. if an individual wants to donate personally they are more than welcome to, however many people there are for donation caps.
also OWS has evolved since it began. the undercurrent of class warfare present at the outset is no longer there, or so i think. the main issue now, as far as i can tell, is corporate influence on the vox populi as it were.
about obamas policies…like i said…theyre not for either side right now. conservative or liberal. both sides, in their opinion, are missing the point. both sides are still open to corporate influence and as such, as far as they are concerned, are not acting in the best interests of the people.
average age WAS college age and a bit above, but the most vocal protesters were all middle aged or in their late thirties and over. level of education varies, but again, the most vocal are usually the most educated. there are of course exceptions like the two unfortunate loons i had the misfortune of encountering…but everyone else i spoke to seemed well educated, well informed, and quite passionate.
oh and its funny you should mention ron paul and the tea party…ron paul essentially started the tea party. look it up 🙂
November 15, 2011 1:02 am at 1:02 am #827298artchillParticipantThe Occupy Chicago chevra are complete loons. It reminds me of the medrashim on NOach describing the building of the Tower of Bavel. No two people share the same agenda. Some are for welfare not warfare, others are protesting to arrest the mayor for red light ticket greed, others are asking who the other 99% are, etc. It’s a riot watching these sophisticated individuals seeking to change the dynamics! Kookoo!
November 15, 2011 1:12 am at 1:12 am #827299yentingyentaParticipant“is corporate influence on the vox populi as it were”
i’m trying to understand so don’t be offended. when you say corporate influence, are you referring to companies who donate big bucks to a presidential campaign and then get favors from the gov? (didnt the VP or s/o have a green energy co. go bankrupt recently?)
while free commerce seems like a good idea, certain categories SHOULD be monitored. one, FDA. drugs need to be monitored continuously as new side effects only become known once the drug is in the general population. two, the USDA. no brainer meat that has found to have been contaminated should be recalled. those are 2 off the top of my head. they might not be perfect but imagine if no one found the increased risk of MI associated with Vioxx?
what do they think of cains 9 9 9 plan? is that one still the best plan out there or did he lose support b/c of the allegations against him?
sorry if i’m asking too many questions. this whole OWS is fascinating. wonder where its going to lead. how are the other occupy movements doing?
November 15, 2011 2:16 am at 2:16 am #827300apushatayidParticipantIt is tough to say there is any unified message coming out of zucotti park. Anyone and everyone has something they don’t like and an agenda they wish to push. Occassionally the agendas overlap and those people hang out together for a bit. I don’t mean to be cynical, but if Citigroup, BoA, Chase or any other financial institution showed up and announced they were hiring most of the OWS protesters would line up resume in hand.
November 15, 2011 3:15 am at 3:15 am #827301soliekMemberas well they should if afforded that opportunity…i dont see how the two conflict.
“Occassionally the agendas overlap and those people hang out together for a bit.”
thats a fair assessment…im just saying that these two agendais specifically seem to overlap overwhelmingly as opposed to others
“i’m trying to understand so don’t be offended. when you say corporate influence, are you referring to companies who donate big bucks to a presidential campaign and then get favors from the gov?”
yeah i knew that was coming…there are certain things which should be bought and sold and certain things which should not. elections is one…court cases is another…you see my point.
“while free commerce seems like a good idea, certain categories SHOULD be monitored. one, FDA. drugs need to be monitored continuously as new side effects only become known once the drug is in the general population. two, the USDA. no brainer meat that has found to have been contaminated should be recalled. those are 2 off the top of my head. they might not be perfect but imagine if no one found the increased risk of MI associated with Vioxx?”
and youre absolutely right. i dont think anyone would disagree with you. there is a time and a place for everything
“what do they think of cains 9 9 9 plan? is that one still the best plan out there or did he lose support b/c of the allegations against him?”
9 9 9 is a ridiculous plan. first lets examine the first 2 9s. a 9 percent income tax and a 9 percent consumption tax. thats an 18% tax on every dollar you earn regardless of how much you earn. next you have a 9 percent tax on all business transactions….which of course will be passed along to the consumer as all corporate taxes are. so thats…lets say…22 percent of every dollar regardless of earnings going to the government. 9 9 9 doesnt account for local and state taxes. so lets say new york feels it isnt getting enough federal money for project X and decides to raise property taxes to fund it. or raise the state sales tax. or teh state income tax. see what im getting at?
November 15, 2011 3:34 am at 3:34 am #827302yentingyentaParticipantAlthough the numbers seem like alot, would this tax system be across the board and not on a tiered system (isn’t that what what the system is now?) OWS is fighting economic unfairness right? does that include all the tax breaks the “1%” get? but I totally get what your saying about the taxes. It seems like the taxes would be separate entaties of state and federal which would Only increase the taxes we are already paying.
What are the ideas of OWS and the other candidates regarding the economy?
And btw soliek your doing a great job explaining. Thanx
November 15, 2011 4:29 am at 4:29 am #827303soliekMemberto be honest i didnt spend enough time there to get an idea of what general sentiment is concerning tax and economic policy…so i cant answer that question yet. i do plan on going back this week though so ill post more when i know more
November 15, 2011 5:21 am at 5:21 am #827304TheGoqParticipantI don’t understand why you would voluntarily spend time at a place which is known to have criminally minded people who do not live in a healthy environment.
November 15, 2011 8:56 am at 8:56 am #827305soliekMemberwhat makes you say theyre criminally minded?
November 15, 2011 10:28 am at 10:28 am #827306yentingyentaParticipantSoliek: I have to agree with goq. I don’t know what OWS holds on violence, but there has been reports of violence in the park. Attacking an FDNY EMT is not exactly a peaceful action. It’s not exacly the safest place to be at night if you are planning on going motzie shabbos.
Also, I just looked on the ywn home page. Top report was a raid on the park. One thing that stood out was a line that said something like the protest has deteriorated from a peaceful protest to a backdrop for crime and violence. Curious to see what comes out of this if the whole occupy movement will continue as is or will change direction. Is this the first time OWS in the city was kicked off the park?
November 15, 2011 1:08 pm at 1:08 pm #827307happiestMemberUmmmm, none of them looking for govt handouts? If this is true, why don’t they go and FIND or even LOOK for work?!?! Until they do that, I have 0 and I mean 0 pity on all of them!! (and this is very very not my type. I feel bad for almost anyone which is not a good thing either!)
As for the Ron Paul thing, of course they like Ron Paul the best. He is the most liberal of the Republicans. He barely can be called a Republican.
Uch, I can’t believe someone would honestly waste their time and go down and speak with those people who are just making a mess of other peoples businesses. Oh, and they are SMALL businesses, nothing corporate about them. (all those businesses in Lower Manhattan that have said they have approximately lost over $400,000)
November 15, 2011 1:30 pm at 1:30 pm #827308TheGoqParticipantThey are breaking laws on a consistent basis.
November 15, 2011 1:50 pm at 1:50 pm #827309soliekMemberwelp…there goes that then…right along with my motzaei shabbos plans…%$#@ you bloomberg! 😀
November 15, 2011 2:05 pm at 2:05 pm #827310TheGoqParticipantNovember 15, 2011 2:36 pm at 2:36 pm #827311soliekMemberif you read further youll see he calls them an unfortunate minority. the only crime i saw there was weed smokage and i hardly think that matters…
November 15, 2011 2:45 pm at 2:45 pm #827312BTGuyParticipantWhile the OWSers are exploiting some good points, they are not victims of the economy at all. Yes, some genuine working people having difficulty have joined their ranks, but I suspect they are paid protesters here to create a classic scapegoat (Jews in the financial world), in order to deflect from Obama’s miserable failure as a president. Job creation was the constant promise of Obama.
Wall Street certainly can be criticized, which is why this conspiracy is a very clever tactic to help re-elect Obama and keep him looking like a man of the people.
Americans are way too fickle and politicians know fake perception can easily become reality.
The plutocracy changed the world since Bush was in office. Bush and Obama are the same two-headed monster. The rest of us are coasting by on the fumes of America’s past greatness.
The only good thing about all this out-of-control world situation is that it must mean Moshiach is soon on his way.
November 17, 2011 11:57 pm at 11:57 pm #827313☕️coffee addictParticipantBTGuy (and everyone else here)(possibly even soliek),
how do you feel about OWS having these anti-semitic and terrorist comments (Jews control Wall Street, molotov cocktails at Macy’s)
November 18, 2011 2:12 am at 2:12 am #827314yentingyentaParticipantHHHHMmmmm good question CA. i’ve been busy all week (clinicals, test lecture etc) but from what i’ve scanned is the raid kinda backfired in that it incited those in the group more inclined to violence. i have to read the newest reports out there to get a better picture. but my opinion is still kinda the same: a bunch of ppl trying to change the world by making noise (literally) yet they have not given any substantial ideas.
anyone else?
November 18, 2011 2:07 pm at 2:07 pm #827315soliekMemberdefine substantial idea…i mean how does this differ from the senate or congress? some senator picks a cause…proposes an idea to his staff…the staff write the bill…he approves it and then it goes before both houses of congress. it starts as a kernel, just a “what if” and then it turns into a bill.
unfortunately citizens cant introduce legislation and i doubt congresspeople would be bothered to even review a citizen made bill…so “what ifs” is all we have as citizens. seriously…tell me…what do you expect from OWS…an alternate form of government? theyre a bunch of people with interesting ideas you cant possibly expect nor should you expect fully detailed pieces of legislation from them. you wouldnt expect it of yourself either.
“but my opinion is still kinda the same: a bunch of ppl trying to change the world by making noise”
BINGO! you finally understand OWS! see you make enough noise you get attention. you get attention you get people to talk to you. you get people to talk to you…and if what ypu have to say is convincing and makes sense…then you now have one more supporter. i cite myself as a perfect example.
idk if you get the impression from talking to me on the CR…my friends would be able to confirm this. i am not easily taken in by movements of any kind and it is very difficult to change my mind on an issue. you have to be really convincing to do that. the fact that i support OWS should stand testament to their validity, for whatever its worth.
“but from what i’ve scanned is the raid kinda backfired in that it incited those in the group more inclined to violence.”
that is true…and it makes me very sad. i believe strongly in what the OWS people are doing, which is encouraging open discussion about the most important issues of the day, and the fat that what was always intended as a peaceful demonstration was hijacked by a bunch of hothead lunatics. that bloody kid will forever be the face of OWS and it is so tragic..after all they worked for…to have THAT represent them.
“how do you feel about OWS having these anti-semitic and terrorist comments (Jews control Wall Street, molotov cocktails at Macy’s)”
it hurts me as a person and it hurts me as a jew. however im not blaming OWS for that. i ws called a slave trader and a greedy jew at OWS by one nut. i saw NO anti semitic signs, i was treated respectfully by everyone else i encountered, and i met quite a few jewish occupiers. i do not, in ANY way, hold OWS responsible for any of the racism or vandalism that has resulted from the movement, much in the same way i dont hold Martin Luther King Jr responsible for any unintended violence or racism that resulted from his movement. there is always a fringe of every group which feels that violence and hate is the only answer and to hold the movements which they exploit responsible would be a terrible victory for that fringe.
“Wall Street certainly can be criticized, which is why this conspiracy is a very clever tactic to help re-elect Obama and keep him looking like a man of the people.”
OWS, and i say this based on the people i spoke to, does not support either side. it is completely non partisan because neither side is satisfying their claims.
“The rest of us are coasting by on the fumes of America’s past greatness.”
very true.
November 18, 2011 2:34 pm at 2:34 pm #827316yentingyentaParticipanti was thinking substantial idea as one that the media/govt sees and likes. one that has the potential to work for the economy. and when i said a group making noise, i meant it in a negative way even it IS what the group is in essence.
and the new image of OWS, not really surprised. i think its common for peaceful groups to attract unruly people which then escalates to violence. it is unfortunate that it happened here too that what started as a meeting place for reform now has a picture of violence attached to it.
based on the reports i read this morning, they seem to be losing media support. guliani said he would of closed them down from day 1, and IIRC wasnt a councilman or s/o arrested there? and even their plan to cripple wall street with tens of thousands of protesters and block the bridge and disrupt subways….. didnt work. how many ppl showed up for the protest? if they come up with an idea that is workable, it might help them regain some positive media coverage.
as a side note, besides ron paul, any other politicians support them?
November 18, 2011 3:04 pm at 3:04 pm #827317BTGuyParticipantHi coffee addict. At the root of this is anti-semitism. I believe this movement is funded by Soros as a counter to the Tea Party and to distance his stooge, Obama, from the problems he has created and exacerbated from since he took office.
The fact that anti-semitism is in the mix to a good degree is just a sign of their fingerprint. Remember, the overt anti-Jewish and anti-Israel stance in the American political arena has become pronounced in the Obama administration. The others kept it covert.
Incidentally, this is classic anti-semitism. Their Wall St thing is really a way of saying the Jews are to blame, and their ranks have pretty much gone on record with stating that.
November 18, 2011 3:25 pm at 3:25 pm #827318soliekMember“based on the reports i read this morning, they seem to be losing media support.”
they never had media support…
“guliani said he would of closed them down from day 1,”
bold words coming from a former mayor…but bloomberg was against it from day one as well he just couldnt do anything about it
“and IIRC wasnt a councilman or s/o arrested there?”
a great stunt to ensure his re-election
“if they come up with an idea that is workable, it might help them regain some positive media coverage.”
occupying zuccotti park WAS the good and workable idea…but they were evicted so there goes that…
“as a side note, besides ron paul, any other politicians support them?”
no but is political support ever a good thing? 😛
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.