- This topic has 35 replies, 10 voices, and was last updated 5 years, 11 months ago by .
-
Posts
-
Would you rather speak only in poems, or only be able to speak sentences that have already been said?
Speaking in poems sounds nice, but it will probably come out creepy, in a “Cat in the Hat” kind of way. Pretty sure most of what I want to say has been said already, but it would be difficult in certain very specific situations such as referring to people by their full name.
Speaking in poems would be more fun. Although it would definitely get tiring by like day 2.
Poems. Always, always the poems. You could go from Hallmark banality all the way to Beowulf… sonnets, songs, Psalms, Song of Solomon, Haiku, the possibilities are endless as opposed to repeating that which has already been said.
Would you rather have your filter block CR or stick hot needles in your eyes?
You’re being offered 1 million $$$ with the caveat that one or more of your precious memories will be deleted from your mind forever. Would you take it, or rather refuse and hold on to the memory for life??
Ziongate
I would take the money and make new memories
Well…
If the hot needles could do something about cataracts, glaucoma or the clearing out of the sinuses then most def the hot needles over the filter. I think I would still take the hot needles if in exchange for access to CR they also blinded me to ugliness, greed and debauchery
I would keep my memories intact and go out and make my own million dollars if I needed it that badly.
The question of the million dollars of course sets off an entire cascade of further thought and consideration..
I’m fairly simple. I have my family, friends, a house to live in, food to eat, clothes to wear. I have my faith and life and breath in my body. I’m happy and content. Try not to get carried away by my breathtaking saintliness… I can also be foot stampingly stubborn and impatient..
What if the million dollars came with a guarantee that among the many things a person could buy with a million dollars it could also buy the return of a precious memory to someone who had lost all of their’s through neurological illness, head injury or trauma? You have no control over the beneficiary of the returned memory other than that you must first sacrifice one of your own. Do you do it?would you rather sour cream or applesauce on your latkes?
Applesauce! Applesauce!! Applesauce!!! APPLESAUCE!!!!!!!!!!!
**stated vehemently with foot stampingly stubbornness and impatience**
The answer about memories or a million dollars is not that simple. When a person reaches a ripe old age, he has much to thank Hashem which no one else can fulfil only himself. This is why the chazal had us say Modim Derabonon and it is not enough the Modim of the Baal Tefila . It says מה אשיב לה’ כל תגמלהי עלי that responsibility rests on me and no one else can fulfil it. Those memories are precious and for no price are you willing to sell it.
Laskern,
I don’t follow (maybe because I don’t have such a good memory
If you have nothing better to do than musing on such trivialities, go to a shiur, or say some Tehilim. Don’t waste your EMPTY MIND on figuring out “Devarim shel ma b’kach!”
coffee addict, maybe you don’t understand me because you don’t want to. It has nothing to do with your memory but your mind.
coffee addict, memories remind us of all the good that Hashem Yisborach has bestowed on all of us through out our life from birth to the present.
laskern,
I think coffee addict’s kidding with “memory ”
You make an excellent point. Precious memories are gifts from Hashem to last a lifetime even one ch”v loses material things. They enrich a life and I regurgitate them in my mind all the time , and they make me happy. No one has a guarantee for a tomorrow when new memories can be made. Even if yes, new memories do not replace the old , and are not meant to.
There are precious moments in a life, even if they be for a couple of seconds, but stay in the mind forever.
No, keep the millon, I savor my jewels, those precious priceless memories.Laskern,
I still don’t follow
If I had a million dollars in place of forgetting my wedding day I would just make a new wedding
Coffee addict,
You ain’t makin’ no new wedding…. and you ain’t forgetting anything.. How long you married??
Your current wife be putting her hands on that million befire you can chant a harei att with a new one…
Trying to slip that mil in your pocket past her, is like trying to slip a sunrise past a rooster…
Your wife is like mine and everybody else’s… Happy Chanukah..Thank you ZionGate you expressed my sentiments very eloquently. coffee gate stop kidding and destroying something precious.
coffee adict, what are you going to do with memories you cannot recreate because the individual is not here anymore or you were saved from illness or from other tragegy?
RebYidd,
Not 1 precious memory ?
A precious memory is like a duck…. if it quacks, walks, feels like it, it’s precious. It’s very easy to know.
Bad memories?? I think WE will pay to wipe them out.Sorry to interrupt the memory one but I have another one. This one is for baseball fans. Game 7 of the world series and your favorite team is in it. Would you rather not have any means of following the game and yet at the same time know that your team will have an automatic win, or go to the game with your friends not necessarily knowing what the outcome will be?
To add to my previous post I think my memories wouldn’t change my future (and my present too) which I feel is what matters in life
The past is gone therefore unchangeable the present or future can be changed
Take the birth of my oldest, I fed him first with him looking up at me with those baby eyes, how does that affect my life right now? It doesn’t! Do I love him any more than my other son who I didn’t feed first? No! So this good memory has no bearing on my present life whatsoever
Zgate & laskern,
I guess you don’t know my life
And I guess you don’t know my wife
You don’t know how I was brought up
And you don’t know what memories are in my kup(Oh dear, rebyidd’s op has been fulfilled in me
1) my posts were switched
2) it doesn’t show that I posted on the main Cr page
coffee addict, you missed the whole point. First you must be young so you don’t have too many memories, second nothing extra ordinary happened to you and third you are taking everything that happened to you for granted believing that all of it you deserve.
Laskern,
How do you see that?
coffee addict, from your posts it looks like that you don’t seem to appreciate your memories.
So how does that show that I think I deserve everything that happens to me
In the Megilla, Achashverus appreciated favors done to him and therefore created the book of memories, recognizing that memories are precious to be able to show appreciation and thereby Mordechai was elevated.
coffee addict, what Hashem Yisborach does to us is more appreciated accumutavely, from birth to the present as I posted above, and that can only be done by keeping our precious memories intact.
I see
Like the Haggadah it’s a סיפור & זכירה which we say דיינו in appreciation for everything that is done
Would you rather living in society but without the CR or being stuck on a deserted island with internet access only to the CR
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.