DaasYochid: So now you want to argue that they SHOULD have specified that they don’t accept him? Why? The Rabbanut isn’t accepting him anyway. There was no reason to, and as I said, the RCA said many times that they don’t accept him.
PBA: Not accepting his geirus is the point. That wasn’t the “other things” that were being dragged into it. Because of the Avi Weiss thing, they brought in the question of which groups in the US are “frum” enough for them to accept. The RCA said this shouldn’t be a part of the Avi Weiss thing, and it’s something that can be discussed separately.