Reply To: Very Interesting! The Reason Why We Eat Jelly Donuts On Chanukah

Home Forums Yom Tov Chanukah Very Interesting! The Reason Why We Eat Jelly Donuts On Chanukah Reply To: Very Interesting! The Reason Why We Eat Jelly Donuts On Chanukah

#990792
BP Zaideh
Member

I asked Horav Peretz Moncharsh of Revach.net

Why didn’t you bring the Eitzah of the Chayeh Adam Klal 43:9 (quoted in Biur Hahalcha) to be Mekaven at Hamotzee for these mezonos deserts?

Horav Peretz Moncharsh’s Answer:

A good point. However the logic of the Chaye Adam is that explicit intention on the donut is equivalent to saying hamotzi directly on the donut. This works because if one said hamotzi on something that is mezonos he is yotzei b’dieved. I prefer to suggest a solution that works l’chatchila when available.

I am impressed

This answer can also be viewed at:

http://revach.net/ask/article.php?id=1987