City budget data shows that Jewish affiliated nonprofits have far outpaced their religious counterparts in bringing home taxpayer dough.
Jewish groups secured $4.26 million from City Council members in the 2012 budget, far more than Catholic groups, which will take home $517,250, and Islamic/Muslim groups, which secured $19,000.
The numbers reflect a million-dollar bump for Jewish groups, compared to this year’s budget, and a dip of $50,000 for Catholic groups.
The council distributes $50 million in so-called “member items” to nonprofit organizations citywide, and a recent report by Manhattan Borough President Scott Stringer said favoritism is endemic in the flawed system.
Among groups with a religious affiliation, the biggest beneficiary in the funding free-for-all is the politically connected Metropolitan Council on Jewish Poverty, which is taking home $1.4 million — more than Episcopal, Lutheran, Baptist, Presbyterian, and Pentecostal groups combined. The Met Council’s CEO, William Rapfogel, is a longtime friend of Assembly Speaker Shelly Silver, and his wife, Judy Rapfogel, is Silver’s chief of staff.
* In some cases, the cash supplements extant city services. The civilian patrol groups Shomrim and Shmira will take home $131, 875.
* Chaverim, whose volunteers help those locked out of their cars or homes, are getting $35,000.
* The New York Board of Rabbis and a rabbinical seminary will get $51,000. The Council of African Imams: $5,000.
* $122,500 will go to the powerful Bobov Hasidic sect, money that will go to help members struggling with medical bills and other services.
Estimates vary, but according to 2008 data from the Association of Religious Data Archives, Catholics, at 62%, make up the bulk of the city’s population, followed by Jews at about 22%, Protestants at 10.7% and Muslims 3.5%.
Join the official YWN WhatsApp status
5 Responses
Shechitah in Europe. Milah in California. Rubashkin. The “birthday Rabbi.” Discretionary funding for non-profits. Wake up guys. Choose to be different and be left alone, or desire and yearn to be like all the rest and be picked out of the crowd.
The title for this article in the NY Post is scary…
Great! so here we have the full circle of Chilul Hashem on both ends: First, the silance on same-gender marriage because we have more important things at stake, which is – making another Chilul Hashem by breaking the city bank
There is a process called writing and applying for grants. If you feel you are entitled get a good grant writer and there might be some money in it for you. What i believe would be fair is that receipts for all expenditures of these monies be inspected to rule out any fraud and of coarse chilul Hashem.
Jews have needs/drives very different from the needs of these other groups; they don’t have a chaveirim, Hatzalah, Misaskim, Shomrim. What community groups they DO have are probably much smaller in numbers per capita than any of these other communities. Jews vote to express these needs and their thanks to those who help them attain them. Where is the chillul HaShem? We only ask and we ask to benefit real, above-board, helpful, productive non-profits. If the politicians choose to give these organizations based on community needs or even for their personal gain, where is the chilul HaShem?