Reply To: At what point are you officially one side or the other?

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee At what point are you officially one side or the other? Reply To: At what point are you officially one side or the other?

#983464
HaKatan
Participant

Charlie:

Regarding MO and Kollel:

No, MO is not following the traditional view in secular studies.

In fact, it is the traditionally Orthodox Jews who follow the traditional practice. And the Chassidim, too, have a tremendous amount of workers, regardless of what degrees they may or may not have pursued.

Whatever secular studies were studied historically are not comparable to MO’s elevation of secular studies to “Torah uMaddah”. Traditionally Orthodox Jews, on the other hand, do attend college and obtain various degrees, including advanced degrees. Yet they do so for the proper reason (parnassah) and with the proper balance (Torah is holy and the rest, lihavdil, including Maddah, is merely utilitarian), not via MO’s taking away from the Torah to elevate Maddah.

Again, MO is not the traditional way, much as they wish they were.