Reply To: Chayiv Misah as applied Halacha?

Home Forums Controversial Topics Chayiv Misah as applied Halacha? Reply To: Chayiv Misah as applied Halacha?

#982328
Avram in MD
Participant

gavra_at_work,

I don’t buy the “He was not normal” argument.

I have not read much about the incident, but the details I have read seem to point towards mental instability. That steeping in the seething nastiness of the Israeli political climate may have provided a focus or justification for his actions in his mind is a good question. Where a “normal” but misguided person may vilify, an unstable person may act violently. He probably did view himself as upholding some sort of religious honor, but I don’t think his thought processes were rational as you suggest with your question.