Reply To: A ???? Shailah

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee A ???? Shailah Reply To: A ???? Shailah

#969270
BSD
Member

Haleivi-“Your tongue is in your mouth for over 24 hours.”

Tongue in mouth=ok

Foot in mouth=problem

All seriousness aside, I was wondering if your choice of gid hanashah is actually a problem because I was klerring what is the reasoning behind batul bishishim-is it that the ta’am is diluted or is it that the apposing ta’am overpowers it? If it’s the former, than your gid hanasheh example holds muster, if it’s the latter then it would remain treif despite having shishim. This must be am haaratsus though because according to my reasoning if tarfus falls into water it cannot become batul, unless you say water has ta’am. In NJ it does. Anyway I haven’t leaned this in well over a decade since leaving kollell so please forgive me-I’m just having some fun.