Reply To: Would you ever withhold a ???

Sam:

1. Also, you can’t have a child from mishkav zachar.

2. A man can still care deeply about Halachah and say, “I can’t live life alone, I’ll violate a Cherem so I can keep all 613 Mitzvos.”

No, we aren’t arguing. I’m talking about someone who keeps halacha; not about someone who “cares deeply about halacha.” For someone who keeps halacha, and will continue to keep halacha, it makes no difference at all whether it is a cherem or a minhag or anything.