Reply To: Satmer

Home Forums Controversial Topics Satmer Reply To: Satmer

#961572
HaKatan
Participant

rationalfrummie:

You aren’t being very rational, and you are presenting emotional sevaras that have no intellectual basis. Your implication is that the proliferation of Torah in E”Y means that Zionism is ergo correct. So, by that logic, why was Hitler so successful if he was wrong, and he obviously was? The simple answer is that one (proliferation of Torah) has nothing to do with, lihavdil, the other (Zionism).

As Rav Elchonon said, it is certain. Your questions, again, are not questions.

That Hashem has spared His children, that Hashem has spared many Jews in Israel’s wars is also, obviously, not a raayah to Zionism. Of course, B”H, Hashem has rachmanus on His children.

Regarding the desert blooming, this also does not speak about Zionism, only about Jews in Eretz Yisrael; Jews do, of course, live in Eretz Yisrael.

It’s best to learn (outside of Zionist sources) first before ridiculously accusing people of calling neviim, CH”V, apikorsim.