mosherose:
“How dare you call a minhag that yidden have observed for thousands of years “pointless”?”
If this is regarding my statement made previously,if you are using quotes, please quote accurately (all you need to do is copy and paste).
Please bring proof that shtar mechilah is something we have been doing “for thousands of years”. I believe, as I stated previously, that this concept of this shtar is something new that was never done previously, and I will stand by words unless proven otherwise.
The statement and quote by mosherose was clearly in response to Wolf, quoted exactly, and was regarding tanaaim not shtar mechilah.