Logician –
Many if not most (if not all) of the issues that divide the kofer and the ma’amin are in the realm of logic. They may not have been proven or disproven with logic, but one can imagine that theoretically an argument might exist that can logically prove or disprove any of these issues. My point here has been about the justifiability of the claim that one not read a book or listen to an opinion that may or may not contain such a logical argument. Thus I believe my argument is relevant.
Therefore something which would contradict that – i.e. imply that He is something He cannot be – is a logical contradiction.
Please cite an actual example of this, where I cannot fall back on the simple but logically viable answer that God’s existence is unfathomable by its very definition.