Reply To: Afikomen Tnai

A possible suggestion to the question of ?? ????? ????? ??????? ???? ????? may lie in the explanation to the reason why there is no ?????? by ????? – why is it different to anything where we say ???? ?? ??? ??????

The ??? ??? asks this in ??????? ?? ??. The ????”? (I think ?? ???) explains that essentially there is ?????? even by a ????. But ?????? can only help to tell you that the ???? of the ???? can be attributed to the ????, but the ????s body is not the ????s body.

Therefore, if the ???? puts on ??????, the ???? of ?????? laid on the ????s hand can be attributed to the ????, so it is as if the ???? placed ?????? on the ???? — which won’t help him be ????? his ????.

?????? WOULD work, if for example, the ???? puts the ?????? on the ????s hand (for example if the ???? is disabled and cannot do it himself), then it will be ?????? to the ???? that ?????? was put on HIS hand, and he would be ????? his ????.

So – ????? – Afikoman is ???? ???????; just ?????? doesn’t help to be ????? the ????.