Reply To: Stuffing Your Face w/ Marror, Red as a Tomato

DY: It is no more Gaavadik than those who think that what our ancestors did wasn’t good enough and try to add on or change the Halachah in the other direction. I don’t think Rav Schachter is a Ba’al Ga’avah here. I think he honestly learned the Sugya and believes that one is not Yotzei with horseradish root (he also quoted the same well-known Talmid Chacham that Old Man quoted and said that Baruch Hashem each year more and more people listen and there is less horseradish being used in B’nei B’rak every year).