Reply To: Should Harassing Other Posters Be Allowed in the CR?

Does that include being disrespectful to people who you don’t agree with?

Of course.

What do you mean by harassing? If you mean a comment that does nothing but demean another poster, then adamant no.

Exactly.

Does it include voting other CR members ‘off the island’ because you disagree with them?

It isn’t because I disagree with her. It is because she posts comments which do nothing but demean another poster. And that is precisely what this thread is about.

I happen to agree with her; I like when people in good grammar. But I don’t go around making fun of them for not knowing good grammar, nor do I say that their opinions are useless if not conveyed in good grammar.

Note how I made a similar case a few years back, but phrased it as advice to the posters themselves on how make their comments accessible. I do it to help the posters themselves. http://www.theyeshivaworld.com/coffeeroom/topic/how-to-write-an-easily-readable-post