Reply To: Satmar Rav on rice

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Satmar Rav on rice Reply To: Satmar Rav on rice

#896711
HaLeiVi
Participant

Rashi does bring Arabic words, as well as German, Slavic and Russian.

Although finding a similar word in a different language is a good backup, it is not the be-all-end-all. Rashi gave a word because of what he was Mekabel or built from Raayos, not in a vacuum. Perhaps you can say that had he known of two languages with similar words that would have swayed his reasonning to translate it as such, but that’s it.

It is very likely that Rashi’s unclear

description may have come from the

simple fact that rice cultivation wasn’t

introduced into France until over 300

years after Rashi was nifter

Problem with that is that tosafos does say it means rice. Tosafos is not 300 years later.