Home › Forums › Eretz Yisroel › Are you a Zionist? › Reply To: Are you a Zionist?
Sam2 -“Health: Karka Einah Nigzeles. The Goyim never had the R’shus to become Ba’alim on it. (And even if you Pasken Yeish Kinyan L’AKU”M L’hafkia…, they still can’t actually own the land. Eretz Yisrael belongs to the Jews L’olam Va’ed.) Whether or not making a State was Assur, you can’t fix that by being Over on another Issur D’oraisa.”
So you just cleared it up yourself. Since we aren’t allowed to have a Gov. there and the Goyim can’t own the land -then we can give the Gov. to Turkey. So No “Lo Sechohname”! (Didn’t give them anything.)
“(I could also make the claim that this Issur is Yeihareg V’al Ya’avor because it’s related to Avodah Zarah and because the Passuk directly implies it, but I’m really not in the mood to discuss that at the moment.)”
If you did make such a claim -you’d be the first one I know to claim “Lo Sechohname” is an Abizreyhu D’avodah Zora!