Reply To: Giving A Year To R' Elyashiv

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Giving A Year To R' Elyashiv Reply To: Giving A Year To R' Elyashiv

#893045
WolfishMusings
Participant

Wolf: The Gemara’s S’vara for why you can’t kill someone even for Pikuach Nefesh. There are some cases where it really shouldn’t apply. What do you do then?

I still don’t get it. When does the rule of not killing an innocent (i.e. to exclude someone who *is* actively attacking someone) to save another life not apply?

The Wolf