Reply To: Dying Al Kiddush Hashem

His violent death provides a full or a partial kaporah for him.

if it’s a partial kaporah he/she should still get Gehenom, secondly why is that, there was no Teshuva?

If he doesn’t believe in the Torah, however he died it wasn’t Al Kiddush Hashem.

Choppy, do you have a mekor, besides one made up

If someone dies becuase they are Jewish, that means they have left an indelible marker in history that there was such a thing as a Jew.

this answer makes sense

Coffee addict, I thought Beit Din Shel Ma’ala made those decisions. Wrong again! Instead, “we” should take over from Beit Din Shel Ma’ala and rule against people who can no longer testify about what they ate, did on Shabbat, and believed or didn’t believe about the Torah — and on this basis bar them from olam haba.

Naftush, I’m not ruling out anything, I’m just saying it sounds like a goyish zach (getting olam haba for believing in Yoshko, or for what the Arabs do

Check sefer Vayikro and the death of Nodov Ve-avihu- inspite of the possuk saying they died because of ‘aish zoroh”, Moshe rabbeinu said’ :”Bikrovay ekodesh”. if it is good enough for Moshe rasbbeinu , it is good enough for me.

Nadav and Avihu weren’t living their life like a frei yid